The crisis of 2001 in Argentina and the social protest that erupted with it were not simply a call to restore the capacity of the state to secure economic growth and development but, more profoundly, a redefinition of social citizenship. According to Marina Sitrin, the social mobilisation that emerged on the eve of 2001 must be seen as ‘politics in a different way’ (p. 85). What is different, according to the author, is that expectations of social change became associated with alternative forms of organising protests through ‘horizontal’ collective action that escape traditional forms of control by the political parties, labour unions or the Peronist elite. These forms of collective action were manifested in the Movement of the Unemployed, factory takeovers, neighbour assemblies and street vendor movement, all of which were rooted in local community activism and the practice of ‘direct democracy’ (p. 8). It is a politics that not only refuses institutionalisation and hierarchical leadership but also imagines a new subjectivity. Sitrin explores how the new politics of social protests, demonstrations and resistance in post-crisis Argentina has been driven not by concerted efforts to construct an effective political liaison with existing political parties or unionised groups, but rather by the reclaiming of ‘neighbourhoods and the workplace’. Sitrin explores, in an accomplished manner, how in the context of a profound crisis of political legitimacy in Argentina, a new repertoire of social change and ‘social innovation’ emerged through the practice of solidarity, self-management and productive reorganisation.
The book offers a simple yet captivating narrative organised in eight chapters that cover three main defining features of post-crisis – and perhaps post-neoliberal – innovative models of social articulation: first, horizontality, denoting a form of organisation that rejects traditional forms of political delegation and hierarchy structuring political parties and labour unions (chapter 3); second, affective politics, namely the imaginary or subjectivities framing new repertoires of social change, belonging and identity politics (chapter 4); and, third, autonomy – that is, the capacity to reorganise and self-manage workplaces and engage with solidarity economies (chapters 5 and 6). These concepts are applied to new forms of social activism which, at odds with historical forms of protest, not only called into question the morality of neoliberal democracy but were also moved by a desire to recover the workplace and develop solidarity networks in order to provide services in the form of cooperatives and other communal ties. The breadth and scale of mobilisation, Sitrin argues, suggest an ambitious attempt to revitalise a different model of emancipatory politics in which workers and neighbours challenge capital and the legitimacy of the state as the place for democracy and inclusion.
While this book is a valuable contribution to the literature and practice of social movements, democracy and contentious politics outside state politics, the analysis is over-reliant on actor-oriented and oral history-led explanations. This poses at least three fundamental concerns.
The first relates to the transformative capacity of these movements. Horizontalism, as a category of analysis, captures ideas, subjectivities and affective politics embraced by new social movements in a context where the state, or traditional forms of political representation, offer no way out (pp. 7–8). However, while the movements analysed here have been highly significant, creating new repertoires of contention and resistance in Argentina's immediate post-crisis period, it is not clear how transformative as a social project they can be in times of normalisation. Furthermore, the extent to which horizontalism can consolidate a ‘meta narrative’ or ‘master frame’, paraphrasing Snow and Benford, of civic opposition and social change is left unexplored. These issues are of particular significance and need to be thought of in the light of current changes in the political economy of post-crisis Argentina, as resource boom growth, though not the only factor, has been highly consequential for contentious politics.
A second concern relates to the connections between horizontal movements, contentious politics and the state. New horizontal forms of social contention can and have survived: the recovered factories described in the closing chapters of the book are a case in point. But a theoretical speculation beyond politics of affection could have been offered to conceptualise how these movements relate to the state, beyond top-down forms of co-optation, which is the only politico-institutional dynamic considered in the book. Political and economic recovery after crisis means that horizontal movements are faced with the dilemma of how to adapt to changes in political structures that seem to narrow the available potential of opportunities to preserve self-management and direct democracy. What explains political resilience in horizontal movements? Institutionalisation may require sacrificing a degree of spontaneity, a characteristic that initially brings esteem to horizontal groups. But nurturing a new, self-conscious (worker's) identity within the larger labour movement is difficult to envisage. The analysis suggests that some movements are more susceptible than others to being absorbed by state ‘national-popular’ rhetoric and depoliticising tactics through the institutionalisation of workfare and social programmes and subsidies to state-sponsored cooperatives and to self-managing practices of workers in fábricas tomadas. But any inquisitive reader may wonder about synergies between the internal characteristics of a movement and the external political opportunities that explain pathways taken by horizontal movements vis-à-vis state politics, beyond a false dichotomy between politics of state co-optation versus horizontal groups’ autonomy.
Finally, a deeper discussion about what horizontalism means in terms of post-crisis citizenship beyond the logic of individual cases is still pending. Horizontal social articulation not only denotes the complexities of a reawakened society and the challenges of defining citizenship ‘from below’, but also, and more importantly, opens new questions about new models of social underpinnings of ‘citizenship from above’, or post-neoliberal corporatism, as inclusion is, essentially, a matter for the state.
Regardless of specific criticisms, this should in no way detract from the book's overall quality. Everyday Revolutions is engaging and extremely informative on peoples’ ability to self-organise, socially and economically, in response to expectations of social change. It is timely for those interested in social movements, the politics of dissent, social engagement and democracy across the globe. Its distinctive narrative is also a journey through social imaginaries and emotions.
