Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T01:01:29.705Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Mean flow generation via non-resonant interactions in two-dimensional forced stratified turbulence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 December 2025

Antonin Zoppi
Affiliation:
LadHyX, CNRS, Ecole Polytechnique, Institut Polytechnique de Paris, 91120 Palaiseau, France
Paul Billant*
Affiliation:
LadHyX, CNRS, Ecole Polytechnique, Institut Polytechnique de Paris, 91120 Palaiseau, France
Leo Demaine
Affiliation:
LadHyX, CNRS, Ecole Polytechnique, Institut Polytechnique de Paris, 91120 Palaiseau, France
*
Corresponding author: Paul Billant, paul.billant@ladhyx.polytechnique.fr

Abstract

We perform numerical simulations of two-dimensional strongly stratified flows in a square periodic domain $(y,z)$ forced by a steady mode with vorticity of the form $\sin (k_{\textit{y f}}y)\sin (k_{\textit{z f}}z)$, where $(k_{\textit{y f}},k_{\textit{z f}})$ are fixed wavenumbers. It is shown that such deterministic forcing can lead to a transition to turbulence and the emergence of horizontal layers (so-called vertically sheared horizontal flows, VSHFs) similarly as for random stochastic forcing. The flow characteristics are studied depending on the Froude and Reynolds numbers. Furthermore, the mechanisms of layers formation are disentangled. Triadic instabilities first lead to the growth of pairs of wavevectors that resonate with each of the four forced wavevectors. Quadratic interactions between these resonant modes and the forcing also drive the growth of several non-resonant modes at the same growth rate. Since the forcing comprises the wavevectors $\pm (k_{\textit{y f}},k_{\textit{z f}})$ and their mirror symmetric with respect to the horizontal $\pm (k_{\textit{y f}},-k_{\textit{z f}})$, there exist enslaved/bound modes with the same horizontal wavenumber and different vertical wavenumbers. Hence, the quadratic interactions between the latter modes force a second generation of modes among which some are VSHFs. Their growth rate is twice the growth rate of the primary resonant modes. Such a mechanism is similar to resonant quartets (Newell, J. Fluid Mech., 1969, vol. 35, no 2, pp. 255–271; Smith & Waleffe, Phys. Fluids, 1999, vol. 11, no 6, pp. 1608–1622). When the forcing is restricted to only the two wavevectors $\pm (k_{\textit{y f}},k_{\textit{z f}})$, the second generation of enslaved/bound modes all have a non-zero horizontal wavenumber. However, further quadratic interactions can force VSHF. Thus, horizontal layers also emerge, but with a growth rate equal to the number of quadratic interactions times the growth rate of the primary instability.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Summary of the parameters of the main simulations. $\mathit{Re}$ and $\mathit{F_h}$ are the Reynolds and Froude numbers, respectively, as defined in (2.6). $\nu$ is the viscosity, $N$ the Brunt–Väisälä frequency, $q_0$ the amplitude of the forcing, $(k_{\textit{y f}}, k_{\textit{z f}})$ the wavenumbers of the forcing and $T_{\!f}=2\pi /\varOmega$. $k_{{\textit{max}}}$ is the maximum wavenumber and $\eta$ is the Kolmogorov length scale. $F_{\textit{ht}}$, ${\textit{Re}}_{t}$ and ${\textit{Re}}_{b}$ are respectively the turbulent Froude number, Reynolds number and buoyancy Reynolds number defined in (2.7).

Figure 1

Figure 1.Evolution of the amplitudes of the modes in the wavenumber ranges $0 \leqslant k_y \leqslant 12k_0$, $0 \leqslant k_z \leqslant 12k_0$ of the (a) buoyancy $b$ and (b) horizontal velocity $v$ in a simulation without random noise at $t=0$ for $F_h=0.4$, $Re=8840$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$ (solid lines). The dashed lines represent the asymptotic solution (2.4). The y-axis corresponds to natural logarithm. A moving average over a time interval $\Delta t = 5$ has been applied to filter the oscillations at frequency $\varOmega$.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Horizontal velocity field $v$ for $\mathit{Re}=8840$, $\mathit{F_h}=0.4$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$ at different times: (a) $t=1$; (b) $t=410$; (c) $t=560$; (d) $t=1100$; (e) $t=2100$; (f) $t=4630$.

Figure 3

Figure 3.One-dimensional spectra of kinetic energy $E_k$ (red lines) and potential energy $E_p$ (blue lines) for $\mathit{Re}=8840$, $\mathit{F_h}=0.4$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$ averaged over the time interval $2100 \leqslant t \leqslant 2200$. The solid and dashed lines show the horizontal and vertical spectra, respectively. The purple and green lines represent the $k^{-3}$ and $k^{-5/3}$ slopes, respectively. The vertical dashed line indicates the forced wavenumber $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}$.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Space–time diagram of the horizontal mean flow $\langle v \rangle _y(z,t)$ for $\mathit{Re}=8840$, $\mathit{F_h}=0.4$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Temporal evolution of the root mean square of the total horizontal velocity $v$, the mean $\langle v \rangle _y$, the fluctuations $v^\prime$, the vertical velocity $w$ and the scaled buoyancy $b/N$ for $\mathit{F_h}=0.4$, $\mathit{Re}=8840$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$. The inset shows a close-up view of the curves of $\langle v \rangle _{y-{rms}}$, $v^\prime _{\textit{rms}}$ and $w_{\textit{rms}}$ plotted in natural logarithm coordinate in the range $200 \leqslant t \leqslant 700$. The black straight lines represent the slopes of pure exponential growth at rates $\sigma$ and $2\sigma$.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Total buoyancy field $b_t = N^2 z + b$ for $\mathit{Re}=8840$, $\mathit{F_h}=0.4$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$ at different times: (a) $t=1100$; (b) $t=2100$.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Evolution of the energy dissipations and production as defined in (3.3) for $\mathit{Re}=8840$, $\mathit{F_h}=0.4$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$. The different lines correspond to the dissipation of kinetic energy $\epsilon$ (red), the dissipation of potential energy $\chi$ (blue), the energy provided by the forcing $P$ (yellow) and the total dissipation (purple).

Figure 8

Figure 8.Growth rates of the r.m.s. of the horizontal velocity $v$ (blue circles) and the mean $\langle v \rangle _y$ (green diamonds) as a function of the forcing amplitude $q_0$ for $N=1.75$, $\nu =0.008$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$. The blue and green lines show the growth rate $\sigma$ and $2\sigma$, respectively, computed from (A9) for each values of $q_0$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.(a) Averaged root mean square of the various velocity components as a function of the forcing amplitude $q_0$ for $N=1.75$ and $\nu =0.008$. (b) Averaged root mean square of the various velocity components divided by $\textit{Nl}_0$ as a function of the Froude number for $\nu =0.008$. The different lines correspond to $\overline {u}_{\textit{rms}}$ (black), $\overline {v}_{\textit{rms}}$ (red), $\overline {w}_{\textit{rms}}$ (yellow), $\overline {\langle v \rangle }_{y-{rms}}$ (blue) and $\overline {v^\prime }_{\textit{rms}}$ (green). In panel (b), the solid and dashed lines represent the simulations for variable $q_0$ for $N=1.75$ and for variable $N$ for $q_0=0.5$, respectively. The forcing wavenumbers are $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Snapshots of the horizontal velocity field $v$ in the statistically steady regime for various values of $q_0$: (a) $q_0=0.17$, $t=4043$; (b) $q_0=0.33$, $t=2471$; (c) $q_0=0.58$, $t=2023$; (d) $q_0=0.74$, $t=1968$ for $\nu =0.008$, $N=1.75$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$. In each case, the instant shown corresponds to the time $t_0+1000$.

Figure 11

Figure 11.(a) Averaged root mean square of the various velocity components as a function of the Froude number $F_h$ for variable $N$ for $q_0=0.5$ and $\nu =0.008$. (b) Averaged root mean square of the various velocity components as a function of the Reynolds number $Re$ for variable $\nu$ for $q_0=0.5$, $N=1.75$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$. The different lines correspond to $\overline {u}_{\textit{rms}}$ (black), $\overline {v}_{\textit{rms}}$ (red), $\overline {w}_{\textit{rms}}$ (yellow), $\overline {\langle v \rangle }_{y-{rms}}$ (blue) and $\overline {v^\prime }_{\textit{rms}}$ (green). The forcing wavenumbers are $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Amplitudes of the Fourier modes $\hat v$ of the horizontal velocity at $t=380$ for $\mathit{F_h} = 0.4$, $\mathit{Re} = 8840$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$. The colour scale is given in natural logarithm. The grid represents the discrete wavenumbers resolved in the numerical simulations. The wavevectors labelled $\boldsymbol{k}_{1+},-\boldsymbol{k}_{2-},\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f+}}$ are the resonant wavevectors, whereas the first non-resonant modes, $\boldsymbol{k}_1^{(i)}$ and $\boldsymbol{k}_2^{(i)}$ with $i=\{ 1,2,3 \}$, which are linearly generated by the interactions with the forced wavevectors $\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f-}},-\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f-}},-\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f+}}$, are labelled in red and green, respectively. The wavevectors labelled in black correspond to a sample of modes that are nonlinearly generated.

Figure 13

Figure 13.Evolution of the modes in the wavenumber ranges $[0,12k_0 ]\times[0,12k_0]$ for $\mathit{F_h} = 0.4$, $\mathit{Re} = 8840$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$. The $y$-axis corresponds to natural logarithm. In each of the four plots, all the modes are plotted in grey lines, but different modes are highlighted in colour. In panel (a), the three dominant modes $\boldsymbol{k}_{1+},\boldsymbol{k}_{2-},\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f+}}$ are displayed in colour. In panel (b), the modes $\boldsymbol{k}_1^{(i)}$ and $\boldsymbol{k}_2^{(i)}$ with $i=\{ 1,2,3 \}$, resulting from the interactions with $\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f-}},-\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f-}},-\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f+}}$, are plotted in colour. In panel (c), the three shear modes $\boldsymbol{k}_{vf}, \boldsymbol{k}_{v1},\boldsymbol{k}_{v2}$ and a sample of other modes, labelled in black in figure 12, that grow at a rate $2\sigma$ are plotted in colour. In panel (d), the other shear modes are displayed in colour. A moving average over a time interval $\Delta t = 5$ has been applied to filter the oscillations at frequency $\varOmega$.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Components of the wavevector $\boldsymbol{k}_{1+}$ (red dashed line) satisfying the resonance conditions (5.5) for $\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f+}}=(4k_0,4k_0)$. The red solid line delimits the unstable region predicted by (A9) for $q_0=0.5$, $\nu =0.008$ and $N=1.75$. The grid represents the discrete wavenumbers resolved in the numerical simulations. The coloured vectors represent the unstable triad ($\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f+}},\boldsymbol{k}_{\!1+},\boldsymbol{k}_{2+}$).

Figure 15

Figure 15.Representation of the wavevectors of the triad with subscript $+$ (solid lines) and of the non-resonant wavevectors (dashed lines) generated by the interaction with the other wavevectors of the base solution $(-\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f+}}, \boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f-}}, -\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f-}})$. (a) Non-resonant wavevectors $\boldsymbol{k}_{2+}^{(1)},\boldsymbol{k}_{2+}^{(2)},\boldsymbol{k}_{2+}^{(3)}$ are indicated by green dashed vectors. (b) Non-resonant wavevectors $\boldsymbol{k}_{1+}^{(1)},\boldsymbol{k}_{1+}^{(2)},\boldsymbol{k}_{1+}^{(3)}$ are represented by red dashed vectors.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Reynolds stress divergence $\mathcal{R}$ at times (a) $t=380$ and (b) $t=460$ for $\mathit{Re}=8840$, $\mathit{F_h}=0.4$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$. The blue line represents $\mathcal{R}$ determined from (5.2), while the orange line corresponds to $\mathcal{R}$ computed with the approximation (5.15).

Figure 17

Figure 17.Wavevector $\boldsymbol{k}_{1+}$ satisfying the resonance conditions (5.5) (red dashed line) for (a) $\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f+}}=(3k_0,3k_0)$, (b) $\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f+}}=(4k_0,3k_0)$, (c) $\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f+}}=(4k_0,5k_0)$ and (d) $\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f+}}=(5k_0,4k_0)$ for $q_0=0.5$, $\nu =0.008$, $N=1.75$. The red solid line delimits the unstable region according to (A9). The blue vector represents the forced wavevector $\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f+}}$. The grid represents the discrete wavenumbers resolved in the numerical simulations. Those that are unstable are highlighted by a circle whose colour indicates the growth rate level (colourbar).

Figure 18

Figure 18.Space–time diagrams of the horizontal mean flow $\langle v \rangle _y(z,t)$ for (a) $(k_{\textit{y f}},k_{\textit{z f}})=(3k_0,3k_0)$, (b) $(k_{\textit{y f}},k_{\textit{z f}})=(4k_0,5k_0)$ and (c) $(k_{\textit{y f}},k_{\textit{z f}})=(5k_0,4k_0)$ for $q_0=0.5$, $\nu =0.008$, $N=1.75$.

Figure 19

Figure 19.Temporal evolution of the root mean square of the total horizontal velocity $v$, the mean $\langle v \rangle _y$, the fluctuations $v^\prime$, the vertical velocity $w$ and the scaled buoyancy $b/N$ for $(k_{\textit{y f}},k_{\textit{z f}})=(5k_0,4k_0)$ for $\mathit{F_h}=0.4$ and $\mathit{Re}=5660$. The inset shows a close-up view of the curves of $\langle v \rangle _{y-{rms}}$, $v^\prime _{\textit{rms}}$ and $w_{\textit{rms}}$ plotted in natural logarithm coordinate.

Figure 20

Figure 20.Evolution of the modes (grey lines) in the wavenumbers ranges [$0$,$24k_0$]x[$0$,$24k_0$] for $(k_{\textit{y f}},k_{\textit{z f}})=(5k_0,4k_0)$ for $\mathit{F_h} = 0.4$, $\mathit{Re} = 5660$. In panel (a), the forced mode, the two dominant pairs of resonant modes and the resulting shear modes are plotted in colour. In panel (b), all the other shear modes $(0,k_z)$ in the band $0 \lt k_z \leqslant 24k_0$ are highlighted in colour. The $y$-axis corresponds to natural logarithm. A moving average over a time interval $\Delta t = 5$ has been applied to filter rapid oscillations.

Figure 21

Figure 21.Same as figure 4, but with the forcing (7.1).

Figure 22

Figure 22.Same as figure 5, but with the forcing (7.1).

Figure 23

Figure 23.Amplitudes of the Fourier modes $\hat v$ of the horizontal velocity with the forcing (7.1) at $t=550$ for $\mathit{F_h} = 0.4$, $\mathit{Re} = 8840$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$. The colour scale is given in natural logarithm. The wavevectors labelled $\boldsymbol{k}_{1+},\boldsymbol{k}_{\!{f+}}$ are the resonant wavevectors. They drive the other wavevectors that are all non-resonant. The evolutions of the labelled wavevectors are displayed in figure 24.

Figure 24

Figure 24.Evolution of the amplitudes of the modes (grey lines) in the wavenumber ranges [$0$,$24k_0$]x[$0$,$24k_0$] for $\mathit{F_h} = 0.4$, $\mathit{Re} = 8840$ and $k_{\textit{y f}}=k_{\textit{z f}}=4k_0$ with the forcing (7.1). In panel (a), the modes labelled in figure 23 are plotted in colour. In panel (b), all the shear modes $(0,k_z)$ with $0 \lt k_z \leqslant 11k_0$ are highlighted in colour. The $y$-axis corresponds to natural logarithm. A moving average over a time interval $\Delta t = 5$ has been applied to filter rapid oscillations.