Newspapers blossomed in early modern London after the lapse of restrictive legislation in 1695, expanding rapidly in number, increasing from one to up to eight pages in length, and in many cases being published daily. Most contained combinations of news, letters, commentaries, reviews and excerpts, as well as large numbers of notices and advertisements. These contents were absorbed, communicated and discussed in social venues such as the coffeehouse, as well as in private, and circulated around the world.
Historians of science and technology have largely underutilized these sources, in part because of inaccessibility. This is no longer an issue thanks to digital resources such as Gale's online database of the Burney Collection of the British Library. Jeffrey Wigelsworth, who teaches world and English history at Red Deer College in Canada, has provided one of the first books in our field to centre upon these valuable resources. This welcome, albeit somewhat uneven, volume makes a strong argument for their greater incorporation into scholarship on early modern ‘science’ and ‘science writing’ and their advertising and commoditization.
In the introduction, Wigelsworth provides useful background information on the nature of early modern newspapers and advertising. He suggests that English science advertisements arose from the errata, notices and commercial postings that appeared in the Royal Society's Philosophical Transactions under the heading ‘Advertisement’ from the 1660s onward. The author hypothesizes that they found their largest audiences in the newspapers in the decades preceding Isaac Newton's death in 1727, and that they helped to make science a public and collaborative enterprise. Finally, he argues that these texts were essentially the same as other contemporary ‘science writing’ in inducing readers to grant legitimacy to their subjects and to participate in knowledge formation.
Chapter 2 deals with the ‘advertisements’ in the Philosophical Transactions and more briefly with those in the state-controlled London Gazette, both of which started publication during the 1660s. In Chapter 3, Wigelsworth compares the number of advertisements in the Whig-leaning Post Man and the Tory-leaning Post Boy in 1695–1700 and 1710–1720, to suggest that politics did not play much of a role in the placement of the advertising of early science, as compared to its production and funding. Chapter 4 reveals the breadth of science advertisements in the daily newspapers during the 1720s, and common strategies employed therein. Chapters 5 and 6 are case studies, with the former mainly detailing longitude schemes which appeared in the newspapers within a year of the Act of 1714, which established a prize of up to £20,000 for an improved method of estimating a ship's longitude at sea.
Chapter 6 discusses the ‘branding’ of individual lecturers and luminaries by examining the dispute which arose in 1719 between the lecturer and author John Theophilus Desaguliers and the booksellers William Mears and John Woodward over rival editions of a Newtonian textbook. The Conclusion argues that such modes of advertising and commoditizing science did not last ‘long’ past Newton's death due to the rise of scientific disciplines and more specialized terminology, methodology and journals by the nineteenth century.
There are many admirable features of this book but also issues including a certain imprecision of language, which sometimes weakens the author's points or leads to misstatements. For example, Wigelsworth says that Isaac Newton considered the problem of determining marine longitude ‘unsolvable’ (p. 121). In fact, he suggested that it might be impossible for a timekeeper to ‘keep’ time reliably enough for better finding the longitude, but that astronomy might eventually prove a means of ‘finding’ it. The vital difference between these concepts is elucidated in a number of key pieces of longitude scholarship, including the collection edited by William J.H. Andrewes, The Quest for Longitude (1996), which is unfortunately absent from this book's bibliography. It is a shame that the author also does not mention the appropriately epistolary debate which arose around Jeremy Thacker's longitude pamphlet after Pat Rogers declared it an eighteenth-century hoax in the Times Literary Supplement in 2008 (p. 131).
A number of times Wigelsworth draws conclusions about an advertiser's success merely from the frequency of their appearances in the newspapers, such as that ‘the public was not impressed’ with T. Wilsford since he only advertised two series of lectures in that medium (p. 82). In early modern London, it was not actually that common for advertisers to hawk their wares and services as frequently or consistently in the newspapers as might be expected today. Many prominent scientific instrument-makers of the early 1700s, including Edward Nairne, advertised stock there infrequently, and others may never have done so, as in the cases of Jeremiah Sisson and the renowned specula-maker James Short. The author's oft-stated point that ‘newspapers had supplanted other advertising venues’ (p. 72) by this period cannot be entirely accurate, since many entrepreneurs continued to successfully advertise through word of mouth, books, pamphlets and trade cards. Similarly, it is unlikely that earlier audiences for scientific knowledge were almost wholly ‘passive’ in comparison to newspaper readers, as is repeatedly suggested (pp. 2, 124, 180).
Finally, the ubiquitous usage of terms such as ‘science’, ‘scientific’ and ‘science writing’ in the book is imprecise and may prove particularly misleading to readers from other academic specialities, who should otherwise find much of value in the volume. It would have helped if the author had at least explained the anachronistic terms' usage and attendant issues more explicitly and at greater length in the introduction. There is similar confusion over the definition of newspaper ‘advertisements’ since it sometimes includes non-commercial notices and yet seldom, if ever, the subtle advertising and science-related communications often present in other sections of these publications.
Overall Wigelsworth provides insights on many of the dynamics common to the advertising of early modern ‘science’ in newsprint during the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries. His book weaves a number of disparate samples, case studies and secondary sources into a good introduction to the subject and helpfully emphasizes the importance of incorporating these texts into the broader history of science and technology.
