Draining the swamp is not a new impulse in American politics. According to Michael F. Holt, Republicans’ successful 1860 campaign was a crusade against corruption, not slavery. In The Election of 1860: “A Campaign Fraught with Consequences, ” Holt offers a nuanced and challenging reassessment of conventional views of the 1860 presidential election. This four-way race on the eve of the Civil War did not, for instance, comprise two separate campaigns, waged between Constitutional Unionist John Bell and southern Democrat John C. Breckinridge in the Slave States and between northern Democrat Stephen A. Douglas and Republican Abraham Lincoln in the Free States. Most of the parties campaigned nationally. Nor did Republicans nominate Lincoln because he was more “moderate” than the likes of William Henry Seward. And, most importantly, Republicans did not win because they activated a moral majority of northern voters opposed to slavery and its expansion. Playing to the conservative center, Republicans instead made the election a referendum on corruption. Deemphasizing the divisiveness of slavery as a political issue in the 1860 campaign, Holt's argument has implications for our understanding of Civil War–era politics beyond this pivotal election.
Holt's take on the election dovetails with his scholarship on antebellum politics more generally, especially his contention that slavery was not the sole issue driving politics. Nativism and anti-Catholicism, Holt assures readers, were also viable issues, and he concludes that Republicans deemed Lincoln the more “available” nominee partly because he was not an outspoken critic of conservative nativists, whose votes Republicans needed. “Honest Abe” was also the ideal candidate for a party seeking to distinguish itself from the notorious corruption of the current Democratic administration. The new Constitutional Union party joined Republicans in campaigning against Democratic malfeasance. Holt's attention to all four parties, especially the often overlooked Constitutional Unionists and Breckinridge Democrats, including that proslavery party's northern supporters, is refreshing.
The only party that focused on slavery were the Breckinridge Democrats. All others sidestepped the issue, which, for Holt, suggests its lack of resonance. Compared to an antislavery Republican party, a party of anticorruption lacks moral grandeur, which will dissatisfy those who depict Civil War–era politics as an ideological showdown over slavery. This historiographical impasse is not new, and for decades Holt has sought to temper those who position disagreements over slavery as central to Civil War causality. But just how galvanizing was anticorruption? Was Republicans’ anticorruption rhetoric the boilerplate trotted out at every election, when out-of-office electioneers railed against corrupt incumbents? Holt documents such rhetoric in 1860, but he cannot gauge its effectiveness. Did the desire to drain the Democratic swamp impel the average voter to the polls?
Average voters and grassroots partisans, in fact, do not often feature in this work. Holt relies on the writings of party leaders to analyze electoral strategy, and he delves into newspapers to reconstruct parties’ public appeals. The research is deep, but not broad in terms of who is thereby included as political participants. This is a story of party bigwigs and political conventions. Only one chapter tackles the actual popular canvasses, when parties took their nominees and platforms to the people and when the people passed judgement. Much of the book is a detailed recounting of national political disputes and intraparty tensions prior to the election and of the five conventions that produced this messy race, which are chronicled over four chapters of their own. With clear, dynamic prose, Holt makes sense of complex issues—such as how hairsplitting disputes over territorial slavery divided the Democratic party. He does so with narrative verve, as in his gripping accounts of the conventions. His mastery of political personalities and party factionalism and his command of sources make for political drama that is fun to read.
But blow-by-blow reporting of conventions may not be enough to convey the fullness and significance of this most significant of presidential elections. More attention to the canvasses, which put the parties and the people in dialogue, would capture the scope of the election and of antebellum politics generally. A more expansive notion of what an election entailed would bring in the average voter as well as nonvoters, who, at over half of the population, are inexcusably absent from this book. The election comes across as an insular affair, cordoned off from the concerns of many Americans, which is at variance with the seamlessness with which partisan politics intersected with all Americans’ daily lives. Partisan politics was an arena in which Americans debated family, gender, religion, race, and political economy, all of which were at issue in 1860. Nineteenth-century political historians know that there was more to politics than this book suggests.
We know, for example, that women were political observers and participants. All parties used gendered appeals and female iconography, and the Republican party was unprecedentedly receptive to female participation. Holt does evaluate how each party presented their manly candidate to the electorate. Yet women appear in Holt's book only once, when readers learn that on election night Lincoln enjoyed “a midnight supper prepared by the town's Republican ladies” (172). Political historians also know that, to the consternation of white southerners, enslaved southerners followed partisan politics and were especially intrigued by the avowedly antislavery Republicans. For slaves, this was undoubtedly an election about slavery. And what about African Americans in the Free States, some of whom voted? Did Frederick Douglass's qualified endorsement of Lincoln show that he was alarmed by political corruption, or did he see something else at stake in this contest? Holt discusses the surge in young men's interest in the election, exemplified by Republicans’ youthful auxiliary, the “Wide Awakes.” The youth vote was a factor in the election's outcome. This is an instructive example of incorporating diverse groups, who brought their own agendas into political contests, the parameters of which were not predetermined by party elders.
The absence from this book of vast swaths of Americans, who influenced the parties even when they could not vote, does not reflect the current state of the field of political history. Partisan politics engaged every aspect of life, and all Americans found elections compelling. A presidential election, with political enthusiasm at fever pitch, should prove just how relevant and consequential nineteenth-century electoral politics was to everyone. After all, the results of this election prompted Americans to kill each other. Holt gives us a new and historiographically provocative analysis of an old and familiar story. Thinking about the election in broader terms and asking how diverse Americans understood it would make the 1860 election a new story altogether.
