The essays in this book are taken from the conference on Karl Barth's theology that took place in Princeton in 1999. The title of the collection is more a reflection of the catholicity of that conference than of any particular thematic unity between the lectures, for they range from purely systematic or more historical pieces, to discussions of Barth's relevance within contemporary global-political debate. Of equal significance to their content, perhaps, is the event they document, namely the conference which inaugurated the Center for Barth Studies at Princeton Theological Seminary. Over three hundred participants from North America, Europe and Asia attended to celebrate the opening of the Center in 1997, in the Seminary's Luce Library. Its establishment reflects the important trend whereby many of the keenest students of Barth's theology are now found in North American circles. Having purchased the library and personal documents of Markus Barth, the Center is well on the way to acquiring an exhaustive collection of writings by and on Karl Barth, as well as other historical artifacts, which makes it an unparalleled resource for scholars world-wide.
The book, meanwhile, indicates the continuing appeal of Barth's writings beyond narrowly theological groups. After an introduction by Hunsinger, there are six main essays, each of which is followed by a shorter response. The first is by John W. Hart, who distils a number of insights from his important book on the fragile theological alliance between Barth and Brunner. Hart's work is useful in a number of respects. First, he traces the beginnings of the disagreements between these theologians to a much earlier date (1916) than those who have approached their relation through the nature–grace debate of the early 1930s have been inclined to think. It appears (especially from an examination of their correspondence) that real theological differences were close to the surface from the start, a fact masked by their initial collaboration in the journal Zwischen den Zeiten. Second, Hart recognises the extent to which those disagreements were certainly magnified by personal difficulties, namely an inferiority complex on Brunner's side and Barth's unsympathetic way of dealing with this. A third result of Hart's research, which unfortunately does not make it into this shorter lecture, has been to show how unpalatable to Barth was Brunner's enthusiastic relation to the Oxford Group Movement which the latter had encountered in Princeton in 1928. Barth's natural aversion to pietism, his suspicion of ‘movements’ in general, combined with the political naivety of the OGM in Germany, only increased the tension between them. The major significance of Hart's work lies in correcting the stereotype (which tends to be common currency on the basis of introductions to modern theology) that these two theologians simply fell out over a rather abstract debate about natural theology. It is only regrettable that the relationship between them seems to have brought out less endearing qualities in each.
In a different essay, Eberhard Busch presents arguments from his enormous book on Barth's relation to the Jews. He has defended him against German historians of the Third Reich who suggest that Barth bore a measure of responsibility for the church's failings during the Holocaust. While F.-W. Marquardt, Ulrich Dannemann and others have laid to rest the ghost of a politically quietist Barth, suspicions have remained that, both in political conduct and theological conviction, Barth's approach to ‘the Jewish question’ was at best ambiguous. In particular, it is regretted that Barth's vitriol was directed not against the German Christians themselves, but at those moderates who mediated between them and the Confessing Church (including Brunner himself, of course). His concern for doctrinal purity in the church was of no practical help to the Jews at the time. On the contrary, Busch argues that Barth's insistence on the first commandment in the early 1930s was directed precisely against a ‘two-kingdoms’ doctrine which would have allowed the church to continue in happy isolation. He judged it pointless to exit the national church, if this simply meant the creation of a free church into which baptised Jews would be welcomed, but which would abandon any Jews outside it to the devices of the state (pp. 56–7). The greater part of the essay, however, is devoted to discounting the allegation that, if he fought against political anti-Semitism, Barth's theology was nonetheless systemically anti-Judaic, because of his reading of Romans 9–11 in CD II/2. Barth's description of the relation between the church and Israel as witnesses of the covenant is held to be problematic because of the way in which this double witness is expressed. It seems that Israel stands under the curse of her rejection of the Messiah, a judgement that makes her subsequent fate (from the destruction of the Temple, to – possibly – the Holocaust) explicable, if not justifiable. But, Busch contends, it is the Romans text itself (and beyond this the general relationship between the Old and New Testaments) that raises these problems (p. 71), and Barth ought not to be read as an advocate of any form of supercessionism. Rather, his conclusions need to be examined in the light of his conviction of the intrinsic dignity of Israel's particular attestation: ‘According to Barth, Israel bears witness to the divine judgement, to the promise heard, and to the humanity that is passing away. The church bears witness to God's mercy, to the promise believed, and to the humanity that is yet to come’ (pp. 70–1). Be that as it may, Katherine Sonderegger's brief response to this essay (pp. 80–7) indicates that those sections in Barth are better read as an interpretation of Paul's argument in Romans than as a helpful contribution to the church's understanding of Judaism or Israel. Barth does not really work out the distinctions between Second Temple and rabbinic Judaism that would be required in any modern engagement with this issue.
The remaining four longer essays cover the following issues: 1) Barth's ecclesiology as it relates to the themes of economic and ecological justice, and pacifism (Clifford Green); 2) Barth's understanding of providence (Caroline Schröder); 3) Barth's doctrine of love, which is contrasted with an account of the actions of resistance in the small village, Le Chambon, in Vichy France (Caroline J. Simon); 4) Barth's conception of eternity, in which George Hunsinger indicates how this doctrine is elaborated by Barth in a thoroughly trinitarian way. The volume concludes with a light-hearted series of anecdotal reflections from John D. Godsey, which testify to Barth's passion and good humour as a teacher. Inevitably, perhaps, the book does not really have a unifying thread, and its topical variety is both a strength and weakness. If Green's essay uses Barth's political theology as a springboard for a series of programmatic proposals for American church social policy, Hunsinger's is a detailed and strictly theological reading of one section of CD II/1.
This last contribution aside, one issue that crops up again and again in different places is the way in which Barth thinks through the relation between church and secular culture. Schröder and Simon are both concerned that, in different ways, Barth was a separatist who appealed either to a special knowledge or a secure ontology in the church, by virtue of which he elevated it over against the world. And yet, as the respondents to the essays show, these arguments are sometimes strained. Indeed, Catholic interpreters of Barth have tended to think, on the contrary, that he did not have enough to say about ecclesial ‘visibility’. If he is too complex to be easily reducible to one or other position, it remains true that Barth was often distrustful of the institutional church and occasionally had uneasy relations with its authority figures. He was very attentive to what Rowan Williams has called ‘the judgement of the world’: the way in which the church and theology must be open to allow its knowledge and identity to be subverted by all-comers if it wishes to remain grounded in the truth. Such voices are not competitive with the normative authority of the Bible, but may be its authentic witnesses, which the church ignores at its own peril. In Kant, Feuerbach and Nietzsche (among others) he discovered valuable reminders to truths that modern theology had neglected; he thought that the socialist movement, for example, often embodied a love for the neighbour that put the church to shame. Perhaps the difficult theme of Barth's understanding of the relation between church/theology with the world/philosophy ought to be tackled as much by discovering what he saw in such concrete examples as through trying to work out those relations in abstract or formal terms.
