The exploitation of natural resources in armed conflict has been the object of a number of scholarly writings.Footnote 5 Considering the role of natural resources in triggering, financing, and fuelling armed conflict, the primary concern of the scholarship has been to indentify more stringent legal restraints on the rights of the belligerents with regard to the exploitation of natural resources in times of armed conflict.Footnote 6 The purpose of Dam-de Jong’s volume goes beyond early efforts to develop a more coherent regulatory framework for the exploitation of natural resources in armed conflict. The aim of the book is to investigate the role of international law in “ensuring that natural resources are used to promote development as well as sustainable peace in countries that are experiencing or that have experienced armed conflicts which are either caused, financed or fuelled by natural resources” (p. 27). In this regard, the book is topical, original, and it fills a gap in the literature.
The question is explored in three steps, which correspond to the three main parts of the book. The first part examines the legal framework for the governance of natural resources in peacetime (although the author prefers to employ the term “governance within States”, p. 33), notably international human rights law and international environmental law. Particular attention is devoted to the principle of permanent sovereignty over natural resources, as the “organizing principle for the governance of natural resources within States” (p. 57), which is made the object of an in-depth analysis.
The law regulating the exploitation of natural resources in situations of armed conflict is explored in Part II. After a discussion on the continued applicability and role of peacetime law in times of armed conflict, the book turns to an analysis of the rules in international humanitarian law relevant for the protection of the environment and natural resources.
The third part of the book considers different strategies by which to address the illegal exploitation of natural resources as part of conflict resolution and peacebuilding. Whilst Chapter Seven discusses the UN Security Council’s initiatives to break the links between natural resources and armed conflict (e.g. selective commodity sanctions, targeted sanctions), Chapter Eight examines informal and voluntary processes initiated by group of states and the civil society to promote transparency in the management of natural resources (e.g. the Kimberly Process for the Certifications of Diamonds, the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiatives). Part III provides the most original insights by comparing hard and soft approaches to tackle conflict over resources, by assessing their contribution to a better governance of natural resources in post-conflict countries and by illustrating ways in which those initiatives could interact and reinforce each other. With regard to the latter aspect, emblematic is the Côte d’Ivoire case-study, where the UN Security Council “made the lifting of sanctions conditional on Côte d’Ivoire participation in the Kimberly Process” (p. 381).
The author reaches the conclusion that international law is “fairly well” (p. 429) equipped to deal with the challenges associated with resources-related armed conflict. This balanced conclusion is the result of a comprehensive, rigorous inquiry that highlights the strengths of the existing international legal framework and practice, as well as its inconsistencies and limitations. In the final remarks, the author formulates some proposals for the way forward. The core recommendation concerns the development of a more structural approach to promote good governance over natural resources in post-conflict countries. Two fundamental, though neglected, components of such a structural solution ought to be environmental sustainability and public participation in the process of conflict resolution and peacebuilding. The underlying assumption is that whilst “maldistribution of natural resources wealth” may catalyze social violence and armed conflict (p. 420), properly managed natural resources can contribute to the peacebuilding efforts and to the post-conflict development.
Without ignoring the challenges ahead, Dam-de Jong’s lines of argument deserve to be further developed and more attention devoted to the economic and environmental dimensions of armed conflict, if the international community is serious about its commitment to peace and sustainable development.
