This book will provide a fascinating read for scholars of politics, social policy and for all those involved with providing services for young children and their families. It is written partly as a political diary, with all manner of interesting nuggets of gossip, intrigue and internecine squabbling. In addition it accurately presents a detailed account of a major re-emphasis of services towards younger children, with good detail on the nature of the service under question – namely Sure Start – and of its evaluation. Naomi Eisenstadt was in a pole position to understand how the programme came into being, as its first director, and also to understand how it has changed over time.
She presents the information in chapter headings that liken the programme to a child developing into adulthood (e.g. a start is born, what happened next, stroppy adolescence, Sure Start grows up). However, the most fascinating aspect of the story for me was is in fact that this was not one child growing up but instead was more like a seed that was hot-housed too soon under different environmental conditions into many different varieties and then subjected to genetic engineering so that the end result, the adult, in no way represents the ideologically driven initial DNA. Nevertheless, the sense of growth and development is a good metaphor for this once-in-a-lifetime initiative. Never before had a government been so committed to the early years, or its robust evaluation.
As a social scientist, for my part the most attention-grabbing parts of the book are the details of how one minister's particular whim or hobbyhorse, or a need for politically expedient news at election time, could change the whole nature of an initiative that was simultaneously being presented as ‘evidence-based’. This was familiar to me to some extent as one of the directors of the national evaluation, in that the number of Sure Start Local Programmes was doubled (due to its ‘success’) before the evaluation contract was even awarded. Details of this and the methodological problems that ensued can be found both in this book and in the volume describing the evaluation in detail (Belsky et al., Reference Belsky, Barnes and Melhuish2007). However, Naomi Eisenstaedt's unique insight from within the civil service fleshes out the scenario in a way that will be absorbing for any social scientist who has ever thought about the relationship between policy, evidence and services.
She witnessed many inter-governmental discussions about this programme, and was also able to interview the ministers involved, who have been very candid about their own thoughts and roles. They have been honest with her in a way that I doubt would have taken place if she had not been an insider. Intriguing details are given in her account, such as how photo-opportunities were sought – who would not want to see a minister sitting in a colourfully decorated room with lots of happy toddlers and their parents in a community that had been given a huge sum of money to develop services according to local need? Throughout the development of Sure Start, political expediency was balanced against a real desire to make a difference, and to show that this difference had happened with high quality academic research evidence.
The book provides accurate details of a range of policy documents in a way that is both understandable and even handed, allowing a clear understanding of the process by which policy is transformed, and its impact of the relevant services. Stroppy adolescence, as chapter 6 is called, or genetic engineering as I would see it, documents many changes that occurred following the second Labour victory in 2001 and the consequent Comprehensive Spending Review in 2002. As the ‘Every Child Matters’ agenda was developed, a subtle change took place in the way that Sure Start was mentioned in government statements. By 2004, they were referred to as Sure Start Centres, and the concept of the locally managed Sure Start Local Programme was disappearing.
In the ‘growing up’ phase described in chapter 7, it becomes clear that the government's agenda was heavily oriented towards services that would facilitate parental employment. Thus, rather than providing a range of family support services, most centres became more focussed on provision of child care so that the likelihood of child poverty would be reduced.
The end result of 500 plus Sure Start Local Programmes, becoming 3,500 Sure Start children's centres, had undoubtedly represented a massive sea-change in the investment in early years services and one that Naomi Eisenstadt can justly describe with some pride. There had, by the time the book was completed, been a change of government. The current approach is still heavily focussed on early intervention (Allen, Reference Allen2011a, Reference Allen2011b) but now a different strategy is being applied. Local decisions have been made to close some centres and centrally funds are being sought from external investors to provide programmes that can show evidence of impact. It will be interesting to see how the next decade develops for early years services. Hopefully, another insider will be able to give an account as detailed, informative and accurate as the one presented in this volume about Labour's flag-ship Sure Start programme.
