The role of Islam in the public sphere, the management of secularism, and the maintenance of peaceful sociopolitical interactions in postcolonial francophone West Africa have been the subject of much scholarly engagement. In this volume, ten contributions, including the editor's introduction, examine, from various angles and disciplinary perspectives, Sufism, democracy, and tolerance in contemporary Senegal. The authors draw upon both ethnographic and historical data to analyze a socioreligious arrangement that has produced both an ethic of pluralism and collaboration and a functional political order unusual in Africa and in much of the Muslim world.
Studies have documented why Senegal was able to produce a stable religiopolitical regime. This volume seeks to reassess the sociocultural processes, historical shifts, and political adjustments that resulted in this ‘well understood secularism’. The ‘social contract’ of cooperation between Sufi brotherhoods and state authorities made Senegalese experience an exceptional ‘success story’ in both global and regional contexts. Alfred Stepan notes, ‘Senegal is possibly the only country in the world where Sufis are not only the overwhelming majority of the population but have never been systematically repressed, marginalized or controlled by state authorities’ (p. 227). In other words, as Joseph Hill notes, Senegal produced a ‘practical response’ to the challenges of secularization while serving as ‘a paradigmatic example of moderate, nonpolitical West African Sufis’ (p. 101). Islamism as an ideology has never sought to capture the state in Senegal. Instead, state authorities and Muslim brotherhoods negotiated to insure mutual respect and pluralism. In many ways, the contributions in this volume grapple with this exceptionalism, revisiting its sociological, cultural, historical, and political conditions.
Thus, unlike France, its former colonizer, Senegal has never experienced a radical secularism (laïcité), which would have translated into anticlericalism and possibly unrest. On the contrary, social, political, and cultural factors combine to make the separation between religion and the state negotiable, enabling subjects to live in a secular environment and yet to submit to Islamic governance. This modus vivendi and its practical pluralism have made Islam less problematic in the public sphere and a major dimension of modernity. In daily life, Islam is publicly displayed and celebrated, sometimes conspicuously, as the defenders of secularism would say. Islam has a dynamic presence in the media, a vivid manifestation through what Erin Augis refers to as ‘moral activism’ (p. 73) and Stepan terms, ‘rituals of respect’ (p. 108) enacted in social spaces that extend beyond the family, the ethnic group, and Senegal. The result is a moral economy and a political philosophy that clearly prevented radicalization and favored pluralism while continuously transforming Senegalese society.
While most of the contributions celebrate this exceptionalism, Leonardo Villalón, suggests examining the Senegalese experience from a comparative regional perspective. Sounding a discordant note, he observes that developments in both the political and the religious spheres indicate the ‘need for caution in any generalizing about the impact of Sufism on a given outcome, such as democracy’ (p. 240). Beth Buggenhagen notes that in light of the new visibility of Islam in the public sphere, there is a need for Senegalese secularism ‘to be continuously understood by all actors in the public sphere’ (p. 48) and Cheikh Anta Babou insists that ‘the relationships between the Muridiyya and the Senegalese state are less stable and more complex’ than the social contract theory anticipates (p. 127).
Overall, the volume adds to the long list of works on Islam in Senegal. Its chapters deal fairly well with the topic and suggest new ways of historicizing the social contract. Even though some of its arguments have been made elsewhere, its ethnographic and historical perspectives combine to give the volume substance. Examining the social contract in the interactions between the political society, in general, and the brotherhoods would have enriched the volume, especially because, as it stands, the collection promotes a rereading of the Senegalese religiopolitical experience. In any case, the book should be of interest not only to Africanists and Islamicists, but to all scholars interested in documenting the reformulations of the secular and in theorizing Muslim modernities.
