This is the third in a series of articles about the activities of the French Politics Group (FPG), charting the institutionalization of our research and teaching partnerships with our colleagues in France. In last year's essay for PS (April, 2006: 389–91), we discussed 10 lessons we had learned in pursuing successful international collaboration. Following yet another productive year of ever-increasing collaborative activities on both sides of the Atlantic, it appears that this prescription for success has continued to work. As evidence, one need only look at FPG-sponsored activities at the APSA annual meeting. In Philadelphia in 2006, the group hosted five panels with an average attendance of 25 people. Attendees at our (open bar) Friday, late-night cocktail party declared it to be the toast of the APSA social scene. We have seen an increased attendance of French political scientists as well (20, compared to two in 2001). Finally, an APSA-sponsored roundtable has laid the foundation for a French “State of the Discipline” to be published in collaboration with the Association Fran[,]caise de Science Politique (AFSP). Here, we revisit the top 10 key ingredients to our growing and highly fruitful collaboration in hopes of spurring on others to invest their time and limited resources to contribute to the internationalization of the discipline and APSA.
1. APSA Support—APSA this past year included one of our roundtables on “Mapping French Political Science” in one of their international committee roundtables slots. Hosting the roundtable at noon meant that we could maximize attendance without competing with other panels. The success of this strategy is witnessed by the fact that we had 60 attendees to this panel. The European Politics section also helped us out by co-sponsoring several of our panels; in addition, one of our panels was taken up by the APSA theme committee. As a result we were able to field five panels/roundtables with only one official panel slot, averaged 25 people per panel and increased our permanent panel allocation to two.
2. Moderate Levels of Resources for Travel and Awards—We continue in not having to ask our members to pay dues—in part to avoid creating a heavy administrative process. At the same time, we have been quite successful in receiving financial assistance from our institutional partners including:
- money for the all-crucial French Politics reception was contributed by the AFSP, the Centre d'Etudes de la Vie Politique Fran[,]caise (CEVIPOF), the Institut d'Etudes Politiques (better known as Sciences Po-Paris), and the French Politics Group PSA-UK;
- APSA travel grants for foreign scholars for several French participants;
- Sciences Po-Paris creating a permanent fund to finance our newest award, the Stanley Hoffmann Best Article on French Politics Award;
- funding from the journal French Politics, Culture, and Society for our group's dissertation award.
3. Institutionalized Partners in Other Countries—We continue to produce a joint newsletter with the French Policy and Politics Group of the PSA-UK. We have a very close collaboration with the AFSP. In addition to contributing to our receptions, the FPG is currently working with the AFSP on the following collaborative projects:
- a workshop on methodology at their upcoming conference in Toulouse with the participation of Janet Box Steffensmeier (head of the Political Methodology Section—APSA), Gary King (Harvard University), and Gary Goertz (University of Arizona);
- an ‘inventory’ of contemporary political science in France;
- a co-edited book project on “the state of the discipline” in France—to be eventually co-produced by APSA and AFSP;
- a second roundtable on the state of French political science at the 2007 APSA meeting in Chicago.
Sciences-Po Paris and the Fondation Nationale des Sciences Politiques continue to be key partners as well as providing a significant share of funding and support for our efforts. CEVIPOF, another French national research unit that focuses on political science, has also been an important partner through funding and the participation of its researchers—over two thirds of the French political scientists at the 2004 APSA annual meeting in Chicago worked at CEVIPOF or Sciences Po-Paris, or both. With the help of the AFSP, this year we are working on extending our collaboration to Institutes of Political Studies outside of Paris in Toulouse, Lille, Bordeaux, Grenoble, and Strasbourg.
4. Section Awards Generate Interest and Attention—One of the features of our growth has been the diversification of research considered for awards beyond what might be termed a traditional French politics audience. We gave our third best paper award to a political theorist, Roxanne Euben, who focused on Tocqueville in comparison to African theorists. The new Stanley Hoffmann Best Article Award will be an important part of our institutionalization in the U.S. and in Europe. We have significant prize money for the winner (2,000 euros, take note!), a prestigious name on the prize, and a systematic process for coming up with the pool of articles to be considered. Rather than making a call for articles, we will do a search of all refereed journals that might publish scholarship on French politics. Making the award for English-language articles will also contribute to the internationalization of the study of French politics. Combined with the permanent support for the generous prize money, the semi-annual award stands to enhance the reputation of the FPG-APSA on an international level. Reflecting our group's interest in encouraging graduate students, we will make our fifth award for the Georges Lavau Dissertation Prize in 2008, an award we have made every three years since it was created in 1991.1
The FPG decided to make the award every three years in order to generate a large enough pool to maintain quality. It has the not-unintended additional benefit of reducing workloads for those serving on the committee.
5. Cosmopolitan Membership Representing all Career Stages—Since 2002, we have increased our membership from 95 to 145, bringing in equal numbers of scholars from the U.S. and France with additional members from the UK, Germany, Japan, Sweden, and Canada. We see this national balance on our award committees and panels. We continue to have an equal distribution of junior, mid career, and more senior people. The composition of the Best Article Award Committee represents this well, with three senior scholars (Pierre Hassner, Stanley Hoffmann, and Gérard Grunberg), and two junior-level scholars (Sylvain Brouard and Ben Clift). About 10% of our members are graduate students, reflecting the vitality of a new generation of scholars working in the field.
6. APSA Short Course Format, Working Groups, and Receptions—APSA provides a variety of venues for political scientists to gather and work, and we have taken pains to take advantage of all of them. For example, this year we are organizing our first short course on research; an assessment of French political institutions in honor of the 50th Anniversary of the Fifth Republic. The short course will be open to the public and participants will be presenting draft chapters for an edited volume to come out the anniversary year of the Fifth Republic. In addition, we will take advantage of the new working group structure at APSA, and will convene the first Working Group on French Politics around five panels and the short course. We hope to attract newcomers to the group this year and are encouraging graduate student participation in the working group. Finally, we will hold our French Politics reception, which provides a fun venue for our members (and non-members) to get together in a convivial atmosphere. Being able to ‘hang out’ and ‘chew the fat’ over good food and wine is a crucial part of our success and a reward for everyone's hard work.
7. Developing Manageable Teaching and Research Projects that are Linked to Mainstream Political Science—We have four in-progress projects that have come out of our collaborations at APSA. Two of these projects will produce publications: the edited books on French Political Institutions at 50 and the State of French Political Science. The other two will have other outcomes—a survey of French political scientists and the joint methods workshop in Toulouse in 2007. All four have been developed incrementally in conjunction with the 2007 APSA annual meeting. All of our projects are tightly linked to political science in the U.S., through theory, methodology, and individuals. In addition, four out of five panels for this upcoming conference are explicitly designed to address critical debates in comparative politics, and to contribute to theory building within the discipline. Our projects also reflect the trend within our discipline to develop rigorous, multi-method research strategies appropriate to the investigation of social scientific problems.
8. A Sympathetic (but not affiliated) Journal—Unlike the early years of the French Politics Group (when it was inextricably linked to French Politics and Society), we have carved out an important independence. In part, this is a reflection of the growth of journal offerings. Revised versions of the papers presented on last year's panel French Feminists and the Republic have been submitted to a new journal in the field, French Politics, for consideration as a special issue. However, we have maintained good relationships with the original publication (now renamed French Politics, Culture, and Society); for example, Herrick Chapman, the current editor, has consented to finance our dissertation award.
9. Group Members Willing to Invest Time and to Share the Burden of Work—FPG members and individuals from our partner groups remain a key to our success. As a group, we have eschewed an overly bureaucratic structure for a more broad-based participation. Counting the members of committees, institutional partners, panel participants, and short course organizers, we have nearly 40 people who make significant time contributions each year, including those who attend our annual business meeting at the APSA annual meeting. This collective involvement makes it easier for the group convener to do the job of coordinating all of the different activities.
10. APSA Meetings an Important, But not Unique Focal Point—While the APSA annual meetings continue to be our major focus, we use the venues of our other institutional partners in France and the UK as outlets for our activities. This year we take the show on the road through our co-sponsored methodology workshop in Toulouse France through the AFSP and next year we will look to send our members to the PSA meetings in the UK.
For more on the group, contact Amy Mazur (mazur@mail.wsu.edu) or Andrew Appleton (Appleton@wsu.edu), or look at the group's web site: http://ww.wsu.ed/~frg/.
