The rule of law does not have all of the answers to today’s cultural heritage issues. The internationalization of relations, the complexity of situations, and the diversity of historical, political, diplomatic, economical, and spiritual concerns call for the assistance of other, softer rules, such as ethical rules. In this context, the Institut Droit Éthique Patrimoine, the Institut d’Études de droit public, and the École du Louvre have conducted an international seminar where jurists, art historians, curators, and art market professionals exchanged ideas on ethical questions raised by their practice. Below are the summaries of some of the interventions that may be of particular interest from a jurist’s perspective.
INTRODUCTION
Since the widespread adoption of the 1970 Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property, some ethical norms pertaining to cultural property protection have been incorporated in substantive law. Footnote 1 We have also seen concrete manifestations of their development, notably in cases of human remains restitution Footnote 2 and through the recent multiplication of deontological codes in this field. However, collaboration between professionals remains essential to continue identifying and addressing cultural heritage ethical issues, especially because legality and legitimacy may not always be synonymous. Footnote 3
“ARTIFICATION”
Although generally gratifying and, thus, seldom contested on ethical bases, “artification”—namely, the transformation of non-artistic property into artistic property—also has undesirable consequences such as desecration, dispossession, and exploitation. Footnote 4 Moreover, the relationship between “ratification,” ethics, and the art market should be reinforced. In France, for instance, the legal texts governing the Conseil des Ventes Volontaires (CVV) do not address ethical issues. As such, the CVV generally cannot prevent the sale of objects that wound sensibilities; free trade prevails. Other shortcomings affect the United Kingdom’s art market, where art dealers do not need particular diplomas, are self-regulated, and are not subject to specific governmental control.
INTANGIBLE HERITAGE
Ethical issues also arise in light of the application of the 2003 Convention for the Safeguarding of Intangible Cultural Heritage (2003 UNESCO Convention). Footnote 5 This convention cannot justify safeguarding all kinds of intangible cultural heritage, as shown by the examples of the corrida and slash-and-burn agriculture, two cultural practices that have been prohibited or limited by national legislators in light of other societal considerations. The 2003 UNESCO Convention also raises multiple ethical questions that have yet to be addressed by corresponding guidelines and on which interdisciplinary collaboration is essential. Footnote 6 As a first step, a draft Model Code of Ethics has recently been prepared by the United Nations (UN) Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization.
SPONSORSHIP
The actual legal rules governing sponsorship in the art and cultural property fields are not sufficient to ensure balance in the relationship between sponsor and recipient. Ethical questions have therefore grown in importance in the sponsorship industry, which has had to develop tools that increase its transparency and to create various new legal structures, including sponsorship conventions and ethical charts. However, it is currently difficult to measure these ethical norms’ efficiency since issues arising out of sponsorship contracts are usually settled through private negotiations.
DIGITIZATION
Cultural heritage digitization poses new ethical issues pertaining to its sorting, selection, and censorship. Digitization activities initiated by both public and private actors raise questions on the transparency of public-private partnerships, the use of personal data, and accessibility guarantees in light of corporate profit objectives. Digitizers must also reflect on how to guarantee full and transparent access to the chosen material as well as its authenticity. Footnote 7 It is also necessary to re-evaluate the roles and places of collective management organizations in the arts and culture industries.
RESTITUTION OF HUMAN REMAINS
It was submitted that the contours of a customary “right to restitution” of human remains may be starting to appear in public international law, as notably illustrated by the Indigenous peoples’ right to repatriation of their remains that was set out in Article 12 of the 2007 UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (a soft law declaration). Footnote 8 Indeed, precedents illustrate the regular application of this principle even in the absence of hard law. Footnote 9 Moreover, the fact that the majority of member states voted in favor of this declaration without reservations, as well as the multiple agreements on restitution of human remains concluded between states and communities in the past years, could demonstrate the existence of opinio juris on this question.
RESTITUTION OF LOOTED ART
In some cases of restitution of looted art, the absence or incompleteness of applicable positive law have allowed judges to give greater consideration to principles of fundamental justice. However, positive law has also sometimes been the source of injustice, as shown in the examples of “legal” criminal acts performed under the Nazi regime. Such conflicts between ethics and positive law could be resolved by applying the Radbruch formula, under which a judge should refuse to apply a statute if it seems either “unbearably injust” or in “deliberate disregard” of human equality before the law.
DEACCESSIONING
In France, deaccession decisions enabling restitution are often based on ethical principles, such as the immorality of the possession, which collide against clear legal norms prohibiting restitution. Footnote 10 In this light, French museums should consider alternative solutions such as long-term loans in cases where restitution is ethically desirable, but prohibited by law. In contrast, in the United States, the primacy of personal property principle allows for easier deaccessioning. However, the Association of Art Museum Directors’s policy on deaccessioning—a soft law text—indicates that it should only be done in order to improve the quality of collections and not to finance museum operations. In light of the current economical context, this makes one wonder whether education and public interest will really be served if museums, unable to find financing, go bankrupt and close their doors.
CONCLUSION
Law cannot answer all of the questions raised in the cultural heritage field, and “soft” norms, although not legally binding, are frequently relied upon and applied by all actors involved. They also have become all the more important when non-legal actors apply them with the belief that they are constraining. Since cultural heritage keeps diversifying, the number of ethical norms and standards governing it has increased and adapted, allowing them to cover new situations with great flexibility.
