Writing about colonial violence in Algeria has become something of a cottage industry. Often focusing on acts of torture, mass killings, or other brutalities against the “wretched of the earth,” the historiography of Algeria has become the site of a heated debate on the nature and scale of colonial violence. As Benjamin Brower points out in this highly nuanced and impeccably researched study of the French colonization of the Sahara, there are historical reasons for the fixation on violence, especially given the civil war in Algeria, which began in 1991 and prompted a colonial turn in French historiography. Brower writes that “after Algeria's descent into civil war filled French news broadcasts and newspapers with stories of ghastly violence, the door opened to fully revanchist readings of the colonial era” (p. 5). On the other side of the colonial divide, Algerian historiography has often been quick to find a protonationalist logic in each instance of anticolonial revolt, thus remaining locked in the binary logic of colonialism. Brower's work is, therefore, a particularly important contribution. By insisting on the “multiple logic of violence in colonial Algeria,” he underscores “that violence is not a singular phenomenon and assumes many forms” (p. 6).
To illustrate the multiple processes that inflicted violence on actors in Algeria, Brower focuses on the Sahara. This understudied region (with the important exception of works on the discovery of oil) was colonized according to a doctrine of pénétration pacifique, or peaceful penetration. In the first part of the monograph, Brower shows how the colonization of the Sahara was increasingly controversial in the 1840s due to its economic, human, and political costs. Unlike the Mediterranean coast, where the commercial and agriculture benefits of colonization were clear to colonial administrators, the benefits of expansion into an inhospitable desert were much less evident and thus met significant political opposition. As a result, supporters of Saharan conquest were forced to articulate a peaceful colonial vision that required a minimum of physical and economic resources. The pénétration pacifique therefore “helped respond to colonial critics by playing upon those values of French colonialism about which there was general consensus, such as trade and development” (p. 54). Yet despite the benevolent face of this colonial undertaking, Brower shows how the pénétration pacifique led to massacres and other forms of social, political, economic, and even ecological violence. This is an important corrective to a strain of colonial historiography that has often pitted an enlightened colonial humanism (embodied by the Saint-Simonians) against a brutal colonial savagery (exemplified by General Bugeaud).
The second part of the book examines the 1861 attack on a European outpost at Djelfa by Si Tayeb, a member of the Rahmaniyya Sufi order. Here, Brower rejects the paradigms both of Islamic revolt and of colonial accommodation, which have often been used to explain Muslim responses to French occupation. Instead, he claims that anticolonial activity more closely resembled social movements elsewhere in Africa. The imposition of a market economy, destruction of crops, food insecurity, and attack on traditional authority fueled sporadic attacks such as the one at Djelfa. Brower calls this mode of violence a “holiday-gone-wrong,” borrowing the term from René Girard. He writes that “this confused, reckless armed struggle appears as both an expression of frustration and a desperate attempt to reverse the status quo” (p. 133).
Here Brower raises important questions that relate not only to the narration of violence but also to the use of primary sources. How are we to interpret the meaning of violence when it is rooted in the political strategies and imagined possibilities of actors who left no written record? In answering this question, Brower engages in a remarkable and successful attempt at reading French sources to glean information about indigenous actors as well as colonial administrators. In his view, the attack's low percentage of participants, lack of sacrificial or ritualized violence, and intense, indiscriminate nature show that it was a desperate attempt to ensure political control, economic survival, and social meaning. “With daily existence having become precarious, and the social order having been frayed, the people of Algeria sought solutions by following increasingly dangerous paths” (p. 137).
Part III of the book addresses slavery, another issue familiar to historians of Africa. Even though slavery was technically abolished in French territories in 1848, French administrators engaged in a form of political pragmatism by turning a blind eye to the slave trade in order to protect delicate local alliances. Attitudes toward slavery also hinged on conceptions of race: while many French administrators were convinced that freed black slaves would be more loyal subjects than the purportedly fanatical Arabs, the equating of blackness with disbelief led some Algerian Muslims to accept the practice of slavery despite the fact that Islamic law clearly forbade the selling of Muslims into slavery. As Brower illustrates, there was an enormous gap between theory and practice on this latter point. These forms of race thinking and political jockeying resulted in the continuation of the clandestine slave trade, which signified a form of violence that was quotidian, even banal. Highlighting the fact that violence can be inscribed in a status quo and does not require a premeditated logic, Brower treats slavery as a form of violence that was normalized by social, economic, and political conventions.
An even more insidious form of violence emerges in the fourth and final section of the book, which examines the romantic aesthetic that underpinned the dreams of destruction and conquest in the Sahara. The “Blue Legend,” for example, popularized the French vision of the Tuarag as noble savages of the desert. In charting the relationship between aesthetics and politics, Brower also discusses the subjectivity of the French Saharan explorers who wrote accounts that were a hybrid between official reporting and romantic travelogues. He notes, “Saharan explorers rarely probed their worries, fears, or moments of doubt, instead choosing to describe them in fetishistic ways, which denied expressions of weakness or insecurity” (p. 219).
Yet, the extent to which aesthetic sensibilities and psychological blockages explain a form of violence remains up for debate. Indeed, while Brower's expansive notion of violence speaks to multiple phenomena, one might ask at what point violence becomes indistinguishable from coercion, power, and even authority. It is clear that to equate colonial violence with a blanket European “modernity” is futile, and as Brower forcefully claims, “there is no direct path leading from Algeria to Auschwitz, as some have suggested” (p. 24). Instead, the conception and implementation of various forms of violence was a much more contingent and unruly process. Algeria might have provided a laboratory or space of exception for certain colonial officials, but the political, economic, and pragmatic limitations weighed heavily on decision making at every turn.
Moreover, the emphasis on the “violent aesthetics of the sublime in the Sahara” (p. 199) sits uneasily with Brower's earlier claim that “violence consists not of concepts and theories but practices” (p. 131). A tension between regimes of truth and practices of domination runs throughout the manuscript, and while Brower insists that the “violence of power . . . helped colonialism produce itself with a specific episteme” (p. 18), he also claims that “this process displays little Foucauldian sophistication” (p. 17) because French colonial power “saw itself more as a purveyor of death than a regulator of life” (p. 18). Analyzing physical and conceptual violence in a single frame is one of the major achievements of this work, making it an important redress to studies of knowledge and power that frequently overlook the material aspects of colonial rule. Yet a more sustained reflection on the relationship among the various forms of violence that were inflicted on the Sahara would be welcomed. Nevertheless, the book is a remarkable work that will be vital to scholars working not only on the history of Algeria but also on French empire and the genealogy of colonial violence.
