Baz Kershaw begins Theatre Ecology with a self-reflexive, almost elegiac description of himself at his desk watching a storm outside the window while writing the first sentence of his book. As the lightning illuminates the dark sky for a moment, he casts himself into a reverie, circling through memories of past storms and his own human condition, past and present. This brief “Prologue,” like the book that follows, unravels in flashes and fragments, and in the end, what Kershaw means by “theatre ecology” remains oblique and allusive. Readers must be self-reliant; Kershaw tells us many things about the theatre and about ecology, but he leaves it to us to make sense of the pieces and the whole, to generate recognitions and connections for ourselves, and in so doing to perceive the cumulative value of his work both in the theatre and in the academy.
What might be expected of a book called Theatre Ecology? Perhaps a passionate, yet scientific, exploration of the web of interactions among actors, audiences and the theatre environment—not just the mise-en-scène, but the entire building as it encases and informs the experience of everyone within? Or perhaps a rigorous examination of the theatre's evolving representation of and relationship to the natural world, beginning with Zola's formulation of naturalism as influenced by Darwin (et al.) and culminating in a discussion of contemporary environmentalist theatre and performance events? Kershaw has certainly touched upon these ideas, but his book is not so direct. Instead, while the word “ecology” seems to act as a kind of catchment for a whole host of meanings, mostly to do with the social, it may be that Theatre Ecology is best read as a kind of memoir. That is, its aims are explicitly social, but its means are almost entirely personal.
At the outset, and periodically throughout the book, Kershaw tells us that Theatre Ecology is a difficult book, largely composed of previous writings and presentations, brought together in an idiosyncratic montage. One can, it seems, dip in and out of its pages at will, picking at threads of Kershaw's fluctuating thoughts about the relationship among theatre, performance, and what he calls the “narrowing straits between nature and culture” (4). Along the way, we catch glimpses of Kershaw, himself a kind of spectral presence, as he recollects ephemeral traces of diverse theatrical events and muses fleetingly on the history, politics, and ethics of performance.
At the same time, Theatre Ecology is emphatically structured and organized, framed by a “Prologue” and an “Epilogue” and, much like a three-act play, divided into three Parts: “In the Present: Qualities of Theatre and Performance”; “Of the Past: Histories of Theatre and Performance”; and “For the Future: Ecologies of Theatre and Performance.” Each part begins with a Preamble that frames and foreshadows the contents of the three chapters within. The three chapters in each part are also named in ways that signal the effort that has been taken to pull previous pieces and publications into line. Thus, Part I contains chapters entitled “Performance Contexts,” “Performance Archives,” and “Performance Limits.” Part II comprises “Economies of Performance,” “Audiences of Performance,” and “Spectacles of Performance.” And Part III includes “Performance and Black Holes,” “Performance and Energy,” and “Performance and Biospheres.”
The explicit artificiality of the book's segmentation, along with its “chronology of chapter sources” (attached as an appendix), demonstrate the difficulties (and possible resistance) Kershaw experienced when drawing his diverse, divergent lines of thinking over time together into a consolidated artifact. At its heart, the elusive quality of Theatre Ecology seems to reflect a conflict for Kershaw between his fundamental belief in the social value of theatre and performance and his acquisition of stature as an academic—as, for example, when he ruminates on his inaugural lecture as the new Chair of Drama at the University of Bristol (2001):
Because what is performance if not effacement of being in the interests of becoming in the flux of time? What is theatre if not substitution of one thing for another? And, most depressing of all, what is drama and its study but a word-bound pretence that effacements and substitutions could somehow be rescued and resuscitated? Worse still, in the lecture itself the rear-view mirror of history would have to be on display, prominently attached to my shoulder like an ironic prop from Dada's Cabaret Voltaire. It would be, after all, a performance. (42)
As dedicated an activist as Kershaw has been both in his theatre work and in his previous books, it seems here that he has lost faith in both theatre and scholarship. For Kershaw, the state of the natural world has become too dire, the audiences who participate in ecological performances incapacitated, in one way or another too far removed from taking effective action. Somehow the theatrical has become insufficient to the task, and the satisfactions of scholarly argument—the value of theory when faced with the exigencies of practice—have proved illusory at best.
The presence of the personal in this writing is, perhaps paradoxically, the logical outcome of Kershaw's desire to efface himself as “the author,” a way of ceding the authority of his position as a senior scholar. In refusing to construct a clear through line, to define his terms clearly and purposefully, and, above all, to articulate an argument that can be readily grasped, Kershaw performs a kind of academic modesty. Ironically, though, the effect is to reduce his work to a tiny circle of self-preoccupation, rather than to cast light on the theatre in the social world.
