No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
Writing a history of the Armenian people presents a number of challenges. That history spans close to three millennia during which time the political geography of Armenia shifted as a result of domestic struggles and foreign occupation. During long stretches of time, the country lost its central authority or was fully governed by stronger neighbors. Furthermore, beginning in the 7th century some of its people emigrated in waves, a process that continues to this day, creating a diaspora that has remained relevant to the history of the homeland. Because Armenia is a nation that has had more than its share of calamities, historical controversies are painfully present in most contemporary Armenian narratives. Questions about who lost what and why are not just a matter of debate among historians; they appear in arguments concerning post–Soviet Armenia's independence, security, and relationship with its neighbors and the world. For these reasons, writing Armenia's history is not a task undertaken by many.
Nevertheless, the need for a survey has become urgent, given the proliferation of endowed chairs and courses in Armenian history, language, and literature in American universities, as well as the increased interest of the general reader. The first attempt was a two-volume work edited by Richard G. Hovannisian (1997), a much more scholarly yet less coherent work than the one under review, the second such attempt.
Bournoutian's volume has two parts. The first, made up of eleven chapters, covers the history of Armenia from earliest times to roughly its partition between the Ottoman Turkish and Safavid Persian empires in the 16th and 17th centuries. The second part contains thirteen chapters, the last of which covers the first twelve years of the “post-Soviet” Republic of Armenia. While the periodization and organization of the first part follows the conventional dynastic order, in the second part the author introduces an intriguing yet questionable principle of organization whereby five chapters on various diasporan communities separate the chapters on the history of Armenia itself.
In a work of this scope, one expects some factual errors, although those relating to contemporary affairs are difficult to understand. Bournoutian's timelines are a welcome addition, as they place developments in Armenia in the context of events in neighboring countries and the rest of the world, although the relevance of these events is not always made evident. The photos are of poor quality, but the maps are extremely useful in their simplicity and abundance. The style is easy, quite narrative, sometimes anecdotal, and entertaining.
In a brief Introduction, Bournoutian explains his approach to Armenian history in the following way: “[h]ow [the Armenians] managed to survive while larger and more powerful states disappeared, and how, at the same time, they were able to make significant contributions to world civilization, is the history of the Armenian people” (p). That is where the problem of this volume begins. By comparing states to the Armenian people, the author creates a conceptual confusion that underlies his near-celebration of that history. Someone else might have thought the history of the Armenian people consisted of continuous losses and might not have considered the recognition of contributions to world civilization as an appropriate compensation. Evidently, Armenia and Armenians have barely survived. This ability to survive Bournoutian assigns to Armenian rulers—often responsible for the loss of statehood, population, and territory—and to contributors to culture, mainly in the diaspora, rather than the peasants, craftsmen, and commoners who remained on the land, provided the essential continuity in Armenian history, and made all else possible, including the present independent state of Armenia. There is no question that communities in the diaspora have provided substantial support to Armenia and continue to do so. Yet their role remains to be seriously analyzed as far as the politics and economy of the homeland are concerned.
Equally disturbing is that, despite its title, the volume has little to do with the Armenian “people”—at least, until the reader reaches the modern period. Understandably, the term is used to suggest that the volume will cover more than Armenia in the geographic sense, given the importance of the diasporan communities in the last millennium. Nevertheless, the work reads more like the story of Armenian kings, princes, and catholicoses. The author also fails to provide any serious discussion of the institutions and institutional contexts within which those who ruled Armenia and spoke on behalf of the Armenian people for centuries made their decisions. The royal, feudal, and church rulers represented differences with the “people” and pursued institutional and class interests that were often more important in the decision-making processes of Armenia's native rulers than their being “Armenian.” Survival and relevance to others are the substance of diasporan identity politics, and Bournoutian may have written this work with such concerns in mind. In the process, however, he avoided delving into some of the most important internal struggles throughout the centuries that have determined the outcome of Armenia's relations with neighbors and conquerors. For example, the early 4th century—one of the most fascinating periods in Armenian history, when the struggle for power among kings, princes, and the catholicoses determined the fate of Armenian statehood—is hardly analyzed. The fascinating Paulician reformist movement that started in the 7th century is ridiculed in terms more severe than those used by the orthodox clerics who feared and battled it. Another consequence of this avoidance is a tendency to blame external forces for all the tragedies that befell Armenians. This volume could have benefited from valuable research produced both by Soviet Armenian and other scholars. The author is on firmer ground when he deals with the modern period.
Bournoutian is often careful to introduce the reader to a variety of interpretations when dealing with sensitive issues such as the genesis of the Armenian people, the genocide, political-party rivalries, and contemporary politics. While readable and useful, this volume falls short of the promise of its title.