The flow of labor migration to the Arabian Gulf states is today among the largest in the world. Despite the Gulf's rank as a destination for transnational labor, scholarship on Gulf migration has been relatively sparse, leaving the discourse on transnational migration focused more specifically on migration circuits directed to, or through, North America and Europe. City of Strangers, and Andrew Gardner's other work, is a welcome sign that this may be changing. Gardner's work makes an important contribution at a very timely moment. He is one of a growing group of ethnographers, demographers, and sociologists actively exploring and documenting the many communities of migrants moving through the Gulf. His recent and ongoing research marks him as one of the few social scientists with an accumulated body of empirical data that allows for a sophisticated and complex analysis of sociocultural dynamics of the region and its links to South Asia. City of Strangers is the first full-length ethnography of a particular community of migrants, serving as a benchmark in Gulf studies. It is, in fact, the first in-depth monograph addressing migration in the region since Walls Built on Sand, Anh Nga Longva's often cited 1989 study of migration to Kuwait. City of Strangers advances our collective knowledge and understanding of Indian migration to the Gulf, and recommends specific policy changes that could remedy the many social and economic inequities and problems evident in the structure of these flows.
City of Strangers explores the experiences of the migrant Indian community in the Kingdom of Bahrain, striking a sophisticated balance between detailed ethnography and theoretical explication. With rich ethnographic detail collected through interviews with Indian men and women of all walks of life, from men in the labor camps to professionals among the Lions and Toastmasters Clubs to women employed in the service industries, Gardner conveys the heterogeneity of the Indian community, as well as its complex relationships with the Bahraini state and citizens. Within this community, it is the men in the labor camps of Bahrain who stand at the center of Gardner's analysis. His careful prose and compassionate ethnography compellingly weave the laborers’ stories into larger theoretical and analytical discussions, leaving the reader informed of and engaged in the daily lives and experiences of these migrants and the hopes and frustrations they endure. City of Strangers reveals the household pressures that push these men to seek work in the Gulf, the vulnerabilities they face in the labor broker system that facilitates their movement to the region and in the Gulf-wide sponsorship system, and the unequal relationships between citizen-sponsors and foreign workers. Gardner applies the concept of structural violence in his analysis of these phenomena, contributing to a much larger conversation started by Nancy Scheper-Hughes, Paul Farmer, and others. Gardner convincingly makes the case that the sponsorship system governing migrant workers in the Gulf states fosters the production of exploitative labor relations and fuels the friction between citizen and foreigner.
In order to fully capture the nature of the relationships between the Indian residents central to his ethnography and the citizens of the host country, Gardner attends carefully to Bahraini citizens’ interactions with and attitudes toward the foreigners laboring in their country. His insights into the use of urban spaces and conventions of discourse in English-language newspapers open a provocative consideration of the nature of a public sphere potentially shared amongst the resident nationalities. For readers hoping for insight into the many questions about Bahraini society that were brought to the fore by the events of 2011, it is important to remember that Gardner's research takes migration and the governance of migrants as its focus and is not a political analysis of the Arab Spring. Nonetheless, his contention that we can discern the power of the state, in part, from the experience of foreigners is particularly clear, and the second half of the book offers some indirect insights into current tensions in Bahrain. In particular, he touches upon unemployed Bahrainis’ potential resentment toward the employment of foreigners and how competition in the labor market intersects with the objectives of Bahrain's nationalization policies.
City of Strangers is written with a clear and compelling voice. The organization of the book presents a coherent and integrated argument, though each chapter easily stands alone in making a focused theoretical point or providing ethnographic descriptions of particular phenomena. The book or the chapters are thus recommended for use in the classroom, whether as a case study to a course on migration, to explore structural inequities in the new economic order, or to model creative methodologies. From the opening narrative, which carefully recounts an instance of violence against a laborer through discussions of structural violence and the public sphere, to Gardner's subsequent policy recommendations, readers—whether or not they are familiar with anthropology or knowledgeable of the Gulf—will find the work accessible and rewarding.
