In her groundbreaking new work, Contemporary Arab Thought, Elizabeth Suzanne Kassab charts out the major thinkers of the Arab world in the post-1967 period. The major work on Arab intellectual history, Albert Hourani's Arabic Thought in the Liberal Age (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1962), which mapped the dominant intellectual trends of the nahda and interwar period, was written in 1962. Some fifty years after the publication of this seminal work, historians, philosophers, and political theorists have begun to identify the intellectuals who followed in the footsteps of those whom Hourani identified and so brilliantly analyzed. Who were the leading intellectuals of the 1960s through the 1990s? What were the philosophical, sociological, and political trends that shaped their thinking in regard to nationalism, revival, and cultural malaise? How did they relate to the generation of the nahda? Who, in other words, were Hourani's Arab contemporaries, and how do we evaluate their contributions today?
Elizabeth Suzanne Kassab attempts to answer these questions. She does so with much nuance and sophistication. Her book is thus a very important contribution to the field of Arab intellectual history, exposing a new generation of Arab thinkers whose stories have not been told despite their being at the core of the major intellectual debates of the 1960s and 1970s. Inspired by the writings of such theoreticians as Shohat and Memmi, Kassab deftly analyzes crucial intellectual debates and significant conferences on the anticolonial struggle, feminist criticism, secularism, Marxism, liberation, modernization, Westernization, decolonization, reform, and the state of the Arab world. She convincingly argues that despite oppressive military regimes, conservative Gulf sheikhdoms, and lack of democracy, original and pioneering thought never ceased to exist in the Arab world. Kassab read, and integrated into her work, an incredible amount of material, and her book offers innovative analyses of extremely interesting intellectuals and their works. Moreover, Kassab's definition of the Arab intellectual is wide enough to include poets (Adonis), playwrights (Saʿadallah Tanous), Arab Jews (Ella Shohat), academics (Bassam Tibi, Hisham Sharabi), and journalists (Faraj Fouda).
In contrast to the unfortunate flood of books on Islamic fundamentalism that mushroomed in post-9/11 America, this book shows that despite the shock of 1967, secular, leftist, and Marxist voices did not die out. The assumption that the Arab intellectual field became dominated by Islamists, especially Sayyid Qutb's followers, immediately following 1967 is challenged in the book, which demonstrates instead how secularist and leftist thinkers unpacked the meaning of defeat and continued to discuss ideas relating to radicalism, modernity, and secularism. Moreover, these Arab thinkers voiced criticisms of their regimes, Arab political culture, and conservative religiosity all throughout the period. In fact, one of the major contributions of Kassab's book is its giving voice to the generation of the 1960s and 1970s whose views are often ignored in current scholarship on the Middle East, despite the fact that their ideas assumed center stage at the time. While dealing with religious intellectuals as well, Kassab chooses those who promoted a new hermeneutics of the Islamic tradition and dared to confront religious norms and conventions.
Another important feature of the work is its integration of Arab feminism of the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s into larger intellectual debates of the period. Kassab, astutely, does not dedicate a separate chapter to the influential works of feminists and theoreticians such as Leila Ahmed, Fatima Marnisi, and Nawal al-Saʿadawi; rather, she integrates discussion of their ideas into each chapter of the book. We can therefore see how women in this period operated in numerous intellectual circles and how their writings treated not only issues relating to gender but also those relating to nationalism, Islam, colonialism, and modernization. Most female writers, however, relentlessly reminded their male colleagues that conservative elements within Arab society curtailed the liberation of Arab women; they fought discrimination against women and advanced their own interpretations of Islamic and nationalist texts.
The book inspires new debates about periodization. It challenges the simplistic linearity that assumes Arab thought “rises” in the nahda, “matures” in the interwar period, and “dies” after 1967. The work persuasively illustrates how a new generation of thinkers both challenged and appropriated the writings of nahda intellectuals. The conceptualizations of such luminaries as Taha Husayn, Qasim Amin, and Malak Hifni Nasif were relevant to a new generation of Arab intellectuals. Even if the latter disagreed with such thinkers, they always maintain a dialogue with the nahda.
I do want to mention, however, some domains where Kassab's methodological choices leave room for future discussion. It might have been preferable to integrate into the entire work the insights of the fascinating last chapter, which discusses the ways in which non-Arab philosophers and theoreticians dealt with questions similar to those faced by Arab thinkers. I see why Kassab implicitly evoked an East/West binary; many of the intellectuals she studies addressed the divisions between the First and Third worlds, between North and South, and between East and West. Nonetheless, many of the Arab intellectuals she discusses lived in the West and often wrote for Western audiences in Western languages (Tibi, Arkoun, Shohat). Moreover, within the Middle East itself, modern Arab thought was affected by European and American philosophies.
Naturally a book of this nature cannot include every important intellectual in the Arab world. Kassab has done wonderful work in identifying the major voices of the period. Yet the omission of the works of Edward Said, whose Arabic translations inspired a host of interpretations and responses, seems central (especially because the work does discuss Arab thinkers whose careers flourished in the West). I would also have liked to read more about Najib Mahfuz (whose outlook seems crucial to the thinking of Fouda and Abu Zaid), Iraqi intellectuals (such as Muhammad Baqir al-Sadr and his liberation theology), and Palestinian thinkers (such as Ghassan Kanafani and his writing on culture, colonialism, and resistance). The book could have also benefited from further comparisons to the works of Turkish and Iranian thinkers who grappled with very similar dilemmas. In many cases, such works were known to Arab audiences.
I perfectly understand why Kassab chose the great shock of 1967 as a turning point, but more attention to the 1950s could have been helpful. The intellectuals of the 1950s were different from those of the interwar period. Traumatized by 1948, they nonetheless hoped, especially after 1952, for a new, leftist, postcolonial, and revolutionary future for the Middle East. While they differ from the thinkers of the post-1967 era, some of their ideas about reform, liberation, and modernization have much in common with those of their successors. In fact, some of the intellectuals Kassab discusses (Qunstantin Zuraik most notably) began writing in the 1950s and grappled with the post-1948 political and cultural landscape.
More information about the changing contexts in which the works she discusses were read would have been helpful as well. Even if Kassab does not want to engage in the study of reception and only explore interesting ideas and currents of thought, further contextualization of the texts in question could have indicated which works were hegemonic and which were marginal in various sociocultural domains and underlined the fact that many of the intellectuals Kassab discusses were attacked because of their radical views. This would have also helped the reader to understand why Kassab chose to focus on particular intellectuals.
Nonetheless, this is a fascinating work and a much-needed addition to our field. It offers an indispensible overview of the scholars and intellectuals whose works we have read over the years, and it unearths the intriguing opinions of Arab political theorists, writers, and critics. A comment often made with respect to Hourani's magnum opus is that it inspired a new wave of dissertations and articles dealing with the intellectuals Hourani identified. Let us hope that Kassab's work will yield a similar result!
