James Robert Allard and Mathew R. Martin raise the curtain on their collection, Staging Pain, 1580–1800: Violence and Trauma in the British Theater, by addressing the potential inadequacy of any representation of pain. While acknowledging that pain is in some respects inherently isolating, resistant to language, and potentially “even anti-dramatic” (1), Allard, Martin, and their contributors confirm the inseparability of pain from the theatrical. The opening pages trace the history of staged pain from Aristotelian roots through the early modern period; the ethical force attributed to the contagion from actor to audience as a type of “purgation” emerges as key to “classical and early modern theorizing about the nature and import of art in general and theater in particular” (2). The essays in Staging Pain investigate the relationship between pain and theatre in historically specific ways between 1580 and 1800, a period “book-ended” (7) first by the founding of the London theatre and second by an increasing lack of faith both in spectacular modes of punishment and stage effects, and framed as well by essays on Marlowe and on Baillie.
In their introduction, Allard and Martin move beyond their classical theoretical grounding to establish smartly a lineage with contemporary trauma and pain theory. While critically substantiating their work, this move also makes their essays more useful for scholars working outside the early modern period. After first crediting Nietzsche, Marx, and Freud, the editors shift to Foucault's Discipline and Punish, Scarry's The Body in Pain, and Caruth's Unclaimed Experience as key influences. These latter theorists function as interpretative lenses for many of the subsequent essays. A reader who is not an early modernist will appreciate the book's deeply theoretical aspect, not only in the substantial introduction, but also in the worthwhile prefaces to each of the four essay groupings.
The first of Staging Pains's four parts, “Traumatic Effects,” explores theatre's unique ability to work out the nonlinear repercussions of trauma. Martin's essay ambitiously analyzes Marlowe's Tamburlaine Part One as subsuming tragedy within its own traumatic mimesis, breaking from earlier Tudor moralized tragedy, in which trauma is the result of an externally imposed event, to become instead a sequence of traumatic repetitions located in the space between Tamburlaine's becoming and being. In the second essay, Zackariah C. Long presents Amintor from The Maid's Tragedy as a profitable example of the connections between early modern and modern notions of mind–body.
Part 2, “Pedagogies of Pain,” relates “the pedagogical uses and abuses of pain” to pain's potential to be “world-making” (47) by extending outward from the disciplining of one body to the empathetic support of a community. Both essays in this unit suggest that the aestheticization of the (theatricalized) body in pain can potentially transcend its pedagogical functions. For Annalisa Castaldo, the revenge tragedy is defined by violence characteristic of the medieval passion play, but also through an obsessive distancing from the audience that enables the plays' increasingly hyperviolent aspect. William Levine's essay takes Sir Joshua Reynolds's defense of his presence at the public execution of Peter Shaw as a launching point for later eighteenth-century theorizing on the class-based “aesthetics and social value of public executions” (57).
Although pain's bodily specificity may make it unsharable, “Bodies (Im)politic” (Part 2) investigates how the theatre's “trio of actor, acted-upon, and witness” (74) still activates a possibly communal effect in forcing the spectator to register staged pain on some level—whether as sympathy, apathy, or aversion. John D. Staines brilliantly demonstrates this effect through his discussion of the radicalizing effect of pity in King Lear, specifically how the blinding of Gloucester forces the audience to reevaluate vengeance and the political order. While most of the volume's essays are of a high quality, Staines's analysis is especially well-aimed and more willing to innovate rather than rest complacently on established theory. Both Sarah Covington and Susan B. Iwanisziw's essays further recover the theatre's distinctive ability to manipulate boundaries of audience and performer—the former by examining early modern corporeal punishments, and the latter through correlating Elkanah Settle's dramatic output with the fluctuations of late seventeenth-century political upheaval.
Part 4, “Spectacular Failures,” brings the volume full circle, introducing a dialogue with Arendt on the dynamic between failure and violence. If the theatre's framing of violent spectacle can result in potentially productive pain and trauma, the question is still “what does—or can—failure and, thus, pain mean?” (138). In her analysis of Lavinia's rape in Ravenscroft's Titus, Kara Reilly reveals the complexity of the Restoration audience's “titillating experience of seeing a virtuous woman exposed” (139) onstage. Cecilia A. Feilla finds a shift in portrayals and receptions of filicide—from unstageably horrific to profoundly sympathetic—linked to the development of eighteenth-century sentimental theatre. Allard concludes with a refreshing take on Baillie's De Monfort, recognizing the incomprehensibility of the protagonist's hatred as a problem Baillie anticipated but ignored, and taking into account Baillie's revisions of her play for Kean as actor.
Staging Pain conveys a sense of enthusiasm for its project and insists on the capacity of the theatrical to relate uniquely to pain. Allard and Martin recognize that “trauma's temporal complexity poses problems for narrative and for historiography and literary criticism based on conventional understandings of narrative as linear and referential” (13), but theatre's active and interactive nature allows for a more complex and ironically realistic working out of these traumatic possibilities. Unfortunately, the reader might feel a similarly nonlinear effect with the recurring snippets of Scarry and Foucault that inundate the text, but the editors must be congratulated for demonstrating such widespread applicability of trauma theory to theatre. Occasionally the exuberance brought to such innovation gets carried too far; one essayist notes that “[i]ndeed, Amitor's trauma even conforms to the criteria for post-traumatic stress disorder as set out in the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM)” (35). But more often, the essays in Staging Pain passionately uncover details of historically neglected dramatic performances, display the diverse reverberations of trauma throughout the early modern theatre, and suggest the intrinsic ties between violence and the spectacular.
