Studies into Cicero's speeches and oratory continue to thrive; however, of the methods used to analyse Cicero's works, the comparison of Cicero's speeches to rhetorical theory has found little favour amongst scholars. As the subtitle ‘Critic in Action’ suggests, Usher's expressed wish is to assess the extent to which Cicero's oratory displayed the qualities he demanded from the model orator in his theoretical works. Yet, far from producing a study that mechanically applies the rhetorical precepts to the delivered oration, U.'s methodology is especially created around an understanding of Cicero's ideals. To this end, a brief introductory chapter serves to highlight the qualities, or ‘refinements’, that Cicero identified for successful oratory. Based on Brutus 322, U. notes eight refinements which he uses to assess Cicero's own performance in his published speeches. These refinements are further divided into two main criteria that the orator must possess: culture and eloquence.
The core of the book, chs 2–4, contains a chronological examination of all the complete speeches divided into three chapters that correspond to periods in Cicero's legal and political career. For each speech, U. provides a brief introduction, discusses the historical and forensic background, and notes stylistic points as they arise. These chapters will be of more interest to readers looking to learn more about a particular speech or Cicero's oratory at a certain period of his life; for the merits of U.'s approach are better displayed in the final chapters. Ch. 5 ‘Culture’ explores Cicero's deployment of four of the refinements: knowledge of (i) literature, (ii) philosophy, (iii) history, and (iv) law. Ch. 6 ‘Eloquence’ considers the remaining refinements: (v) humour, (vi) emotional appeal, (vii) digression, and (viii) dilatation. In their discussion of the refinements, these chapters provide a useful overview of the techniques of Cicero's oratory compared and contrasted across the full range of his extant speeches. Particularly worthy of comment is U.'s section on digressions which makes a convincing contribution to the question of what constitutes a digression in oratory. It may come as a surprise that U.'s recalculation of the number of digressions in Cicero's speeches makes it ‘the least frequently used of the eight refinements’ (241). Ch. 7 ‘Criticism and Performance’ concludes by examining Cicero's assessment both of his own oratory and that of his Roman predecessors. A useful section summarizes what we know about Roman oratory before Cicero and the chapter ends with a summary of Cicero's deployments of the refinements as identified and observed by U. throughout this careful study. The conclusion that Cicero often neglects to use the full range of these refinements in response to the need for flexibility in actual lawsuits will not come as a surprise to scholars of rhetoric (see, for example, Quint., Instit. Orat. 2.13). Yet the book laudably fulfills its promise to be the first systematic comparison between performance and aspiration in Cicero's speeches.
If there is a criticism of the book it is that the focus on the correspondence between Cicero's ideals and his practice raises many other questions that U. treats either too briefly or only implicitly. To take one example, what about speeches in which more than one speaker spoke? U. notes that Cicero tended to be the last speaker (191); this surely accounts for the high prevalance of emotional appeal. But I feel that this warrants further attention in U.'s concluding discussion which offers reasons for the incidence of refinements in Cicero's speeches. It should be added that readers expecting a full analysis of each oration will be disappointed; for they are examined primarily from the sole perspective with which U. is concerned. U.'s goal is to trace the occurrence of the refinements in Cicero's published orations and he presents historical, legal and other questions only as background for this purpose. I would provide considerably more guidance before setting students to work on the individual speeches; however, the chapters provide a good, general, companion for students interested in Ciceronian oratory. The accompanying glossary serves as a useful introduction to rhetorical tropes and figures and a select bibliography points the way for further study into the topics discussed.
