The motivations and actions of religious agents have increasingly become a focus of attention in scholarship over the last two decades, although the roots of this topic reach further back into the history of various disciplines. In archaeology, the potential of this topic has been noted and has started to be developed in stimulating research projects, such as the collaboration of the Écoles françaises d'Athènes et de Rome under the title ‘Des espaces et des rites: pour une archéologie du culte dans les sanctuaires du monde méditerranéen’ (2012–2016, under the direction of William Van Andringa and Sandrine Huber). Both this volume and its preceding meeting at Rome (18–20 June 2015) derive from this particular framework, and share the title Quand naissent les dieux: fondation des sanctuaires antiques: motivation, agents, lieux. This volume aims to discuss the circumstances and motives which contributed to cult foundations and the installation of architecture and structures in the sanctuaries.
A mere glance at the selection of topics for the contributions to the volume reveals that its scope was not limited to one specific historical period. The various chapters address, among other topics, the question of cult continuity from the Bronze and Early Iron Age into the earliest periods of archaic Greek culture; the periods of major cult foundations in early Greek times; large-scale monumentalisation in the late Classical and early Hellenistic periods; and the effects of increased Roman presence and Romanisation.
The volume comprises a total of twenty-two contributions, which are arranged in geographical and chronological order without any further division into sections. An introduction by the editors (S. Agusta-Boularot, S. Huber and W. Van Andringa: 1–9) and a concluding chapter by E. Lippolis, ‘Fondare un luogo di culto e costruire un luogo di culto e costruire un sistema sociale. Alcune osservazioni conclusive’ (397–410), provide a frame for the contributions. The geographical and chronological spectrum of this volume is vast, reaching from the Aegean and mainland Greece to Gaul, as well as from early Greek to Roman imperial times. The inclusion of case studies from both the eastern and western Mediterranean has to be welcomed, as helping to bridge the communication gap between Greek and Roman archaeology. Almost all of the contributions present case studies from individual sites or regions. Depending on the available evidence and the state of scholarship in the field, they inevitably put the emphasis on different aspects of the overall topic of the volume. A very rich but likewise heterogeneous picture therefore emerges from the contributions, which is further re-enforced by their quantity.
The initial nine chapters are dedicated to cult sites in various cultural zones of the wider Aegean world, such as the Cycladic islands (R. Étienne), Delphi (A. Jacquemin), Eretria (S. Huber), Thasos (A. Muller), Claros (N. Şahin), Xanthos (L. Cavalier and J. des Courtils) and Epidauros (V. Mathé). F. Quantin's contribution on the cults of Apollo and Artemis at Apollonia in Illyria (113–33) and F. de Polignac's chapter — the first of the sequence — on ‘Cités et sanctuaires dans le monde grec: de l'intérêt des décalages’ (11–18) both include discussion of the well-known concepts of the ‘civic deity’ and ‘polis-religion’, and clearly show their limits. But the authors of the other contributions also shed new light on their respective regions and sites, and in many cases lead us far beyond the structures and phases for which these sites are generally known. Religious life on the Cycladic islands, for instance, presents an interesting diversity once we leave Delos and turn to periods of early Greek cultural history. R. Étienne (19–32) argues for interpreting the situation as an ‘open system’ in which religious innovations seem to have been subject to situational demand. From A. Jacquemin, for instance, we learn that in comparison to other oracle cults, the unique characteristic of the oracle cult at Delphi consisted of the Pythia. S. Huber's observations on religious life at Eretria during its early phases (47–68) also draw a very different picture than might be expected from the presence of the later sanctuaries and cults at this site.
A further eight contributions to the volume are dedicated to examples from the Italian peninsula. They are marked by a greater variety of topics than the chapters on the wider Aegean world. Among the sites and regions represented we find Pompeii (A. Coutelas, T. Creissen and W. Van Andringa), Latium (F. Coarelli), the central Italian Adriatic regions (V. d'Ercole) and Lucania (O. de Cazanove). Several contributions deal with evidence and written sources related to Rome (P. Gros; J. Scheid), as well as Ostia (F. van Haeperen), or take a broader perspective of the Italian peninsula (S. Estienne). The issues discussed in these contributions touch upon very different aspects. The excavation results from the Temple of Fortuna Augusta at Pompeii provide new and valuable insights into the construction works of the temple building (A. Coutelas, T. Creissen and W. Van Andringa: 151–72). V. d'Ercole (183–99) re-introduces the region of the Abruzzi, where he observes the presence of various elements from Greek culture, to our attention. It is, however, the contribution by O. de Cazanove which accidentally illustrates what is missing in the range of topics and regions comprised in this volume (201–18). When the author underlines the discovery of a new type of religious architecture with square plan and central cella in Lucania, which allegedly predates the distribution of the Etrusco-Italian temple (212), the omission of any case study related to Etruria becomes particularly apparent. No explanation for this is given.
The final five contributions take the reader to Iron Age and Roman Gaul (R. Roure, A. Creuzieux and B. Girard; S. Agusta-Boularot; W. Van Andringa) and the western Hispanic peninsula (T. G. Schattner), as well as the Roman provinces of Achaia and Macedonia (F. Camia and A. Rizakis). These chapters broaden the picture which emerges from the volume so far by discussing aspects such as the analysis of animal bones and the issues of consumption and religious practices (Roure, Creuzieux and Girard; Agusta-Boularot). In their own chapters, Van Andringa, Schattner and Camia and Rizakis raise the question of the effects of cultural contacts and the presence of different cultural influences.
The diversity of approach in the many contributions to this volume provides the reader with very rich material. The individual chapters approach the overall topic of the volume — the circumstances and motives which contributed to cult foundations, and the installation of architecture and structures in sanctuaries — from many different perspectives. They thus offer a useful dialogue between scholarly traditions. The small inconsistencies in the selection of the case studies (e.g. the omission of Etruria) are forgivable in view of what the reader of French and Italian receives: a must-read for everyone interested in sanctuaries and the archaeology of religion.
