Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T08:18:19.880Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Disks settling in turbulence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 December 2019

L. B. Esteban*
Affiliation:
Aerodynamics and Flight Mechanics Group, University of Southampton, University Rd, SouthamptonSO17 1BJ, UK
J. S. Shrimpton
Affiliation:
Aerodynamics and Flight Mechanics Group, University of Southampton, University Rd, SouthamptonSO17 1BJ, UK
B. Ganapathisubramani
Affiliation:
Aerodynamics and Flight Mechanics Group, University of Southampton, University Rd, SouthamptonSO17 1BJ, UK
*
†Email address for correspondence: L.Blay-Esteban@soton.ac.uk

Abstract

This paper describes an experimental investigation of the dynamics of freely falling thin circular disks settling through turbulence. The patterns of the three-dimensional disk motion are studied using an orthogonal arrangement of two high speed cameras. Turbulence is generated in a water tank using a random jet array facility where the jets are mounted in a co-planar configuration. The facility is run continuously until turbulence reaches a statistically stationary state, then, all water pumps are turned off simultaneously and a disk is released after a given waiting time. Contrary to spherical particles, finite-size inertial disks show an increase in the descent velocity for turbulence velocity fluctuations smaller than the particle descent velocity in quiescent flow. Thus, we observe a severe increase of the mean descent velocity of the disk with increasing magnitude of the turbulence velocity fluctuations (up to $20\,\%$ of the velocity in quiescent flow for the disk with higher dimensionless inertia $I^{\ast }$). We also observe descent events that do not exist for disks falling in still fluid; i.e. ‘slow tumbling’ events and ‘levitating’ events. Finally, we show that the dominant frequency of the particle oscillatory motion decreases for increasing descent velocity and that particles exhibit oscillatory frequencies that never exceed the dominant frequency in quiescent flow by more than $30\,\%$.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© 2019 Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.(a) Sketch of the water tank equipped with a co-planar arrangement of random jet arrays. The central region of the frame allows optical access from the bottom; here, through a mirror at $45^{\circ }$. (b) Time evolution of the turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) during the decay; $q^{2}={u_{1}^{\prime }}^{2}+{2u_{2}^{\prime }}^{2}$. Time is made dimensionless with the eddy turnover time at the start of the decay ($t_{L}$) as $t^{\ast }=t/t_{L}$. Black markers stand for the measured TKE during the natural decay. The dashed-dotted line represents the best fit of the near field and the dashed line the best fit of the far field of the decay. The red, orange and yellow rectangles show the statistical turbulent kinetic energy that the disks will experience during the fall for $dt=2$, $10$, $20~\text{s}$, respectively.

Figure 1

Table 1.Main geometric and material parameters of the disks that define the Archimedes number ($Ar$) and the dimensionless moment of inertia ($I^{\ast }$), both defined in § 1.1.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Three-dimensional trajectory reconstruction of sections of the disk descent in quiescent flow. (a) Disk no. 1, (b) disk no. 2 and (c) disk no. 3. The particle dispersion is normalized with the disk diameter.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Reconstructed 3-D trajectories and ($X,Y$) planar projection for disk no. 1 released after of waiting time $dt=2$. The particle dispersion is normalized with the disk diameter.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Sketch of a disk falling under the effect of turbulence to illustrate how turbulent structures destabilize the particle near the turning points. The particle with dashed contours represents the particle trajectory in quiescent flow.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Reconstructed 3-D trajectories and $X{-}Y$ planar view released after of waiting time $dt=2$. The particle dispersion is normalized with the disk diameter. (a) Disk no. 1, (b,c) disk no. 2.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Reconstructed 3-D trajectories and ($X,Y$) planar projection for disk no. 3 released after of waiting time $dt=2$. The particle dispersion is normalized with the disk diameter. All three panels represent different realizations of disk no. 3 after the same waiting time.

Figure 7

Figure 7.‘Slow’ event during the descend of disk no. 1 under turbulence effects released after a waiting time $dt=2$. (a) Reconstructed 3-D trajectory with the dispersion normalized with the disk diameter, green dots show the start and end of the ‘slow’ subsection. (b,c) Time evolution of the particle speed and particle descent velocity, the green shaded region showing the ‘slow’ subsection.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Fast tumbling event during the descend of disk no. 1 under turbulence effects released after a waiting time $dt=2$. The red marker shows the location of the tumbling event. (a) Reconstructed 3-D trajectory with the dispersion normalized with the disk diameter. (b) Reconstructed top view of the trajectory with the dispersion normalized with the disk diameter showing that the $X{-}Y$ disk direction before and after the event remains nearly the same. (c) Time evolution of the particle nutation angle ($\unicode[STIX]{x1D703}$) during the descent.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Normalized power density spectrum as a function of the Strouhal number. The peak in the spectrum is used to identify the characteristic particle Strouhal number. The dotted line represents no. 1, the dashed-dotted line disk no. 2 and the solid line disk no. 3, all descending in quiescent flow.

Figure 10

Table 2.Values of the mean descent velocity of all realizations ($\langle V_{z}\rangle$), particle Reynolds number ($Re$) and Strouhal number ($St=f\cdot D/V_{z}$) based on the dominant frequency of the descent velocity in quiescent flow.

Figure 11

Table 3.Values of the particle–turbulence velocity ratio ($\langle V_{z}\rangle /u^{\prime }$), frequency ratio ($f_{q}\unicode[STIX]{x1D706}/u^{\prime }$) and main turbulent structure to particle diameter ratios, where $f_{q}$ stands for the dominant fluttering frequency in quiescent flow, $L$ for the integral length scale, $\unicode[STIX]{x1D706}$ for the Taylor length scale and $\unicode[STIX]{x1D702}$ for the Kolmogorov length scale.

Figure 12

Table 4.Values of the particle descent velocity for the three flow conditions at different waiting times during the turbulence decay. The mean descent velocity and the standard deviation of the $200$ realizations per case are shown. Units are $\text{mm s}^{-1}$.

Figure 13

Figure 10.Evolution of the mean descent velocity of inertial disks under turbulent conditions ($\langle V_{z_{t}}\rangle$) as a function of the turbulence intensity. The descent velocity of the particles is normalized using the mean descent velocity of the particle in quiescent flow ($\langle V_{z}\rangle$). Dotted line stands for disk no. 1, broken line for disk no. 2 and solid line for disk no. 3.

Figure 14

Figure 11.Probability density function (PDF) of the ratio of the measured mean descent velocity for disks falling in background turbulence to the measured mean descent velocity of the disks in quiescent flow. The colours of the PDF stand for flow configurations: black for quiescent flow, yellow for $dt=20$, orange for $dt=10$ and red for $dt=2$. (a) Disk no. 1, (b) disk no. 2 and (c) disk no. 3.

Figure 15

Figure 12.Cumulative density function of the mean descent velocity normalized with the mean descent velocity of the disks in quiescent flow. The colours of the CDF stand for flow configurations: yellow for $dt=20$, orange for $dt=10$ and red for $dt=2$. (a) Disk no. 1, (b) disk no. 2 and (c) disk no. 3.

Figure 16

Table 5.Values of the integral time scale ($t_{L}$), Taylor length scale ($t_{\unicode[STIX]{x1D706}}$) and Kolmogorov length scale ($\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}_{\unicode[STIX]{x1D702}}$) for the three flow conditions. Units in seconds.

Figure 17

Figure 13.Normalized power spectral density of the velocity fluctuations in the vertical direction. The colours of the PSDs stand for flow configurations: black for quiescent flow, yellow for $dt=20$, orange for $dt=10$ and red for $dt=2$. (a) Disk no. 1, (b) disk no. 2 and (c) disk no. 3.

Figure 18

Figure 14.Mean descent velocity of disks in turbulent flow as a function of the dominant frequency observed in the fluctuations of the descent velocity. Velocity and frequency are normalized with the values of the quiescent cases, given in table 2. The colours in the scatter plot stand for flow configurations: black for quiescent flow, yellow for $dt=20$, orange for $dt=10$ and red for $dt=2$. (a) Disk no. 1, (b) disk no. 2 and (c) disk no. 3.

Figure 19

Figure 15.Normalized power spectral density of the descent velocity fluctuations. The red lines stand for the conditional averaged trajectories ‘slow’ trajectories in (a), ‘fast’ trajectories in (b). The black lines correspond to the data for quiescent flow. The line styles represent the three different particles; dotted line for disk no. 1, broken line for disk no. 2 and solid line for disk no. 3.