Introduction
In his widely cited and influential article, “Should Trees Have Standing?,” Christopher Stone argued for conferring legal personality and rights on the environment because, as a rights-holder, the natural object would “have a legally recognised worth and dignity in its own right, and not merely to serve as a means to benefit ‘us.’”Footnote 1 In his dissenting opinion in Sierra Club v. Morton,Footnote 2 Justice William O. Douglas similarly argued that “inanimate objects” should have standing to sue in court.Footnote 3 Neither of these esteemed authors posited human rights for nature, but the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACtHR) delivered an advisory opinion on May 29, 2025 that does so.Footnote 4 Contrary to the Court’s finding, “rights for/of nature” do not exist in international human rights law nor are they likely to become part of this field or of international environmental law. Moreover, in my opinion, it is unnecessary to advocate for nature’s rights because existing constitutions, legislation, and legal doctrines will provide equivalent protections if they are properly enforced.
The Inter-American Advisory Opinion
In its advisory opinion, the IACtHR examines states’ human rights obligations with respect to “the climate emergency.” The Court focuses much of its attention on the right to a healthy environment, which it had indicated previously is one of the rights protected by Article 26 of the American Convention on Human Rights.Footnote 5 It reiterates the statement from its 2017 advisory opinion on human rights and the environment that the right to a healthy environment protects the components of the environment, such as forests, rivers, and seas, as legal rights in themselves, even in the absence of certainty or evidence of the risk to the individual.Footnote 6
In elaborating on the protection of nature as a subject of rights, the Court relies on its understanding that degradation or alteration of any component of an ecosystem may have a negative impact on other species, including human beings, who are part of such a system. From this, the Court finds that a recognition of “Nature’s right to conserve its essential ecological processes contributes to strengthening a truly sustainable development model that respects planetary limits and ensures the availability of crucial resources for present and future generations.”Footnote 7 Progressing toward the recognition of rights inherent in ecosystems is “fundamental for the protection of their long-term integrity and functionality, and it provides coherent and effective legal tools in relation to the triple planetary crisis to prevent existential harm before the latter becomes irreversible.”Footnote 8
The Court appears to envisage the recognition of rights for nature as a progressive action in international law, lege ferenda not lex lata. It refers to “transcending inherited legal concepts” and sets forth policy arguments for recognizing rights in nature, emphasizing the essential role of nature in balancing conditions that make Earth habitable and efforts aimed at achieving sustainable development.
The Court seems to see itself as proposing something that does not currently exist in international human rights law. Nevertheless, in its view, the recognition of nature’s rights is a development that does not introduce content alien to the Inter-American corpus iuris. Rather, it represents “a contemporary expression of the principle of the interdependence between human rights and the environment.”Footnote 9 The Court observes that this interpretation is also aligned with advances in international environmental law aimed at preserving the integrity of ecosystems, and notes jurisprudence at the national level and United Nations resolutions and reports that “reflect the increasing recognition of the case law on the Earth and the rights of nature at the global level.”Footnote 10
Analyzing the Court’s Advisory Opinion
The Court’s analysis goes beyond the fundamental rules of treaty interpretation. The American Convention and indeed all human rights treaties are for the protection of the rights of human beings, not other species or nature as a whole. Writing in dissent, Judge Patricia Pérez Goldberg observes correctly that if states want to extend the scope of the treaty in this way they can and should amend the treaty to do so.Footnote 11 Absent such amendment, the Court is acting outside its jurisdiction to create a new category of protected entities with unspecified rights. Notably, the Court cites only soft law instruments, like the World Charter for Nature, in proposing legal status and rights for nature. The dissent again correctly notes that no hard law recognizing such rights exists in international law.Footnote 12
Yet the Court finds “a growing tendency in legislation and case law to recognize nature as a subject of rights.”Footnote 13 It cites six cases from Latin American courts, one from Germany and several from India as evidence of this “growing tendency.” Several examples of domestic legislation are cited, but apart from two instances, they all concern either rights guaranteed for an identified Indigenous People, or protection provided for a single resource, like a river. The well-known example of Ecuador’s Constitution, which recognizes Mother Earth or Pacha Mama as having rights, is almost unique.Footnote 14
Although there is little support for codification of rights of nature, the Court finds it necessary to counter the “risks of an existential nature,” through a universal and effective legal response. The Court thus asserts a biological necessity to create nature’s rights, viewing “the balance of conditions for healthy life in the common ecosystem” as a requirement for the present and future habitability of the planet.Footnote 15 Therefore, the Court concludes, legal protection for rights of nature is essential to ensure the protection of human rights.Footnote 16
What Is the Difference Between Human and Natural Rights?
Distinguishing between human and natural rights provokes the question: what distinguishes a human from other entities? “Natural persons,” the term used to refer to human beings, have certain legal rights adhering automatically upon birth. An entity labeled a natural person is genetically human. A legal or “juridical” person refers to an entity that is not a human being, but one on which society has decided to confer specific rights and obligations. In international law, states and intergovernmental organizations have legal personality; in domestic law, business and charitable organizations, municipalities, and other government bodies are recognized as legal persons.Footnote 17
One basis for personhood rests on the interests of the entity in question. Another basis considers the interests of human persons as a baseline for comparison.Footnote 18 Persons have rights, duties, and obligations; things do not.Footnote 19 According to the legal philosopher Joel Feinberg, an entity must have interests to have moral status.Footnote 20 Bonnie Steinbock adds that “interests” is a term of art which refers to the capacity of an entity to have a stake in things, and this capacity is contingent on the entity being sentient, or consciously aware.Footnote 21 “Interests” in this sense refers to an entity having “a sake or welfare of its own” and “the expression … is intended to emphasize the stake that conscious, sentient beings have in their own well-being.”Footnote 22 If an entity does not have interests in the sense identified above, then a determination of legal personhood must be based on the protection of the interests of others.
The idea that the law might exclude from legal status an entity that meets all the requirements for equal moral status with currently recognized persons, but that is not genetically human, raises the question of why humanness matters.Footnote 23 It seems inconsistent to argue for the extension of legal protection to a non-sentient multi-celled human organism in the beginning stages of development (i.e., an embryo) and withhold such protections from fully developed sentient, and perhaps even rational, non-human animals.Footnote 24 If genetics is the sole basis for legal personhood, there must be some explanation as to why this characteristic is so important.Footnote 25 Thus far, as Jessica Berg comments, no one has provided a satisfactory argument.Footnote 26
The concept of nature’s rights and legal personality has been proposed in a variety of formulations. In some cases, elements of nature such as rivers have been protected with rights language. Giving legal recognition to the intrinsic value of the whole of nature, by adding it as a new subject of law, is a more far-reaching proposal.Footnote 27
Procedures and Limitations
Those in favor of rights for natural entities argue that allowing nature to sue in its own right would mean that more individuals who have previously escaped liability may face sanctions for their destructive behavior, and provide a plaintiff for cases involving environmental degradation. This raises the question of who can speak on behalf of nature.
Conferring legal personality on any part of nature should allow legal action to be brought in the name of the rights-holder through a “guardian ad litem.” Representation by the government may not serve to protect the intrinsic value of the environment, especially where the government’s short-term interests conflict with more long term ecological interests. Governments normally issue mining and forestry licenses, control water rights, and decide on oil exploration and exploitation permits. Such licenses and permits may generate considerable revenues for the state. Moreover, because governments are responsible to the whole population, they may be willing to permit a certain level of environmental degradation in the name of sustainable development.
One way to address such issues is by providing representation, in whole or part, to Indigenous Peoples. A well-known agreement established legal personhood for the Whanganui River, with the river’s rights to be enforced through judicial action by appointed guardians.Footnote 28 The local Maori Iwi (tribe) and hapu (sub-tribes) hold the river sacred and consider the entire river system to be a living being, Te Awa Tupua. The river itself has been the subject of a longstanding native title claim by the Iwi, who claim possession of the river, its resources, and the continued existence of rangatiratanga (chieftainship or ownership) over the river and its taonga (treasured tangible and intangible items). The Iwi and the New Zealand government reached an agreement, codified into law in 2017, recognizing Te Awa Tupua as having “all the rights, powers, duties, and liabilities of a legal person.”Footnote 29 The law creates the office of Te Pou Tupua “to be the human face of Te Awa Tupua and act in the name of Te Awa Tupua,” including by promoting and protecting the health and well-being of Te Awa Tupua and performing landowner functions for and on behalf of Te Awa Tupua.Footnote 30 The office is composed of two persons, one nominated by the Iwi and one by the government.Footnote 31
The fact that this agreement concerns an Indigenous group likely affected the outcome of the negotiations, especially in the light of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP).Footnote 32 Indeed, it is not obvious how recognition of the rights of Te Awa Tupua differs significantly in effectiveness from recognizing the rights of the Indigenous People in their ancestral land.
Are Rights of Nature Really Necessary?
I think that they are not. Nature is already protected through a variety of laws and legal constructs, although they often fall short of adequate enforcement. Protecting Indigenous rights such as those set out in UNDRIP is one such possibility. Of course, not all parts of nature are home to Indigenous Peoples.
Another alternative to recognizing rights of nature is to declare nature or key parts of it to be a public trust. From Roman law antecedents,Footnote 33 early English common law distinguished between private property which could be owned by individuals and common resources which were held in inalienable trust for present and future generations. Many U.S. courts have applied this concept to a variety of resources, holding that the government may not destroy or alienate property within the public trust.Footnote 34
In the early 1970s, the public trust doctrine began to be applied to wildlife and public lands, and incorporated in state constitutions in the United States.Footnote 35 Pennsylvania adopted the first constitutional recognition of protection of nature through the public trust doctrine.Footnote 36 The author of the proposal said that he intended to “give our natural environment the same kind of constitutional protection that [is] given our political rights.”Footnote 37 The proposed amendment was approved overwhelmingly by voters in the state on May 18, 1971.Footnote 38 Many other state constitutional provisions refer to long-established doctrines of public trust.Footnote 39 Hawaii’s constitution, for example, creates a public trust over all of the state’s natural resources “for the benefit of present and future generations; all public natural resources are held in trust by the State for the benefit of the people.”Footnote 40 Other state constitutional provisions are less direct, but rely on aspects of public trust doctrine such as conservation and common use.Footnote 41 The public trust doctrine emphasizes the duties of the trustee to preserve the corpus of the trust for the future rather than the individual rights of the beneficiaries.Footnote 42 It thus takes a long term, transgenerational approach.
Notably, most of the constitutional amendments were enacted because the ordinary political process was failing to protect what the public viewed as the fundamental value of a healthy environment. Public trusts, like national parks and other protected areas, establish a preferential legal status for specific ecosystems or their components, but they normally are constituted for the beneficial use of humans, not necessarily for the direct and primary benefit of the ecosystem or its elements. Public trusts have the advantage over protected areas that the former are normally given constitutional status, while the latter are established by ordinary legislation and can be abolished or diminished in the same way.
Conclusion
In conclusion, nature does not have human rights under existing human rights law and does not need to have such rights. What it does need is vigorous enforcement of existing laws and constitutional provisions, including doctrines such as those declaring public trusts over nature. If the existing constitutional and legislative provisions were to be fully enforced, they could achieve the same ends as would rights of nature, without the complications raised by enacting the new concept. In the reverse scenario, rights of nature could achieve many equivalent results as would existing constitutional and legislative provisions and the doctrine of public trust, but only if rights of nature were properly defined and limited rather than based on wholesale guarantees for the entire biosphere. The confusion likely to result from placing this concept alongside human rights argues for keeping the focus on human rights for human beings.
