The main argument of William Selinger's book Parliamentarism: From Burke to Weber is that the scholarship on the idea of liberalism in political theory has been lacking one significant dimension. A group of major European political thinkers who are commonly associated with liberalism were, more importantly, proponents of the parliamentary form of government. The theory of parliamentarism was a reaction against Montesquieu's account of the English constitution, the opposite of which has been taken as a given in recent scholarship on liberal constitutionalism (8). Moreover, the rise of democracy has tended to overshadow parliamentarism in the history of political thought (17).
Instead of focusing on constitutional or institutional transformations in parliamentary regimes, and drawing attention to the historical development of parliamentarism in terms of institutional markers as in historical institutionalism, the book traces the political thinking behind the parliamentary form of government. Edmund Burke, Benjamin Constant, Germaine de Staël, Alexis de Tocqueville, John Stuart Mill, Walter Bagehot, Max Weber are a few of the authors that Selinger covers in tracing this idea of parliamentarism. He argues that the French Revolution was the political impetus for parliamentarism, as it turned the idea into a paradigm of a free state across Europe (9) and profoundly influenced the debates about constitutionalism. The book further discusses how some of the major political thinkers of the eighteenth to the twentieth centuries were actively involved in trying to formulate the best possible way to fight against arbitrary power, and thus to protect political liberty, through the idea of parliamentarism. This study is a major undertaking, and Selinger clearly has an excellent command of his field.
As the book illustrates, the classical parliamentary form of government is defined by four characteristics: a powerful elected legislative assembly, ministers who could remain in office only with parliamentary support, a constitutional monarch without official prerogatives, and a system of party competition for power in parliament. These aspects, it is shown, are embedded in the writings of liberal thinkers. In addition to discussing the writings of well-known political thinkers, the book introduces some lesser-known authors. One of them was the Geneva-born Jean-Louis de Lolme (1740–1806) who in his The Constitution of England (1771) “accepted a House of Commons that was the dominant constitutional power” (45). The author shows that, instead of having agreed with Montesquieu, de Lolme argued directly against him. In this way, de Lolme was a defender of parliamentarism.
The book focuses on theories about parliamentarism as a political regime. This perspective is rather narrow compared to current scholarship which engages in discussions of parliamentary deliberation, culture, debates, and procedures. The book makes some references to the dynamics between parliamentarism and the art of public speaking while discussing, for example, Tocqueville's critique of increasing parliamentary deliberation as a result of political corruption. It does not take into consideration, however, the broader parliamentary cultures of debate which were realized in associations and clubs promoting public speaking and debate since the eighteenth century. Also, the procedural aspect of parliamentarism is crucial, as it is one of the key aspects of the political mechanisms of parliamentary form of government. Nevertheless, as a contribution to the history of thought on parliaments as political regimes, the book has much to offer.
The origins of parliamentarism derive from the English constitution, in which the idea of an elected assembly to deliberate political action and hold executive officials responsible was considered essential. In Edmund Burke's words, the presence of responsible ministers in Parliament was “the most noble and refined part of our constitution” (76). As the dominant colonial power in the nineteenth century, Britain was the major political regime of the era and had immense influence on the global stage. The Victorian political thinkers offered some of the most influential views of parliamentarism, which are still present in contemporary political theory. As the book shows, in their writings Walter Bagehot, Thomas Macaulay, and John Stuart Mill recognized the constitutional practice in which the monarch should reign but not govern as a political principle on the basis of which English politics operated. Selinger points out that it was actually Benjamin Constant who first articulated the British tradition of parliamentarism in the maxim Le roi règne et ne gouverne pas (182). This dictum was a common point of reflection for the Victorians who were the first to try to reconcile parliamentarism with democracy. But there were some profound dilemmas related to the pressures of democracy on the parliamentary system.
While the book explicates the theories of parliamentarism by liberal authors, it also discusses the major dilemmas of parliamentarism. The writings showed concerns about the role of monarch as well as corruption and political ambition (11). For example, the problem of corruption was a theme in the work of John Stuart Mill, who despite his progressive thinking was a proponent of constitutional monarchy. Selinger is able to convincingly show that Mill's parliamentary theory was much indebted to Benjamin Constant. They both agreed that the principle of a responsible executive, which would safeguard against the threat of cabinet instability, was dependent on the condition that the monarch reigns but does not govern (185).
Selinger's book is a much-needed contribution, not just in the field of the history of political thought, but also as a history of liberalism. It shows that, before the early twentieth century, parliamentarism was largely understood in relation to constitutional monarchy, and the executive officials under parliamentary government were conceived of as subordinate to the legislative assembly. Since then, however, the increasing powers of the executive in parliament have shifted the political framework to such questions as agenda setting and public scrutiny of party government. I agree with the author that the idea of parliamentarism is remarkably persistent, providing important points of reflection to the current political challenges facing parliamentary democracies. Despite the current talk of “crisis of democracy,” there is no alternative theory to replace parliamentarism. The book challenges the idea of the decline of parliamentary government by portraying its history as adaptable to new challenges.
