Theater and Spectacle in the Art of the Roman Empire is an extraordinary and valuable contribution to the study and understanding of ancient theatre—in my view the most important, comprehensive, and wide-ranging since Margarete Bieber's groundbreaking History of the Greek and Roman Theatre (Princeton, 1961). Like that seminal work, which undertook to address the full panoply of ancient theatre history by not confining its focus to dramatic literature (as many previous studies had done), this book's great strength arises from its broad scope, the depth and detail of its account and analysis, and especially the support provided by an extensive collection of invaluable illustrations. Many of these images are made accessible here for the first time. Several of the sites Dunbabin describes, and whose artifacts she closely assesses, have not been previously published.
Recent decades have seen a proliferation of often admirably detailed individual studies of the myriad activities that, in aggregate, comprised the sprawling variety of ancient theatrical art. These works have encompassed the literary genres of tragedy and comedy, the great diversity of entertainments comprising mime, the vastly popular comic and tragic genres of pantomime, circus races, competitive sporting displays, and the array of spectacles taking place in the arena, including elaborate scenic shows of hunts, executions, and gladiatorial combat. The massive expansion of traditional “theatre studies” to embrace so many activities has encouraged some scholars to take a synthetic approach, recognizing and detailing the interrelationships and the prevalent artistic and cultural cross-fertilization among them.
Dunbabin does this in great detail and with consummate authority, her discussion crucially supported by a comprehensive collection, display, and analysis of a huge variety of material evidence, most of it illustrated in color. She includes and explicates mosaics, public monuments, paintings, statues, vases, funerary monuments, and inscriptions and objects of every sort. Some of these materials, beyond providing vivid depictions of performers, settings, and activities, carry us as readers into the very midst and moment of particular ancient performances. They chronicle instances from actual enactments and even record the words of their participants, including in some cases the acclamations of the spectators as they were chanted out at a particular event. For example, mosaics from a bath complex in Rome dating from the fourth century ad, commemorating and vividly depicting moments from a gladiatorial exhibition sponsored by a magistrate named Symmachus, record both the shouts of the crowd and the utterances of the combatants. As Dunbabin notes, “With these words, then, viewers are transported right into the amphitheater itself” (219). A third-century ad mosaic from Tunisia illustrates a staged hunting spectacle showing the slaying of leopards; names the hunters and animals; and records the announcement by the herald, the subsequent acclamations of the crowd, and their praise for the sponsor of the games, Magerius: “Let those to come learn from your example, let those who are gone hear of it! Where was there anything like this? When was there anything like this? … This is wealth, this is power, this is now” (200; original emphasis). The result of such detail is a work that provides both the single most comprehensive account of theatrical activity in antiquity and the fullest compendium of illustrative material yet to appear.
In Dunbabin's words, “It is my hope that the many works discussed in the course of this book will … serve to provide a picture of the culture of a vast and varied area over the centuries of the later Empire, a picture that goes far beyond the evidence offered by the written sources” (17). This approach enables her book to achieve a remarkable cohesion throughout its eight chapters, which, although focused variously upon the individual genres of theatre and spectacle, ultimately reveal and convey to the reader a detailed and nuanced appreciation of ancient cultural continuity and theatrical practice across a sprawling chronological and geographic expanse. Dunbabin skilfully draws attention to important differences between the practice and underlying ideological factors conditioning performance in the western and eastern areas of the Empire. To take one single but extremely important example, the extensive integration of materials separated both geographically and chronologically enables major insights illuminating where, when, and how particular genres evolved and were practiced. Very significantly, she identifies and discusses persuasive evidence proving beyond doubt the (much disputed) continuation of many of these genres—including “traditional” dramatic performance—far longer than most conventional scholarship has suggested. Visual representations of performers of comedy and tragedy persisted into the fourth century, and literary references to such performance at least into the sixth. “Such performance may often have consisted of extracts from famous works, single scenes or salient episodes … but nothing justifies the assumption that the performance of full plays had entirely disappeared” (84).
Inevitably, a book as comprehensive as this will serve very ably as an invaluable and much-needed encyclopedia of visual resources and locations. This capacity is greatly facilitated, moreover, by the book's provision of a full bibliography and an extensive general index, as well as two additional indexes, of ancient sources and of sites and monuments. However, beyond this, and despite its length, there is very considerable benefit in reading the book as a whole so as to perceive and appreciate the full incremental sweep of Dunbabin's scholarship, knowledge, and perceptive analysis. Taken as a narrative, rather than a compendium—however detailed—of source material, the text is clearly written, cogently organized, closely argued, and offers the reader persuasive and judicious conclusions about a range of disputed topics. It is entirely unencumbered by jargon or the imposition of arcane theory and entirely free from errors of proofing or typos. Dunbabin has produced a masterpiece of scholarship that greatly enriches and extends our understanding and knowledge of the variety, content, geographical span, cultural importance, and endurance of the theatrical arts of antiquity.
