It is well known that John Adams was a remarkable political theorist—that in addition to helping to found a political community, he also discovered original political ideas. But if Adams's intellectual discovery is well known, much less is known about his intellectual journey. In the preface to John Adams's Republic: The One, the Few, and the Many, Richard Alan Ryerson writes that no one has explained how and why Adams arrived at his distinctive political philosophy. It is fitting that Ryerson, who served for nearly two decades as editor in chief of the Massachusetts Historical Society's Adams Papers project, should be the first to embrace this task.
Students of political ideas might doubt that Ryerson's careful telling of Adams's intellectual journey is worthwhile. The political theorist who picks up John Adams's Republic will likely grow impatient, at times, with the author's penchant for accumulated detail, and might ask whether it is worthwhile to immerse oneself in the story of how Adams arrived at his ideas when what really matters is the ideas themselves. But an implicit and ultimately persuasive argument of Ryerson's book is that Adams's journey is a lens through which we can examine his discovery.
Adams's fear of aristocratic elites, a fear that Ryerson rightly identifies as “the central anxiety of his political philosophy,” is illustrative in this regard. Adams's worry becomes much more compelling—both in his own context and in ours—once we understand how he arrived at it. Ever since Gordon Wood's account of Adams's political thought in his seminal Creation of the American Republic, historians have tended to view Adams's preoccupation with aristocracy as a premodern concern. Adams remained obsessed with aristocracy, the story went, because he was out of touch with the emergent democratic culture. Ryerson's detailed account of the development of Adams's theory of aristocracy throws new light on the relevance of Adams's view. According to Ryerson, Adams was a close observer of the democratic currents of the day. He knew well the turbulent social forces unleashed by the war and the egalitarian culture the Revolution had left in its wake. But as Ryerson writes, Adams was also keenly aware that new equalities were accompanied by an emergence of “an aristocracy of new men and new wealth” (16).
The disruption of old trade patterns and the creation of new armies generated opportunities for profiteering as new supplies were needed along with privateers who could secure those supplies. Meanwhile, the rapid expansion of government activity required a new flow of paper money, leading to “a commercial bonanza of heretofore unimagined proportions” (232). By focusing our attention not just on Adams's theory of aristocracy but on the social-economic observations underpinning that theory, Ryerson reveals Adams to have been not a premodern theorist of Old World aristocracy but instead a prescient critic of the way that aristocratic power would persist in the modern democratic era.
A distinct charm of Ryerson's book is its description of Adams's appetite for political philosophy. Our second president was “a man who lived a full, complex life of the mind, coupled indissolubly with an active public life” (84). As Ryerson tells it, Adams spent his vacations thinking. Whenever he took time off to rest, he would quickly grow weary of intellectual idleness. He complained to his diary during the first vacation of his political career that “my Brains have been barren. … My Soul has been starved” (81). During later vacations, Adams would assiduously avoid this dreaded idleness by applying his mind to political philosophy. In August 1784, following years of strenuous work as a diplomat in France and Holland, Adams reunited with his family and moved into a quiet residence in the Paris suburb of Auteuil, where he finally had time for calm domestic life. But rather than take the opportunity to rest, Adams set himself the task of systematically reading all of Plato's dialogues. Adams focused especially on Plato's Laws and Republic in those months, moving back and forth between parallel Greek and Latin texts alongside French and English translations. His mind could not sit still.
One shortcoming of the book relates to Ryerson's treatment of the central theme of Adams's political thought: the phenomenon of aristocratic power. In his account of the Defence of the Constitutions, Adams's magnum opus, Ryerson writes that Adams does not closely examine the nature of aristocracy in that work, and that a more theoretically sophisticated account would only appear in Adams's later writings. This is partly correct. As Ryerson notes, most of Adams's treatment of aristocracy in the Defence takes the form of a historical and not a theoretical account. However, in the remarkable fourth chapter of volume 1, Adams clarifies his distinct view of aristocracy as rooted primarily in family name and wealth. Furthermore, he elaborates in detail the way that wealth generates power through advantageous social networks, through relationships of economic dependency between the rich and the poor, and, most intriguingly of all, through the propensity of the common citizenry to admire the rich.
By the final chapters of John Adams's Republic, Ryerson makes clear that Adams viewed aristocracy not primarily in terms of merit—as Jefferson did—but in terms of wealth and birth. However, Ryerson is at other times unclear on this point. At the outset of the book, he describes Adams as preoccupied with an aristocracy consisting of society's most talented and ambitious. “Talented minorities,” writes Ryerson, “would always find ways to defend themselves against less talented majorities” (9). But in fact, Adams was a shrewd critique of the concept of “talent.” Consider Adams's letter to Benjamin Rush in which he describes George Washington's “ten talents,” among them “a handsome face,” “a tall stature,” and “a large imposing fortune.” Ryerson reads the letter as pointing to the complexity of aristocracy, which Adams understood as, in Ryerson's words, a “potent fusion of inherited and acquired ingredients” (379). But in fact Adams was more cynical. The intention of the “ten talents” letter was to demonstrate the human propensity to redescribe inherited qualities in terms of talent and virtue. “Fashion has introduced an indeterminate Use of the Word ‘Talents,’” Adams complained in his retirement-era correspondence with Jefferson. He reminded Jefferson that the very words then used to designate virtuous character, such as “gentleman” and “generosity,” were derived from the Latin generosus and the Greek eugenēs, roots meaning “not of mean birth” and “born of a noble race” (The Adams-Jefferson Letters [University of North Carolina Press, 1959], 398, 366). Human beings had a long history of translating inherited privilege into signs of merit.
Ultimately, the shortcomings of John Adams's Republic are almost negligible in the context of the book's larger achievement. By telling the story of Adams's intellectual journey, Reyerson has revealed the great extent to which our nation's foremost constitutional theorist spent a life preoccupied with vexing problems of modern politics—problems that most Americans have preferred to ignore. The role of unitary-executive power in a revolutionary society, the way that oligarchic power can persist and even thrive in an egalitarian political culture—these were problems that engaged John Adams over a lifetime, and not merely as abstractions but as eminently practical matters that demanded a constitutional response.
It is often said that America is essentially a nation of Lockean liberalism. Following the principles of John Locke's Second Treatise, Americans have placed the utmost value on the right of the individual to strive and prosper in accordance with his or her merits, unconstrained by governmental interference and free from the tyrannical tendencies of majorities. Government, on this view, is primarily an enabler of enterprise and a protector of the private property that is the fruit of enterprise.
Historians have debated the true depth of this tradition's roots, with some arguing that the leading thinkers of the founding generation were exemplary Lockeans and others arguing that they were instead civic-minded “republicans,” and that Lockean liberalism did not take hold until a later date. Ryerson's John Adams's Republic suggests an important amendment to the liberal self-understanding of Americans. Unlike Madison, who followed Locke by asserting that government's primary object was to protect “the diversity of the faculties of men from which the rights of property originate,” John Adams insisted that the primary object of government was the happiness and security of the society (269). And for Adams, the primary threat to happiness and security was not the tendency of majorities or of governments to oppress the enterprising individual, but rather the tendency of the socially strong few to oppress the socially weak many. Ryerson's book suggests that acquainting ourselves with the intellectual journey of John Adams enables us to appreciate a neglected jewel of our national inheritance. If we have inherited a liberal tradition, we have also inherited an anti-oligarchic one.
