In this volume Valerie Hope advocates a holistic approach to Roman death, charting the path from pre-death planning to the afterlife. Chronicling the process of dying, and noting the extent to which it was a part of everyday life, the volume also provides an accessible introduction to the subject, with individual chapters addressing different aspects of dying, disposal or commemoration, and illustrated with archaeological, epigraphic and textual examples. From the start H. emphasizes a number of interweaving themes, including gender, memory and identity, but is also keen to highlight the significance of continuity and change, as well as interactions between the living and the dead. These themes will be familiar to specialists, but for the undergraduate or non-specialist reader they provide a useful structuring device for the volume and allow H. to demonstrate the benefits of an interdisciplinary approach.
Beginning with mortality, H. summarizes the philosophical debates concerning death, wills, the building of tombs and memory. This is followed by the many ways in which a person might die, and the importance amongst élite circles of ‘dying well’, with the subsequent chapter devoted to the funeral itself. Here H. stresses the difficulties of recreating these events without generating a funeral that is dislocated in time and space, but argues that doing so brings this problem into focus and raises new questions about the relevance, significance and practicality of these activities to disparate groups within the Empire (66–7). H. also acknowledges that her narrative is focused heavily on the city of Rome and, although occasional examples from provincial settings are highlighted, the picture is skewed very much in favour of the Italian urban setting of the first century b.c. to second century a.d. Ch. 4 considers the fate of the soul and the underworld, asserting that religion acted as a ‘common currency’ rather than something everyone believed in. Mourning and grief form the core of the following chapter, in which the literary and epigraphic evidence for emotions are drawn together. The final chapter examines cemeteries, highlighting the importance and limitations of information gleaned from epitaphs. An Epilogue reasserts the key themes of the volume, in particular the central role of the dead in the lives of the living. Here H. calls for ‘more joined-up thinking’ when it comes to the various rituals, activities, and monuments caught up with Roman death (185–6).
H. advocates a less discipline-specific approach than is evident within some recent scholarship, suggesting that examining the bigger picture may not always be detrimental. Although an interdisciplinary methodology clearly has its merits, the problems created by a broad brush approach are nevertheless difficult to overcome, as demonstrated by the narrow focus of this volume and the fact that H. does not offer many answers to the questions she poses: there is simply too much to deal with. Any attempt to synthesize Roman funerary customs will confront this problem and H.'s book should not be unduly singled out for criticism of its narrow geographical focus or the fact that some important elements, such as the disposal of the body itself and grave goods, are mentioned only briefly. The chapter on cemeteries and monuments is, however, rather cursory given the wealth of excavated data recovered from sites across Rome and Italy in recent years and new approaches to place, landscape and performance. H. suggests that new methodologies should be adopted for studies of Roman death but exactly what these are, and their theoretical underpinnings, are not always made explicit.
This volume does not argue anything particularly innovative, but it offers a relatively up-to-date account of what we ‘know’ about Roman death that allows the author to raise questions about what we do not know: how do changes in epigraphic content or frequency relate to changes in practice from cremation to inhumation? How and why did groups outside of Italy respond to these traditionally Roman activities in particular ways? The emphasis placed on considering the sometimes detached elements of the funeral as part of a more complex, connected process is also a valuable reminder of the intricacies of dying. One excellent aspect of the volume is that it can be used in conjunction with H.'s (2007) sourcebook on the same subject; indeed many of her examples can be found in full in the earlier volume. Although scholars of Roman death are likely to find the sourcebook the more useful tool of the two, this new volume offers a valuable point of reference and a narrative introduction to the subject.
