To outlaw the sale, manufacture, and transportation of alcohol to an entire population appears to Germans as an incredible intrusion into the private lives of the citizens more appropriate to totalitarian rule than democracy. That the United States, which prides itself on being the home of the free, enacted such a far-reaching policy is, from the German point of view, beyond comprehension. The social historian Thomas Welskopp has taken up this perceived contradiction.
In this monumental book Welskopp provides a comprehensive, multi-facetted, and entertaining study of Prohibition in the United States. Although much has already been written on this subject, Welskopp reveals that historians have paid much attention to the introduction of Prohibition while neglecting the period of Prohibition itself. This book provides a comprehensive treatment divided into seven chapters. Chapter one deals with the driving forces of Prohibition, chapter two with the legal aspects, chapter three with economics, chapter four with culture, chapter five with society, chapter six with media, and chapter seven with the politics of Prohibition, which the author reads as the beginning of big government.
The protagonists of Prohibition, a movement widely attributed to Gilded Age and Progressive Era moral reform efforts, were, according to Welskopp, strange bedfellows. They included religious zealots, racists, and eugenicists. Divided over almost every aspect of modern life, these forces were united by their desire, for very different reasons and motivations, to save their fellow citizens from the dangers of alcoholism. This unique coalition was held together through the construction and propagation of “enemies” and the fact that each group kept its distance from the other, avoiding direct contact. Because of this lack of coherence, Welskopp questions whether it is even appropriate to call this phenomenon a social movement.
The campaign against alcohol consumption was from the very beginning not just a crusade against alcohol but a statement about the social context of drinking. Welskopp argues that focusing on alcohol's danger to human health alone would not have swayed Americans to embrace Prohibition. It was the fact that it was a campaign against the “other” (the immigrant) and his “un-American culture” that made this effort successful. The European immigrants who brought with them customs and cultures (for example, beer gardens) to big American cities that did not seem to fit into Anglo-American culture were “unwelcome intruders” in the minds of the defenders of Prohibition. Those who owned saloons and those who patronized them were not seen as truly American. The impact of World War I allowed the protagonists, further, to seize the moment and paint the defenders of free alcohol consumption as unpatriotic. German Americans in particular were considered to be the fifth column of the German Empire and its Kaiser (a title that was purposefully no longer translated into English as emperor to distinguish him from other civilized emperors). To argue against Prohibition became identical with disloyalty to the United States.
The first years of Prohibition saw a significant decrease in the consumption of alcohol, followed by an increase after 1921. However, the steep decrease was, according to Welskopp, not due to Prohibition but the result of increased prices. Alcohol consumption declined all over the Western world before 1914 and during the war, which suggests that in times of crisis alcohol consumption generally goes down. The increase in alcohol consumption after 1921 did not reach pre-war levels but was nevertheless quite high. Most importantly, Prohibition had no impact on how much Americans spent on alcohol. In 1929, it was estimated to be as much as $5 billion, about the same amount as before Prohibition.
Most of the alcohol sold during Prohibition in the United States came from Canada. In fact, exporting alcohol to the United States provided a significant economic stimulus to the Canadian economy during the 1920s. It helped Canada to develop a modern and effective brewery industry and increased tax revenues tremendously. By the end of the 1920s, more than half of the Canadian government's income derived from taxes and custom duties (which included a significant portion from alcohol production and export). A comparative view might have helped answer some questions raised by the author. Canada too had, after all, enacted Prohibition laws in various provinces including those (such as Ontario) that were home to the expanding breweries providing alcohol for American customers.
Welskopp argues that the Eighteenth Amendment was unique because it interfered with the private lives of Americans and revoked certain rights. However, do Americans have a legal and constitutional protection of privacy? This is, after all, the country which, by invoking the greater common good, not only introduced Prohibition but also defined by law “normal practices” of sex (sodomy laws), which were enforced until the end of the twentieth century, and allowed—with the blessing and even encouragement of social reformers—the sterilization of “degenerate” citizens until the 1970s. Welskopp constructs a contradiction between civil liberties and political excesses such as Prohibition. However, is there really a contradiction or does he simply confuse two different levels of social organization—the political and the social-moral?
Further, although there is the guarantee of (political) civil liberties in the Constitution, is ingesting substances that have the potential to harm an individual a right granted to American citizens? Where does a society draw the line? Does religious or political society have a right to intervene for the protection of a citizen's health? It seems necessary to reconsider Prohibition in the context of other governmental intrusions into the private sphere of the individual citizen in order to assess the relationship between individual and state in American history. Furthermore, comparative studies of social attitudes toward such historical moments might help explain the contradiction between extensive civil liberties and the rigid enforcement of social-moral norms. Canada, by the way, would be an excellent candidate for such a project because of its similar culture as well as the divisions between the different provinces over the issue of banning alcohol consumption.
This book is, nevertheless, an impressive and comprehensive social history of Prohibition. It provides statistical information about alcohol consumption, price developments, and so on, as well as a thorough examination of the culture, economics, law, society, media, and politics of the Prohibition. Its lucid style makes it an attractive work that will certainly reach readers of German beyond the academic world.
