Trying to compress the broad sweep of four score years into a survey is such a daunting task in itself that it would be churlish to ask for an effervescent style. It might even be foolish. All too often, the most brilliant books have been like a fireworks display: a sudden, dazzling light, followed swiftly by a darkness that seems deeper than before. All the more, then, readers should appreciate Steven Hahn's narrative of the era of Manifest Destiny, sectional crisis, and industrial upheaval. It will not shock (though every page or two it may awe, in the breadth of its scope), but its measured prose and bold rereading of what defined the era as a whole make it required reading for those willing to do some re-thinking—especially beyond the water's edge.
For many historians, the nineteenth century had several themes that just barely graze each other: the struggle over slavery and racial equality, the settlement (and unsettlement) of the frontier, the outward thrust of an America determined to absorb its neighbors and subdue those countries and tribes within its boundaries. A Nation Without Borders makes a convincing case for pulling them together, and for realizing that American history and its sense of destiny did not stop at the shoreline. Rather than privileging what Hahn calls the War of the Rebellion, he places it in the context of other violent struggles, among them the fights against Comanche and Sioux, Mormons, Filipinos, freed black people, and immigrants. That broader scope seems reasonable, especially in the late nineteenth century, the age of labor militance and a militarized response to strikers. Coeur d'Alene and the Homestead mills came fearfully close to civil war themselves.
Scholars of the colonial period have made great strides toward an Atlanticized history, binding the future United States in its culture and economics to Europe and Africa. Hahn urges us to Pacificate it as well, to see how vital the ambition to spread across to the very shores of China was to our Manifest Destiny. We cannot understand the Jacksonian economy, for example, without following the demand for opium and the production of silver in China and Mexico respectively. The context of the Kansas-Nebraska bill changes completely, when put alongside the simultaneous hunger for a warm-water empire among slaveholders—a point often overlooked by historians, but not by foes of the Slave Power. The same powers that imposed rules of conduct on white southerners in Reconstruction were using military force to impose their definition of civilized behavior on the Native Americans of the Plains. So, too, the upsetting of biracial governments in the South could be traced back to the Panic of 1873, which, in turn, should lead us to the hunger for capital that only European financiers could satisfy.
Challenging the premise of American exceptionalism, Hahn does what no other survey of the age attempts. He pulls this country's history into the larger world, often in striking ways. Who else has linked the election of Rutherford B. Hayes and the expansion of railroads out west with tentative plans to swallow some of Mexico's northernmost states and the Hayes administration's cooperation with Porfirio Diaz's regime? Or connected the Populist unrest, the Boxer Rebellion in China, the Land League in Ireland, or millennialism in Brazil? Yet that is just what American history needs: capitalism and industrial expansion, like territorial expansion, were international phenomena, coalescing and colliding with each other. Pent in a cell in McHenry County, Illinois, the railroad union leader Eugene Victor Debs could break into a world as wide as Socialist thought could make it, from the works of Karl Kautsky and the British trade unionism of Keir Hardie to the inheritors of the French Enlightenment and the screeds of the Chartists. How could it have been otherwise, in a country into which so many immigrants came, not simply with their possessions, but their experiences and their thoughts?
The prize-winning author of A Nation Under Our Feet, Hahn has earned his reputation by the depth of his research into primary sources. If any are used here, they are buried deep: scholars will find no footnotes or citations, though a comprehensive bibliography discusses the vast secondary literature on which A Nation Without Borders bases its account. With such a broad scope, unbound by North America's coasts and with so much imagination in putting events and movements together that conventional history has not, Hahn should not be expected to follow the same rules that go into a wafer-thin topic in a monograph. So many books and articles have been written about what Hahn calls the “age of civil wars,” that even reading those would take a lifetime.
The choice of sources does carry drawbacks. Readers will be edified. Writers of articles or dissertations might take any one of the linkages and turn it into a monstrous volume all by itself. Still, will anybody outside the academy read this book for fun? The lively quote, the memorable personal vignette, the idiosyncratic spelling, the individual experience of some dramatic event—they have no place here. All of them fade away in a secondary work based on secondary works. Not all surveys suffer the same deficiency, of course. The ability to reconcile the world in small with the epoch writ large may explain some of the strength and certainly the readability of other books covering long expanses of time: William Freehling's Road to Disunion, for example; or Daniel Walker Howe's What Hath God Wrought. Here, the larger argument, the broader themes, stand out, but those looking for drama and passion may feel disappointed. For scholars for whom ideas count the most, however, A Nation Without Borders will feel like a fresh traveler in an antique land.
