Over the nineteenth century, a variety of public women came under attack from both the colonial administration and Indian moralists and social reformers, who collapsed the distinctions between ‘prostitutes’ lower class singers, and elite courtesans.Footnote 1 There were several impulses behind the social marginalisation of female artists, which has come to be termed the ‘anti-nautch (dance) movement’.Footnote 2 In the early nineteenth century, the British began to discourage relationships with Indian women, but also lost interest in indigenous entertainments and cultural practices, including the patronage of dancing girls.Footnote 3 Those sectors of the Indian middle classes that fared well under the colonial economy also denounced female performers, calling them prostitutes and the root of social decay.Footnote 4 These discursive attacks were compounded by political interventions, including the destruction of aristocratic patronage in cities like Delhi and Lucknow following the Uprising of 1857, and a series of legislative acts intended to regulate prostitution. These different campaigns against ‘fallen women’ had multiple implications: song genres were de-eroticised; instruments associated with the nautch became unpopular; women from ‘respectable’ families began to appear on the public stage; and many professional entertainers were forced into sex work in the absence of cultural patronage.Footnote 5 Nonetheless, the culture of singing and dancing women survived in a much reduced form up to the present day: vitriolic campaigns against female performers were never entirely successful, as the same arguments and denouncements of elite patrons continued through to Independence and beyond.Footnote 6
This article considers how female performing artists were understood in relation to language, literature and urban culture in the late nineteenth century. In colonial north India, the cultural connotations of language were in dialogue with social changes: the language a courtesan spoke was not a given, but reflected the training and class of patron available to her. A focus on language—the social connotations of different registers, literary composition and oral performance—sheds light on the strategies for survival available to public women in a changing moral climate, but also on the men who patronised and appreciated women artists. This focus allows us to consider courtesans as litterateurs, supplementing their usual characterisation as musicians and dancers, and takes into account the distinct advantages of being famed as a writer. As for the men: how did male patrons who were brought up to appreciate courtesans as the custodians of elite culture position themselves in a colonial society that was increasingly coloured by a new middle-class morality? Language was a tool for the social mobility of female performers, and was used to overcome a series of obstacles posed by colonialism.
Insights from the history of emotions nuance these tensions and transitions in colonial society, especially when dealing with the archive of poets and their critics. In itself, poetic language can pose methodological problems for the cultural historian: when a literary genre (such as the Urdu ghazal) demands that emotions be articulated through prescribed aesthetic conventions, can a poem only be taken as evidence of a society's conceptual approach to emotions, or as an artefact of the poet's lived experience?Footnote 7 The study of emotion demands us to look beyond the words themselves to multisensorial and multi-medial forms of interpretation and participation with the poetic ‘text’.Footnote 8 Experiencing a courtesan's poetry was not a matter of silent reading, but involved embodied voices, performance (recitation, singing, dancing), specific forms of sociability, material objects (relating to the salon or the printed page), and larger political considerations. The audience or consumer of the poem was not a passive recipient of these experiences, but responded through active listening (entailing gesture and response), and supplementary actions, perhaps including eating, drinking, and sex, all of which had transformative potential in terms of emotional impact.Footnote 9 Both the multimodal delivery and the context-specific reception of poetry were theorised and mediated by associated knowledge systems relating to literary aesthetics, musicology and conduct literature: an emotional community's tools for self-management and self-cultivation.Footnote 10
Thinking of readers and audiences in terms of an emotional community, that is one “tied together by fundamental assumptions, values, goals, feeling rules, and accepted modes of expression”,Footnote 11 has several implications. First, late Mughal readers were heavily invested in strategies of refinement, which prescribed their emotional engagement with courtesans through socially sanctioned forms of affection, friendship, and desire. Second, this coding of emotion influenced how men were placed in elite society, but also, as will be explored below, had social and economic implications for performing women. Third, though it would be problematic to think of post-1857 India in terms of ‘emotional regime’ change, or the courtesan's salon as an ‘emotional refuge’ from a hegemonic emotional style informed by colonialism,Footnote 12 it is helpful to consider how sensibilities cultivated in multiple emotional communities overlap in the experience of the colonial subject. It then becomes possible to view urban societies both as crucibles for new, mediated Anglophone mores and colonial subjectivities on the one hand, and as spaces for preserved forms of Mughal sociability and emotional practices on the other.
Against the Nautch
Under the Mughal Empire, music and dance were highly valued and different communities of professional performers specialised in repertoires for distinct contexts. Some women musicians only performed in the inner quarters of elite houses: domestic slaves (pātur), companions (ḵẖawaṣṣ), the wives of hereditary male musicians (mirasins)Footnote 13 , and other categories of singing-dancer (including gauharin) were reserved for the entertainment of aristocratic women and the private amusements of the lord of the household.Footnote 14 When elite men hosted musical parties for their male companions they paid a different category of woman to perform, known most commonly as kaṅcanī or kanjar, lūlī or ṯawā’if.Footnote 15 In theory, these women were not attached to one household, though some were retained by particular patrons. The most successful became significant patrons and political actors in their own right, but these were exceptional cases.Footnote 16
The change in fortune of dancing girls—from a position of cultural authority, if not mainstream respectability, to one of marginalisation and infamy—can be traced to colonial rule, when the British discontinued patronising the nautch and increasingly defined dancing girls as prostitutes. As early as 1837, James Paton (1798-1847) published a bilingual pamphlet through the Baptist Mission Press, denouncing European and ‘Native’ patrons of dance: “An Exposition in English and Hindustani of the Evil Tendency of Naches, in corrupting the morals, and especially in supplying money for the further purchase of Innocent Female Children, for the wretched purpose of Prostitution! And an appeal to the respectable natives of India, and to all Christians by their influence and example to discountenance so great an evil”.Footnote 17 Paton was an educationist and reformer fixated on the elimination of vice. In 1837 he was based in Awadh as assistant to the Resident at Lucknow, William Sleeman, where he notoriously orchestrated the regulation and execution of Thugs.Footnote 18 Paton saw dancing girls as the exploited victims of a pernicious industry that was spreading immorality and disease. He identified the ṯawā’if as a prostitute (kasbī) and the nāyika (the conductor of a performing troupe) as a procuress, who corrupted little girls and hired them out to sing for ‘musical people’ (rāga ke log).Footnote 19
Despite this burst of anti-nautch fervour, it seems that most Europeans in India were not opposed to dancing girls until the 1860s, and even then the language used to describe them was mixed.Footnote 20 Interest in indigenous entertainment slowly drained away, propelled by the increasing availability in cantonment towns of music and women from Britain. However, morality was not always a consideration: even the politest circles of British society were comfortable attending a nautch hosted by Indian aristocrats. The Marchioness of Dufferin and Ava recorded one such entertainment in her diary in 1885:
‘A Nautch in the Upper Hall,’ says the programme! The old and blasé Anglo-Indian despised this one, and whispered something about music-halls; but as we are not blasé, it amused us very much. . .One of the women was very good-looking, and was heavily clothed from head to foot in velvet and gold, and a great scarf of green and gold; the other wore rather short pink petticoats, but when she did whirl round, one saw that she had on a regular suit of armour, cloth of gold down to the ankles. Nothing could be more strictly proper, and nothing could possibly be more languid and gentle and almost motionless than the dancing, if dancing it can be called.Footnote 21
The newly-arrived Marchioness’ reaction—a combination of curiosity and amusement—contrasts with that of the established Anglo-Indian, but even here the issue was a matter of taste rather than morality: the suggestion was that music-hall culture was preferable to a nautch, not that the nautch girl was a prostitute. Indeed, the Marchioness reassures her English readers that the entire spectacle was nothing but “proper”. From other late travelogues, it is apparent that while the British gradually lost interest in the nautch, many of them did not see dancing girls as a social evil.
Nonetheless, colonial policies relating to the restructuring of cities and the regulation of military brothels had horrific consequences for public women. The Cantonment Acts of 1864 and 1889, supplemented by the Contagious Diseases Act of 1868 (repealed 1888), set up regulations for brothels visited by soldiers and other military personnel, including obligatory medical examinations and ‘Lock Hospitals’ designed to confine women with venereal diseases.Footnote 22 Although the Cantonment Act and Contagious Diseases Act were theoretically confined to brothels frequented by the army, they had a much wider impact. In Mysore the principles of the Acts were stretched to harass women accused of ‘clandestine’ prostitution: in some cases, women even committed suicide “to escape the disgrace of being brought under the Lock Hospital Act”.Footnote 23 The association of performing women with sexually-transmitted diseases fed into the rhetoric of the anti-nautch, as in Punjab where one reformist proclaimed: “let those who are conscious of the evils of this custom shun dancing parties as contagious diseases”.Footnote 24 In her study of post-Uprising Lucknow, Veena Oldenburg recorded the oral histories of courtesans, which suggested that women from elite salons (kothas) were forced to service soldiers.Footnote 25 Following her account, other scholars have argued that these policies destroyed the prestige of high-status artists and forced them into sex work.Footnote 26
However, this was not a universal outcome, and kotha culture was not eradicated entirely. Stephen Legg noted that these policies were difficult to implement and impractical.Footnote 27 Confusion persisted over how to distinguish a dancing girl from a prostitute.Footnote 28 A columnist in the Lucknow-based newspaper Karnama commented in 1871 that the Lock Hospital Act was inadequate since it was enforced inconsistently:
Now prostitutes and concubines, who have settled themselves with one lover, or whose profession is only to sing and dance, are exempted from the Act, and now they are again brought to trial. One officer takes one course, which is changed by his successor.Footnote 29
Certain policies were unsuccessful precisely because it was known that ‘prostitutes’ were held in high esteem: “the condition of the women is far less degraded, and their influence in the community often considerable, so that unwise interference would be frequently resented even by the influential classes of the people”.Footnote 30 The uncertainty over how to distinguish between musical performance and sex work persisted, as men from elite or aspiring families continued to visit courtesans and pay for dancing girls.Footnote 31
Vernacular urban newspapers indicate that at times dancing girl culture was on the rise, especially following the devastating famine of 1877–78: many famine victims turned to the dance and sex industries to obtain some livelihood. This is confirmed—and condemned—in a newspaper from Agra, which noted that dancing girls and prostitutes (reference was made to both) were convicted in the criminal courts for buying the daughters of famine-stricken families.Footnote 32 A journalist from Lahore noted an “immense increase” in dancing girls in almost every town, “due to the encouragement which they receive at the hands of the public on festive occasions”.Footnote 33 While we have to read these sources critically, they gesture to the prevailing popularity and patronage of female artists, despite the polemic against them in the press. Indeed, the same complaints continued through to the end of the century, suggesting that the reformist agenda faced an uphill struggle.
Sex and the city
Urban society's fascination with women performers is well attested in literature and aesthetic theory. A long-established tradition of describing cities through its womenfolk continued into the colonial period, though often tempered by new moralising discourses.Footnote 34 Many writers included extensive descriptions of the different female entertainers of Calcutta, from dancing prostitutes to celebrity bāījī singers, when they described the city. Kaliprasanna Sinha's Hutom Pyāṅcār Nakśā (‘Sketches of the Brown Owl’, 1862) mocked the playboy lifestyle of the urban babu elites, especially the attention they lavished upon (male and female) khemṭā dancers and the singers of devotionals (kīrtan) and love songs (kheur and jhumur).Footnote 35 In Debgaṇer Marttye Āgaman (‘The Gods’ Trip to Earth’, 1880), Durgacaran Ray imagined a tour group of gods exploring famous cities and landmarks, in effect crafting a guide book to the subcontinent. Durgacaran characterised Calcutta through a series of brothels, dance recitals and salons. The diversity of public women was almost an index of cosmopolitanism. Mortal tourists also described Calcutta in these terms, including one Malay visitor, Ahmad Rijaluddin in his Hikayat Perintah Negeri (c.1810), which gives an extensive account of the “thousands of whores”, starting with the shipyards and proceeding into the depths of town.Footnote 36 Rijaluddin noted how the women were from different regions, with identifiably distinctive features and clothes:
whores of different races such as Indians [i.e. Hindustanis], Pathans, Eurasians, and Hindu Bengalis, all of them young and fair. . . They sing one song after another accompanied by the sitar, fiddle and tambourine, the noise echoing down the lane. The singing is quite delightful, and many of the passers-by are struck dumb with admiration for their beautiful voices, while the more susceptible go into the brothels to dance with the whores, this is what goes on here.Footnote 37
This cataloguing of diverse genres and regional backgrounds was especially valued in Indian works on aesthetics. Classical poetics (kāvya) traditionally elaborated the different facets and connotations of women, distinguishing them by locale, marriage status, class, age, and emotion.Footnote 38 Variety was the spice of life.
There were many ways to read a work on aesthetics, music, or other allied knowledge systems, but it should be recalled that these texts were intertwined with literature relating to connoisseurship, comportment, and ethics. The connoisseur guarded himself against emotional entanglement with unworthy objects, be they works of art or performing bodies.
In the nineteenth century, musicologists writing in Urdu wove together literary associations with racialised stereotypes and an appreciation of localised musical styles. This is especially apparent in the Ghunca-yi Rāg (1863) of Muhammad Mardan ‘Ali Khan. Khan maintained that dance styles were conditioned by the region where they were developed, especially the climate and beauty of local women. Kashmiri dance was the most notorious and world-renowned, while God had bestowed beautiful women and dances upon Punjab, while in Hindustan music and dance were ‘beguiling’ (fireb). Khan also described the salacious dance of Bengal: “the immodest (be-parda) dance is khemṭā – the destroyer of piety and the breaker of repentance (ghārat-i imān wa tauba shikan)”.Footnote 39 Khan was especially effusive about dance in Lucknow, which had transformative properties when performed correctly:
The music, dance, and art of gesture (gānā, nāch, batānā) of Lucknow is extraordinary. Each expression (bhāv) is matchless. According to the Hindus, the creators of dance (raqṣ) were undoubtedly Mahadev and Parvati, but for a long time in Hind the kathaks have been talented and skilled in it. In dance the gharānā of Miyan Abdullah and Pragās is the most celebrated of its time. Talk of them is in every city. By putting on airs an old man of some years becomes a glittering beauty, so that just looking at his postures (ṭhāṭh) would make a man swoon. . .Those ṯawā’if who have taken instruction from them, are also brilliant – they are described as beautiful and even as prodigies (le-bhāgū, i.e. they pick up ideas and run off without being taught).Footnote 40
This treatise therefore gestures to how the reputations of individuals and entire cities circulated across the subcontinent. Combining poetic attitudes with travelling tales of expert dancers and ṯawā’if gave certain places distinct reputations in the world of performing arts.
This meant cities like Calcutta, which were home to women from many different regions, were seen as culturally rich and aesthetically diverse. However, this sense of cultural geography also put pressure on Bengali women in the city to align themselves with different regions and places, in order to appeal to cosmopolitan patrons with a taste for the expertise of Lucknow or the beauties of Punjab. Cultural connotations about urban femininity therefore determined how women marketed themselves, changing their reputations by training in music, dance and literature. Sumanta Banerjee noted how classically trained bāījīs in Calcutta pushed themselves apart from lower class khemṭā-vālīs by recasting themselves as Hindustani singers rather than Bengali dancers, learning Urdu and Persian, concealing their Bengali accents, and developing new repertoires. Although all these women lived in the same areas of the city and were largely from similarly poor, rural backgrounds, identification with the courtly culture of upper India was a means to attract a different kind of customer, and to achieve some form of social mobility.Footnote 41
Women's words
When she spoke her melodious words,
it was as though she were playing her inner flute.
People say the cuckoo's voice is beautiful, but listening to her it seems dull.
The woman's words are matchless, they sustain life and remove worry,
When he hears her speak, the sage's mind is disturbed.Footnote 42
While the courtesan is usually thought of as a singer (gānevālī) and dancer (nācnevālī), many women were characterised by, and celebrated for, their eloquent speech.Footnote 43 In Lucknow, polished language articulated the prized virtues of cultural refinement (tahẕīb), propriety (shāyistagī), and a softly-spoken, reposed demeanour (ṣalāḥiyat).Footnote 44 Courtesans deployed language in different modes: elegant conversation; composing poetry; reciting poetry; singing poetry; singing non-lexical lyrics; and casting spells. All these functions of the voice related to the possibility of enchantment, and male authors warned against the dangers of entrapment. An early nineteenth-century guide to Indian customs cautioned its readers against the magical tools at a courtesan's disposal.Footnote 45 These practices—which ranged from strategic Qur'anic recitation to uttering supplications to trees, or making charms from donkey semen—were seen as different aspects of the courtesan's ability to manipulate men: her music recitals offered but a glimpse of her dangerously enchanting repertoire.Footnote 46
Feminine forms of speech were both appreciated and condemned in Urdu poetry circles, especially when affected by men. Poets such as Sa'adat Yar Khan ‘Rangīn’ (1755-1835), Shaikh Qalandar Baksh ‘Jur'at’ (1748-1810), and Mir Yar Ali ‘Jān Ṣāḥib’ (1817-96) cultivated reḵẖtī, a gender-bending style of verse centred on the experience of domestic women, courtesans, and servants in a world ornamented by urban fashion and material glamour.Footnote 47 Reḵẖtī relished the pleasures enjoyed by women, and was expressed in a highly colloquial language that was marked as a woman's style of speech (auratoṅ kī zubān or begamati zubān).Footnote 48 Critics of reḵẖtī characterised Rangīn's verse as the speech of whores (raṇḍīyoṅ kī bolī).Footnote 49 Women also wrote reḵẖtī (atypically, since they usually wrote from a male vantage point (reḵẖta) or, following Persian aesthetics, hid their gender with ambiguous grammar). At least two of Wajid ‘Ali Shah's wives are known to have composed reḵẖtī: his senior wife, Khas Mahal (c.1817-1894), who under the taḵẖalluṣ ‘Ālam was a more prolific lyricist than her celebrated husband; and Rashk Mahal ‘Begam’, a Punjabi dancer and poet.Footnote 50
Besides stylised begamati zubān, women poets were also recognised for their eloquence, literary flair and artistic articulations in performance. Although only a few voices have been traced in the archive thus far, it is apparent that early modern courtly culture facilitated the education of elite women – including members of the aristocracy and courtesans.Footnote 51 Noted Urdu women poets, from the eighteenth century, included aristocrats (e.g. Begam Jan Bahu Begam ‘Jani’, wife of Nawab Asafuddaulah) and dancing girls (e.g. Muhammadi Begam of Faizabad, in Shujauddaulah's military camp).Footnote 52 Scholars of the nineteenth century suggest that women's reading cultures changed dramatically under colonialism. After the 1830s elite women became less autonomous, as their financial influence was curtailed and domestic spaces were politically disenfranchised; from the mid-century onwards reformist literature re-fashioned the expectations and obligations of the modern woman, including how and what she should read.Footnote 53 It was acceptable for upper class Muslim women to receive instruction in religious and advice literature, and perhaps Persian poetry, while marsiya recitation continued to be considered a respectable form of performance.Footnote 54 Pernau notes that concomitant social changes hardened the “boundaries between honourable women and their ‘Other’, the courtesans and women from the lower classes, who could not afford to follow the rules of female segregation. . .as had the boundaries between the private and public spheres”.Footnote 55 Crucially, for women's literary practices, “the world of the poets remained closed to respectable women – the recitation and singing of the ghazal was too closely associated with courtesans”.Footnote 56
Nonetheless, men and women who were deeply entrenched in the older, pre-reformist cultures resisted these boundaries. A particularly clear example is the aforementioned queen of Awadh, Khas Mahal, who published several of her own works, and composed a large collection of lyrics for her husband's song anthologies.Footnote 57 Married to the man that embodied Nawabi decadence, it is tempting to dismiss her achievements as an aberration, permitted by her unusually high social status and her notoriously permissive husband. However, this would be a mistake. Khas Mahal took her position as a pardanishīn queen extremely seriously, and preserved her respectability intact: printing collections of ghazal and ṭhumrī did not impinge on her propriety.
More significantly, late nineteenth-century poetic taẕkiras of women poets indicate that a larger sample of courtesans and respectable women were recognised as skilled poets over the course and in the wake of these transitions in colonial society. The taẕkira was a popular genre in Urdu literature: anthologisers would compile directories of poets they knew personally or had heard of, providing biographical details and sample verses. Taẕkiras dedicated exclusively to women was a novelty, and the juxtaposition of ‘prostitutes’ with pardanishīn poets in these anthologies not only challenges the boundary between their social worlds, but also indicates a society of male readers and connoisseurs that was appreciative of their artistic labour. As will be shown, some of the men connected to these women were not castaways from a moribund Mughal culture, but very much involved in the colonial regime: these texts suggest the arena of journal polemic, ethical reform, and middle-class denunciation of dancing girls was not entirely normative in this period, and that societies of appreciative men continued to value—perhaps even fetishize—women's speech.
Collecting and recollecting women
At least three men are known to have compiled anthologies of women poets over the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.Footnote 58 Muhammad Fasihuddin ‘Ranj’ of Meerut (1836-85) first assembled the Bahāristān-i-Nāz (‘Springtime Garden of Coquetry’) in 1864, which grew substantially over two further editions in 1869 and 1882, culminating in a selection of 174 Urdu and Persian poets.Footnote 59 In the intervening years, Durgaprasad ‘Nādir’ of Delhi compiled the Gulshan-i Nāz (‘Rose Garden of Coquetry’, 1876), a short taẕkira prefaced by an essay on Islamic perspectives on women's writing. Encouraged by its positive reception, Nādir quickly compiled the more substantial Taẕkirat al-Nisā Nādirī (‘Nādir's Anthology of Women’), 1878, also called Chaman-i Andāz or Mirat-i-Ḵẖayālī). Some fifty years later Maulvi Abdul Bari drew on both Ranj and Nadir for his own anthology, Taẕkirat-ul-ḵẖawātīn (‘Anthology of Ladies’, c.1930).
The compilers (taẕkira-nigār) organised the women alphabetically by their pen name (taḵẖalluṣ), and provided each one with a brief biography, beginning with where she lived or performed, recording anecdotes and male poets associated with her, and finishing with sample verses. This format was identical to compilations of male poets – indeed, many of the biographical entries were longer than those in some male-dominated anthologies, such as Taẕkirah-i Shamīm-i Suḵẖan (1891).Footnote 60 In her study of Ranj, Carla Petievich suggests an ambivalence in his appraisals: going to the effort of compiling and installing these different authors into the established taẕkira genre suggests that Ranj recognised their literary merit and cultural value to some degree; then again, his annotations are often salacious and irreverent. Belittling the merit of even well-known poets, such as Mah Laqa Bai ‘Chandā’, Ranj appears to suggest that as “quasi-public women”, poetesses “should enter the historical register, but perhaps not on the same line as male poets”.Footnote 61 However, there are difficulties with Chandā’s entry: she was not featured in early editions of Bahāristān-i Nāz, and was later illustrated by only one verse, which makes it is quite possible that Ranj had not actually seen her diwān or heard any examples of her poetry. As such he could comment on her reputation but not her literary merits. While the taẕkira-nigārs are sensationalist in certain cases, that these anthologies were produced at all, in a time of increasing sensitivity or outright hostility towards courtesan culture, is significant.
Sachdeva notes that publishing poetry provided a new public platform for ṯawā’if, who “used specific techniques of self-hood or subjectivity in conjunction with technologies of leisure such as commercial printing to become celebrity entertainers in cities”.Footnote 62 However, this self-fashioning was mediated: by the Urdu poetry itself—which articulates emotions through pre-determined tropes—and by the men who anthologised and disseminated the poets’ compositions. Terry Kawashima has argued that the marginalisation of women in literature is not a clear-cut condition but a haphazard process: the same can be said of the courtesan poets and their male associates, who did not marginalise the women per se, but created a separate quasi-canon for them on the basis of gender.Footnote 63 Many of these women were publishing their own diwāns, which provided the anthologisers with some of their example verses. A feminine taẕkira was an appealing novelty in the market – granting insights into networks of esteemed male poets, the salons of celebrated courtesans, and even into the homes of secluded, aristocratic women.Footnote 64 It is tempting then to consider these anthologisers as book entrepreneurs, expanding their taẕkiras with each edition to meet the demand of their reader-consumers. At the same time, the anthologisers deployed the framework of the taẕkira to create a respected space for women poets and, by extension, the literary-cum-performance culture these men valued.Footnote 65
The entries for contemporary women poets reflect a sense of increased movement in the wake of 1857, since many women are said to have migrated between two or more cities. Successful dancing girls had always been mobile, as with women like Jivani (d.1804), who wrote as Ṣanaubar (‘Pine tree’): she was from Jalandhar, but belonged to a troop (zumra) of ṯawā’if based in Delhi.Footnote 66 Many of the poets contemporary to Ranj were on the move, especially from Lucknow to Calcutta: after Wajid ‘Ali Shah relocated there in 1856, following the Annexation of Awadh, he built a substantial musical community in the southern suburb of Matiyaburj, so it makes some sense that Lakhnavi courtesans followed the patrons who gathered around him.
Jafri, a ṯawā’if and long-time resident of Lucknow, ‘took correction’ from Munshi Fadā Hussain ‘Faẓā’, but then later moved to Calcutta (and was still alive in 1872).Footnote 67 Migrations were often the only biographical details available to Ranj, as with a woman known to poets as ‘Sharm’:
Sharm [‘Modesty’/‘Shame’] – Choti Sahab, she was a ṯawā’if and resident of Lucknow, and then she also went to Calcutta. [The poet] Maulavi ‘Abdul Ghafur Khan Sahab ‘Nassāḵẖ’ wrote that he had seen her. This is one [of her] verse[s]: Mourdah zindah ho gaye pa-zeb ki jhankar se
Har qadam par ḥashar bar pā hai teri raftar se
The dead have come alive from the tinkling of anklets:
On every step a commotion is stirred up [or, the dead are raised up] by your gait.
Yeh kis rashk mah ka naẕẕāra ā hua hai
Ki ḵẖẉurshed ankhon ka tārā hua hai
What envy of the moon has come into sight, such
that the sun has become a starFootnote 68 in her eyes?
Mile ghir se yār ankhon ke āge
Mere jān yeh kisko gwārā hua hai Footnote 69
Before my eyes, my beloved meets with another.
My love! Who can tolerate this?
These couplets (sher) would serve as a link in a longer ghazal chain. Ghazals were commonly recited by men and women alike at poetic gatherings, the mushairas, but some were evidently intended for singing, since we have ghazals in song anthologies as well as poetic compendia.Footnote 70 The excitement aroused by the anklet could be amplified in a physical performance, exploring the words through dance while Sharm sang, tingling her anklets. In the moment of performance Sharm effectively sang in dialogue with herself: her words are directed to a dancer in the second person, “your (terī) gait”, yet she embodied that dancer herself. The option of the split persona is a familiar device in Indian dance, allowing the performer to slide between the roles of narrator and the characters implied in the lyrics. Since the lyric is her own, Sharm is singing playfully about herself, using her own words.Footnote 71 The reaction she excites is earth-shattering and raises the dead – ḥashar (‘tumult’) is a pun here, referring to the ‘commotion’ of the jingling, but is also synonymous for the day of resurrection. This imagery had been used elsewhere in relation to a beautiful gait, and in Ṯilism-e-Hoshrubā (‘The Sense-Stealing Charm’) the trope was applied to a handsome warrior rather than a nimble dancing girl: “Even the dead in their graves opened their eyes to admire his bursting youth and winsome gait”.Footnote 72 Sharm's lyrics were textured with allusions and different possibilities for discursive and embodied interpretations, glossing the danced performance with a sense of cosmology and theology, magnifying the moment through enacted poetry.
In this entry, we are told that Maulavi ‘Abdul Ghafur Khan Sahab ‘Nassāḵẖ’ (1834-89) had seen Sharm. The taẕkiras are peppered with references to well-known male poets: some had merely noted seeing the women, while others taught or had intimate affairs with them. Although it is tempting to think of courtesans as building a world for themselves outside mainstream patriarchal society,Footnote 73 these women evidently operated through networks of cultured men to acquire education and patronage. When Malka Jan (the mother of Gauhar Jan) settled in Banaras in 1879, she undertook training from local specialists: Persian composition with Hussain Ahmed Asghar and Qadar Hussain; Urdu with Hakim Banno Sahib ‘Hilal’; musical training with Zeenat Bibi of Banaras and later Kalloo Ustad, and dance with ‘Ali Baksh of Lucknow.Footnote 74 When she published an anthology of some 600 ghazals, the Maḵẖzan-e-Ulfat-e-Mallika (‘Mallika's Store of Affections’, Calcutta 1886), the work was printed with verses celebrating her achievement by Maluvi Muhammad ‘Shams’ of Calcutta, Shireen Jan of Lucknow, Hafiz Ali ‘Najaf’ (disciple of Dagh Dehlvi), Hazrat Shams Lakhnawi, Munshi Yaqub Sahab ‘Asar’ of Awadh, Raghunath Sahai ‘Ibrat’ of Azimabad, and Ghulam Haidar Khan ‘Muztar’.Footnote 75 Male and female poets were entangled in the same society: while the mushaira was not an egalitarian space, the combination of men and women celebrating a courtesan poet's publication contrasts with the more familiar history of men writing to denounce or reform the ‘fallen woman’.
Reflecting on the male poets who associated with courtesans suggests that there was a porous boundary between older cultures of literary and musical appreciation and new forms of society yoked to the colonial administration. Nassāḵẖ was the younger brother of Nawab ‘Abdul Latif (1828-1893)—founder of the Muhammadan Literary Society at Calcutta (1863)—and son of Qazi Faqir Muhammad, a Persian scholar employed at the Calcutta civil courts (Sadr Diwani Adalat).Footnote 76 Nassāḵẖ was trained by his father to be competent in Arabic, Persian, Urdu, Bengali and English, and also studied at the Calcutta and Hughly Madrasas. He was employed as a linguist in the Sadr Diwani Adalat, and then served as a Deputy Magistrate (Barisal) from 1860.Footnote 77 His poetic works, including a taẕkira called the Shukan-i-Shu'ara, were extremely well-regarded, and he is remembered by some as the ‘father of Urdu poetry’ in Bengal.Footnote 78 Christopher Shackle characterised him as “a lively provincial intellectual, ambitious for preferment under the nineteenth-century Raj at the same time as being more than amply anchored to the élite values of the Mughal past”.Footnote 79 His being a magistrate was no obstacle to his deep involvement in courtesan culture, and Nassāḵẖ appears regularly in the women's taẕkiras. Along with his colleague Maulavi Ismatullah Saheb ‘Mazbur’ (later ‘Azan’), he corrected several women's verses from his base in Pandua, Hooghly District: besides Sharm, his courtesan students included Hijāb (below), and one Zahra:
Zahra (‘Shining’) her pen name, Munni her name. Her ordinary business came from selling her beauty. Her original country was Kashmir, but then her livelihood drew her to Calcutta's bazaar. She was extremely beautiful and had a happy disposition. Sometimes, because of her balanced qualities, her lyrics too were balanced in metre. Maulavi Abdul Ghafur ‘Nassāḵẖ’—editor of the taẕkira Shukan-i-Shu'ara—corrected her verses. She was alive until 1291ah [1874]. This is her composition:
Dekhkar caurang dil hai aishq dilgīr kā
Sabzah-i rukhsar sabzah hai magr shamshir kā
Beholding this dismemberment, the heart fell in love with the morose.
The verdant fuzz of the cheek is but the bloom of the sword
Dil hamārā dard kā putlā banā āye brahman
He taṣawwur dambadam jo us bat be-pīr kā
Oh Brahman! My heart has become the image of pain,
Endlessly picturing that unfeeling idol.Footnote 80
Urban elite culture was not confined to the city proper, but emanated through networks of connoisseurs and patrons in satellite towns and countryside residences. British records (focusing on archaeology) suggested Pandua was a ruined or deserted city, but it was in fact a thriving cultural forum focused around two important dargāhs,Footnote 81 and annually hosted two major fairs that attracted thousands of visitors. Nassāḵẖ and Mazbur were not the only Urdu and Persian litterateurs in residence: Muhammad ‘Abid ‘Ali Khan (b.1872) wrote primers in Urdu and Bengali, a local history, and a lyric anthology (Gulshān-i Hind). Khan did not see himself as a backwater intellectual: he was from a Pathan lineage and boasted that in his family Urdu “conversation [was] very similar to that current in Delhi. Certain rites in our marriage ceremonies are the same as those that used to be observed in the Royal family at Delhi”.Footnote 82 A community from Zaidpur in Awadh were also based locally, and Ghulām Husain Salīm Zaidpūrī (d.1818), author of the Persian history Riyāzu-s-Salātīn (1787-1788), was buried in nearby Angrezabad.Footnote 83 For the courtesans, Pandua was a significant centre of Indo-Persian literary culture only 55km north of Calcutta. The traffic of poets and their pupils indicates an Urdu literary network, not only between larger cities, but coursing through networked households in smaller satellite towns. This corresponds to Mushirul Hasan's notion of qasbahs as “the involuntary heirs of the once-powerful Indo-Persian culture, whose gifts they were to pass on in one direction or another”.Footnote 84 The references to geography in the taẕkiras both authenticate women's positions in a moving network of male artists, but also demonstrate their local engagement with elite circles of cultural refinement and literary expertise.
One of the most notorious tales of mobile courtesans and poets was that of Ḥijāb and Dāgh. Outside of the mushaira, Ḥijāb was called Munni Bai; she was a ṯawā’if from Colotulla Bazaar in Calcutta, and developed her poetry with Mazbur and Nassāḵẖ in Pandua, but she was also especially celebrated for her skills in music.Footnote 85 She made a trip to Rampur, where she began a love affair with the poet Mirza Dāgh Dehlvi (1831-1905), which became part of her biography in the taẕkiras. Dāgh had been educated in the Red Fort after his mother married Mirza Muhammad Sultan, son of Bahadur Shah Zafar. Contributing to the royal mushairas, Dāgh had been at the centre of the Mughal literary scene, and had studied with Muhammad Ibrahim Żauq (1789-1854). Following the destruction of Delhi, Dāgh moved with his family to Rampur, where he became a companion of the heir-apparent, Nawab Kalb ‘Ali Khan (1832-1887) for some thirty years. In that time he toured through Delhi, Lucknow, Patna, and Calcutta, hosting and appearing at poetry assemblies, and finally moved to Hyderabad in 1888.Footnote 86 He composed a masnavī called Faryād-i Dāgh (Dāgh's Lament), which chronicled his love for Ḥijāb, their encounter in Rampur, and their time together when he followed her back to Calcutta.
In his masnavī, Dāgh “hints more than plainly that Hijab made it clear to him that it was not his dark complexion or his ordinary features that she admired, but she admired him as an artist in words”.Footnote 87 A poem commemorating the Benazir Fair of Rampur (where perhaps Dāgh and Ḥijāb first metFootnote 88 ) describes Dāgh in literally glowing terms:
Among the poets of Delhi the Nawab Mirza is
The radiance [or touchstone, roshan] of the intellect, an ornament of light,
When he writes ghazals his taḵẖalluṣ is Dāgh
In the company of poets he is a brilliant lamp.Footnote 89
In later times, he was read less sympathetically: R. B. Saksena (1927) thought Faryād-i Dāgh was “marred by pictures of sensuality and coarse passion and is occasionally revolting to fine taste”.Footnote 90 Saksena acknowledged that in Dāgh's own time his “reputation as a facile writer of easy, smooth and eloquent erotic verses spread like wild fire”, but with hindsight it could be said that Dāgh lacked “the real pathos or pain of Mir, or the sublimity of thought of Ghalib”.Footnote 91 Saksena presented a moderate assessment of Dāgh: harsher critics had apparently called him “a poet laureate of dancing girls and his poetry has been dubbed the poetry of licentiousness and sensuality. These are extreme views which need considerable modification”. Saksena evidently admired the forms and techniques of Dāgh's poetry, but not the social implications of his affections:
His love has seldom any beauty, truth, sublimity, or refinement. . .The kisses and embraces of which he writes are the kisses and embraces which could be purchased and paid for. Many of his verses are not fit for decorous ears. They are fit to be sung, as they are sung in the banquets of pleasure in the company of riotous boon companions, lit with wine and laughter of dancing girls. They depict surface emotions and rarely strike a higher note.Footnote 92
Downgrading Dāgh's feelings to ‘surface emotions’ defines a boundary between emotional communities. Saksena's critique was coloured by his disapproval of Nawabi culture: expressions of love were automatically tarnished by the taint of prostitution, and Dāgh's emotions could not be taken as sincere or meaningful.Footnote 93
However, this condemnation was not universal. Dāgh was made notorious for his relationship with Ḥijāb, but her teacher, Nassāḵẖ was not. Dāgh may have immortalised his love in Faryād, but Nassāḵẖ published a work dedicated to the piecemeal description of a beautiful woman's body (sarāpā), including her bodice and lap, in Shāhid-i ‘Ishrat (‘Witness of Enjoyment’, 1874): although this was an established genre, had critics wanted to condemn his taking on courtesan pupils, this sensual text would have been an easy target. Crucially, however, while Dāgh was a remnant of the Mughal court and a retainer of the controversial Rampur Nawabs, Nassāḵẖ was a magistrate: the different social standing of the poets was critical to their different reception histories, and the perceived respectability of their emotions.
The taẕkiras complicate our assumptions about derogatory language. The compilers used a variety of terms to define the poets: ṯawā’if appears regularly, but also bazārī (bazaar-girl), maqbul-i bazār (mistress of the bazaar), and common words for prostitute or harlot, raṇḍī and ḵẖāngī.Footnote 94 At first glance, it appears the compilers were belittling the poets as ‘fallen women’ in the style of the reformists. But two factors suggest otherwise. Firstly, these terms were consistently used with reference to bazaars and livelihoods (pesh, ma’āsh, āb o dāna), which appear almost as a separate consideration from the women as dancers (raqqāṣa) or their skills in music, recitation and writing. Although these terms are not sympathetic in themselves, in context these writers were not passing moral judgements when they used them to situate women they evidently admired. Secondly, these women were compiled alongside queens, aristocratic women and other pardanishīns. This suggests the persistence of a culture that valued poetic production over other social considerations: literary talent afforded all types of women access to a shared cultural arena, in spite of the opposition from other sections of the middle classes.
How the taẕkiras commemorated the literary talent of women raises questions relating to the influence of gender in Urdu performance culture. On the whole, Ranj and the compilers who followed him were very effusive. Women were described as possessing the same abilities as men. This was explained, almost apologetically, in terms of talīm. Bega ‘Shirīn’, a ṯawāi'f from Lucknow, studied with Muhammadi Sahib ‘Sipahr’, disciple of Khwaja Wazir Sahib,Footnote 95 and then with Shaikh Amdad ‘Ali Sahib ‘Baḥr’. Ranj notes she flourished under their tuition, and “although I have not seen the diwān, I have heard that her own diwān is delightful, considered, and subtly discerning (nukta-dān)”.Footnote 96 The sister poets of Lucknow, Qamran Jan ‘Mushtarī’ (‘Jupiter’) and Umrao Jan ‘Zǒhra’ (‘Venus’), were especially well-regarded:Footnote 97 Ranj tells us that Mushtarī had “an incomparable claim in poetry, her temperament oozed with an extremely sharp discernment”.Footnote 98 The sisters were trained in poetry by a Lakhnavi ustād who had moved to Calcutta, Mirza Agha ‘Ali ‘Shams’.Footnote 99 Ranj reasoned that the sisters shared their famous teacher's reputation for genius, “and why should it not be so? For since the Ustād Jī would have spoken from his magnificent imagination when instructing them, so the student too consequently becomes a household name”.Footnote 100
Other women were judged to be considerably better than male poets, including Bannu of Delhi. Ranj introduced her to his readers as a ḵẖāngī, “good in appearance and good-natured too. . .her style was delicate and visionary (nāzuk ḵẖayālī) – with a moment's thought her words were superior to thousands of men: every moment of her letters, and every hour of her recitals (shě’r-go’ī) was a delight”.Footnote 101 Before presenting her verses, Ranj described the secret love between Bannu and Gulab Singh ‘Āshufta’, especially how Gulab Singh became inconsolable during a period of separation and slit his own throat. This episode was illustrated by Bannu's own grief-wracked verses, Ghalib's reflections on the incident, and the sad postscript that she died of tuberculosis.Footnote 102 As Pernau notes, Āshufta's “biography reads like a living ghazal”,Footnote 103 as the male poet is literally slain, overwhelmed by the pain of “separation in the real world” (‘ālam zist men firāq). Gulab Singh becomes the ‘disturbed’ one—the literal meaning of Āshufta—while Bannu the wordsmith understands the devastating potency of her craft: Ranj described how when she heard about the suicide she was overcome with weeping, yet still spontaneously conjured a couplet, which “she brought up to her tongue” (zabān par layī). This phrasing was idiomatic but pointed. The word ‘tongue’ (zabān), which also means speech, teases out the sensuality of the seductive poetess, tracing her enchanting compositions back to the organ of speech and her physicality.Footnote 104 The episode is almost cautionary, illuminating the power of an articulate woman.
Ranj distinguished between Bannu's writing and her skills in recitation, and other entries in the taẕkira also separate the different art forms in which the women specialised. Badshah Begam ‘Ḵẖafī’, a ḵẖāngī who was intriguingly known in Anglophone circles as Missy Laqab, was praised as a poet (shā’ira) “inclined towards reḵẖta-go’ī, and her shā’ir-go’ī is an utterly perfect accomplishment”. These skills in recited composition (go’ī) were supplemented by Ḵẖafī’s vocal craft: her nāz (grace-suggestiveness) in performing verses was characterised by ḵẖush-āhang sāz, sweet-voiced ornament or harmony.Footnote 105 As already noted, Zǒhra of Lucknow was celebrated as a both an Urdu and Poet poet, “erudite in prosody and cadence” (‘arūẓ wa qāfiya se bā-ḵẖabar), but she was also a dancer (raqqāṣa), and her performed recitation of ghazal (ghazal-ḵẖwānī) was held in higher esteem than her composition (go’ī).Footnote 106 Although it is difficult to reconstruct how these women performed their verses, the taẕkiras take for granted nuanced differences between compositional go’ī, recitational ḵẖwānī, the danced mūjra, and expertise in performance.
Celebrating women writers through the taẕkira genre was particularly meaningful. By working with poetry, these women transcended their local affiliations to bazaars and troupes, and had authentic access to a pan-regional, mobile network of literary performers, working alongside and sometimes competing against men. The biographical sketches confirm that following 1857 familiar patronage systems were unsettled, and female performers and writers moved between cities, especially from Lucknow and Delhi to Calcutta, Rampur, and other secure urban centres. At the same time, there is little sense of total disruption: women continued writing, forging connections with connoisseur networks, and performing. Their recurrent appearances in print underline that the most educated courtesans survived the upheaval of the Uprising and legislation of the 1860s and did not disappear. The record of male poets who taught these women suggests the cultural significance of smaller places, especially satellite towns around metropolitan centres. The variety of women listed (from pardanishīn to raṇḍī) suggests that in poetry circles there was not as rigid a boundary between courtesans and married women in the nineteenth century as is often supposed: to these men, a woman might be considered a whore and a fine poet at the same time. Finally, the taẕkiras bear testimony to the power of these women's language, which continued to be held in high esteem by the men who valued the Mughal society that these women's verses evoked.
Conclusion
The colonial city is usually thought of in terms of new technologies, ascendant middle class societies, and reformist agendas. Urban performance cultures were criticised, varieties of musician and dancer were persecuted, and “in the vernacular press the prostitute became a yardstick to measure every manner of evil within contemporary society”.Footnote 107 However, the transition between Mughal and colonial cultural sensibilities was neither linear nor universal, and the anti-nautch movement needs to be viewed relative to the non-reformist, less radical factions of society, which continued to patronise the established arts of dancing girls and courtesans. A focus on language is one method of qualifying changes in this period: efforts to control or condemn women's speech, especially in its public or sung forms, need to be read alongside taẕkiras that promoted and commemorated women poets and performers. The practice of imagining the city through its women was long-established in literary and musical circles, and was not immediately erased by colonialism.
Anita Anantharam reminds us that “when women's bodies are displaced, ignored, or outright silenced. . .they are refigured back into the public body by various strategies; we need to look in different places to find these voices”.Footnote 108 Although the public presence of performing women and the poetic imaginary of their verses came under attack in this period, the ongoing circulation of these lyrics and biographies indicates the preservation of an emotional community invested in courtesan culture. As Rosenwein has noted, emotional communities are multiple and overlapping: the patrons and teachers of public women could operate in a colonial society with its own conventions and emotional styles, as well as participate in pre-existing Mughal social practices, with quite distinct emotional connotations.
Examining networks between multiple metropolitan bazaars and smaller satellite towns, and exchanges between male ustāds and female students, indicates the continuity of older aesthetic sensibilities, that were undaunted by the rhetoric of the new critics. Language defined the reputations of public women from different regions and repertoires, and their elevated speech was considered powerful and precious. Men who appreciated the language of courtesans prepared a modern literary space for them through print: a space in which some performing women were able to cultivate new forms of reputation and prestige and resist the challenges of colonial society.
