Once one gets beyond the contested notion of “Tai lands” in the title of this insightful collection of essays, the total effect is a veritable story quilt of overlooked human collectives in the upper-Mekong region, seen in situ and viewed through sturdy theoretical lenses. The editor, Andrew Walker, emerged as both a grounded empiricist and incisive theoretician in his 1999 publication, The Legend of the Golden Boat: Regulation, Trade and Traders in the Borderlands of Laos, Thailand, China, and Burma (Honolulu: University of Hawai'i Press), which conclusively disavowed the notion of the upper-Mekong as too peripheral to evince vibrant life and bustling commerce of its own when compared to the center, i.e., Bangkok. On the contrary, his astutely elaborated ethnographic research into cross-border trade from Chiang Khong, Thailand across the Mekong to proximate transshipment points in Laos and then on to China vivified a scene of robust trade and enterprising lives of traders, many of whom were strong women.
In this new work, some of Walker's prior ideation, which focused more on state regulation and trade flows than on the topic of “community,” carries over into this volume. Here he drills deep into competing views of community and modernity. This time he sets out to argue in detail against outdated and limiting notions of “traditional community” (the self-sufficient village of past imaginings) to make new claims about “the modern community” (actors engaged with the state apparatus and international commerce). His aim is to present new and expanded understandings of the nature of community in its modern dress; it is buttressed with observations and opinions of seven Australia-based authors, four of whom, like him, are anthropologists and have done their homework in remote and unromantic places.
Among the most colorful in the collection of articles is Warren Mayes' chapter, “The Mechanics of Belonging: Regional Networks and Italian Scooters from Post-Revolutionary Laos.” The emergence of the Vientiane Scooter Club in the 1990s is an instance of a marginalized group—“hidden” urban Lao Vietnamese—at first cautiously coming together to build an informal association, a “modern community” as it were, that congealed around ownership of vintage Vespas. The motor scooters become metaphors for personal and political liberation abetted by the club members' skill in establishing patronage networks and in negotiating with border regulators as they complete group excursions into Vietnam. When the original Lao Vietnamese club expanded to include mainstream Lao, Bangkok Thai, and Chinese Lao riders as well, they pushed the envelope of belonging (“communitas”) to a transnational level and in their own quiet way, and defied the state and its definition of what it is to be a patriotic Lao citizen.
In contrast to the free spaces created by the Vespa crowd are the locked-in lives of low-ranking Lao forestry officials who live, uncoupled for the most part, in government dormitories from which most pivot back and forth between their distant family loci as money and free time permit. Sarinda Sing, author of the article “Living Within the State,” purposefully lived in such a dormitory in central upland Laos, sharing in the daily lives of these marginalized officials. It was in the “transparent moments” of the dormitory space where she discovered that even small groups can form a community, in this case, of persons and ideas impelled by the failure of the state to “deliver prosperity” to them or the district. Her somber narrative is very much an exercise in plus ça change: grossly underpaid low ranking government workers assigned to the periphery to implement a government policy of “poverty reduction” (echoing Burma!). They are the “public image” of the state dressed in various symbols of power, such as the World Bank stickers on office furniture and motor scooters for the seniors and District Agriculture and Forestry Office (DAFO) signage. The understandable lack of the officials' concern for national goals is replaced with their drive for personal prosperity in a “localized and hierarchical patronage system” (p. 164). One of the dormitory women, who privately lamented being stuck at a low rank for years, was finally nominated for a new, better-paying position because she had been publicly non-vocal and uncomplaining—and her nomination fulfilled the request of a foreign organization for more female representation: she became a token.
The allure of the center and negation of nostalgia is documented in “Re-configuring Belonging In Post-Socialist Xishuangbanna, China” by Antonella Diana. Here the unquestioned power and reach of Bejing has arrived at the point where one more in a series of PRC marginalized communities is in the final stages of “sinicization” (my term): the Tai Lue minority. What has not been accomplished by in-migration of large numbers of Han is instead being achieved by inculcating the value of suzhi or “quality” through incessant sloganeering and the teaching of Chinese language and culture to the post-Mao generations of Sipsongpanna Lue. Young people in the eighteen to twenty-five-year-old age group deride their parent's inability to speak good puthonghua (Mandarin Chinese); moreover, they look down on the “low quality” of their distant Lue cousins living across the very real national border in Muang Sing and other towns in northern Laos. Diana takes issue with the varied notions of “imagined/moral/trans-ethnic/structure of feeling/shared ethnic oppression/sacred topography” community; I find myself in total agreement with her endorsement of “Amit's tenet that [c]ommunity arises out of an interaction between the imagination of solidarity and its realization through social relations” (p. 197). These three foregoing essays and a concluding chapter by Walker, comprise Part 3: The Negotiated State.
In Part 1: Critical Engagements, historian Craig Reynolds begins with a lucid discourse on the emergence of the term “community” in Marxist thought and carries the topic through to the appearance of the term chumchon in Thai (in the early 1900s) and the age of community development that it ushered in. Immediately following is an impassioned piece of economic history, “Building Community in Capitalist Thailand,” by James Haughton, in which he sets out to correct what he considers are general misunderstandings of “economic circumstances and structures” that have taken place in a dynamic, largely urban Thailand, including the poorer rural areas. His argument is largely fashioned by archival research and a 2003 visit to a cluster of Isan villages (around Roi Et) that were part of a community development project funded by the Norwegian government, run by a Thai NGO and shaped by the King of Thailand's “sufficiency economy” scheme, which he unhesitatingly critiques. He instead champions the utility of rural credit unions or cooperatives, greater access to capital, and improved communication and transportation as a way to improve the lives of economically crippled villagers. In the next article, “Tai Community and Thai Border Subversions,” Nicholas Farrelly cautions against the Thai academic architects of a trans-frontier Tai community (the “Tai Studies Project”) who would erase the border between Thailand and Burma. Envisioning the Shan in Thailand as somehow primordial would render them “both invisible and illegitimate by an idealized discourse that undermines their claims for more rights within the Thai nation state” (p. 83). He adds color and cogency to his argument by quoting a Thai service station worker: “The Shan are everyone and everywhere. . . not just in this village” (p. 81).
Part 2, with two chapters, is labeled Local Networks. In the first chapter, “The Spirit of Community: Puta Belief and Communal Sentiment in Southern Laos,” Holly High elevates the discussion of community to an esoteric plane through an exquisite analysis of a ritual, liang puta, performed at a forest shrine in the third and sixth month of each lunar year. The community that participates in the protection-seeking cult is not extrinsically place-based, i.e., the village, but exists in “space-time” and includes members of households who move in and out of the village confines or in fact live permanently elsewhere. Membership is renewed by preparing a banana leaf envelope which holds fine strips of bamboo along which breaks are pinched for each person or animal included in the household. She asserts that the Lao state errs in overlooking such “mobile” communities that maintain an enduring relationship of shared sentiment of belonging. In designating the physical village, “a distinct, closed and geographically limited group,” as the locus of poverty reduction, the state succeeds primarily in extending its reach and making its temporal presence felt. The next piece, “The Festival, the Abbot and the Son of the Buddha,” is Walker's third essay in the collection. It is an ethnographic record of an elaborate celebration organized (in northern Thailand) at great cost in terms of volunteer labor and a compelled contribution of 400 baht from each of 120 households, regardless of wealth. This particular type of community enterprise can be seen as the action of suan huam, ‘the collective or group as a whole’ as opposed to suan tua, ‘the individual or personal.’ One “takeaway” from Walker's observations of this great festival serves in some ways as a template for understanding Thai political culture, past and present: “. . .while there is a flow of resources—labor in particular—from the suan tua to the suan huam, there is general acceptance that some level of benefit—cash and goods—will flow back in the other direction. The suan huam here is associated less with altruistic giving than with calculated exchange” (p.120).
This is an enjoyable book, excellent for students of anthropology and political science, critical for NGO and development workers, and perfect for an enlightened understanding of contemporary mainland—especially Buddhist—Southeast Asia. The articles are fluent; the bibliography is comprehensive, and the index is useful.
