No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 March 2004
During the past generation a number of scholars have examined the question of black property ownership in the South. None of the articles and books, however, has looked at the question from the perspective of slavery in West Africa and communal or kinship ownership in the United States. Dylan C. Penningroth uses a case study of the Fante region on the Gold Coast of Africa (present day Ghana), following the British emancipation in 1874, to show how kinship claims to property were in some ways similar to slave property ownership in the United States. In both locations, he writes, “ownership often included multiple, overlapping, and sometimes competing claims” (p. 41). Viewing the history of ex-slaves' negotiations “over property and social ties through the prism of African Studies,” the author contends, brings into better focus black social relationships. It turns attention away from white–black race relations and shows black kinship and black community life on “their own terms, with all their dynamism and noisy dissent, rather than as mere side effects of their dealings with whites” (p. 185).
The author follows his case study with an analysis of the internal slave economy and the changes that occurred as a result of the Civil War. The major theme that emerges is that the best way to view black property ownership in the mid-nineteenth century is not, as other historians have done, through cultural change (blacks accepting the ethos of acquisitiveness), or as a means of resistance, but rather through the prism of African history where the “negotiations over kinship, labor, and property” (p. 12) were pervasive.
Penningroth uses a wide variety of sources—-the WPA slave narratives, black autobiographies, Frederick Law Olmsted's travel accounts, and others. The author relies particularly heavily on the Southern Claims Commission reports. Created by Congress to reimburse Union loyalists who lost property to Union troops who were foraging for supplies and food during the Civil War, this evidence is skewed toward a few densely black populated sections of the Lower South, especially the Sea Islands and coastal regions of South Carolina and Georgia, and the Natchez and Vicksburg areas of Mississippi. Although the author makes every effort to place the interpretation—that black economic dealings were more social and communal than financial and economic—in a South-wide context, he keeps returning to these locations. Indeed, a few counties, including Liberty County, Georgia, appear to be extremely important to understanding his thesis. To the author's credit he admits that his evidence is only suggestive and in some respects “inconclusive” (p. 161). The theories advanced, however, are evocative, even if they do not offer a new methodology for conceptualizing African American property ownership.