Sustaining Human Rights in the Twenty-First Century: Strategies from Latin America is a much welcome and needed addition to the ever growing scholarship on human rights. The main contribution of this edited volume is two-fold: first, it explores strategies in the struggles for human rights, both past and present and, second, it considers approaches and concepts from Latin America, a region that has been at the forefront of accountability efforts for human rights violations over the past decades. Much of the existing literature tends to focus on either past human rights violations or contemporary human rights challenges, separating them out. This book avoids such an exclusive framing of the human rights question, seeking instead to ‘bridge the connection between past and present by showing how lessons from the past can help address the even protection, persistent vulnerability and evolving concepts of basic human rights around the world today’ (p. 10) as the editors, Mark Ungar and Katherine Hite, underline in Chapter 1.
The chapters in this collection delve into and are structured around a wide array of human rights themes, all of contemporary relevance and importance in Latin America. These range from coming to terms with the past in the aftermath of democratic transition or armed conflict, the role of the United Nations, immigration, the environment, rising levels of crime and insecurity, as well as economic, social and cultural rights. The different contributions revolve around ‘two broad trajectories’ that link past and present human rights concerns (p. 10). The first is the ‘shift from politics and law to accountability’, which emerged as part of efforts during democratic transitions, and the second is ‘a redefinition of citizenship in ways that strike a fundamentally new balance between state and society’, with distinct kinds of political identities and struggles emerging as a result (p. 10).
The book is divided into three parts and the chapter authors are all renowned human rights experts, including Alexander Wilde, Jo-Marie Burt, Priscilla Hayner and Elizabeth Lira.
In Part I, The Human Rights Idea, Alexander Wilde describes in Chapter 2 the evolution of the idea of human rights in Latin America and analyses the human rights movements in Chile and Colombia and how the latter affected politics and policy-making in these ‘two most different’ cases (p. 27). While the struggle to bring to justice Pinochet and his cronies in Chile for the crimes of the dictatorship marked a symbolic watershed across the whole of Latin America, Colombia's long-standing conflict pushes scholars and activists to question the traditional image of the victim of state violence, prompting a rethinking of classic understandings of accountability and responsibility that transcend the sole focus on the state, to encompass non-state actors as potential perpetrators of human rights violations. In Chapter 3, Thompson discusses some of the achievements and dangers for democracy in the region, highlighting the current disillusionment with democracy due to corruption, citizen insecurity as well as social inequality and exclusion.
Part II, Institutional and Legal Frameworks and the Question of Accountability, begins with Burt's comparative chapter on the recent advances in accountability for past atrocities. Citing Eduardo Galeano's phrase in reference to Uruguay labelling it a ‘sanctuary of impunity’ (p. 101), Burt underscores how the progress in accountability for human rights violations is ‘all the more remarkable’ in light of the tradition of impunity that characterised Latin America until a decade or so ago. Comparing the experiences of Peru, Argentina, Chile and Uruguay, Burt convincingly argues that Latin America has been a pioneer in using the domestic justice system to seek accountability, underlining how these advances resulted from both domestic and international pressures. Burt particularly emphasises how such progress would have been inconceivable without ‘the persistent, innovative political action of domestic human rights organisations and activists’ (p. 104), which have been key actors in the fight against impunity. Despite its protagonist role in transitional justice, Latin America remains the most unequal and most insecure region in the world: while homicide rates reduced elsewhere in the world, they increased in Latin America, with over 100,000 murders per year, totalling more than a million between 2000 and 2010 (see UNDP's latest Regional Human Development Report 2013–2014 for Latin America). Crime and rising levels of insecurity have unsurprisingly been ‘top concerns of Latin Americans’ (p. 195) since the mid-1990s and Mark Ungar approaches this essential subject in Chapter 7. Ungar traces the changing nature of violence as well as evolving perceptions in impunity, pointing out how nowadays, in many countries, ‘impunity is no longer about unpunished rights abuses from the authoritarian era, but about unresolved crimes’ (page 205) during democracy. A chapter on Mexico's security crisis in the context of the so-called ‘war on drugs’ would have been a useful inclusion here. In Chapter 8, Lira takes us back to the recent past and the Chilean case, discussing the country's trajectory in coming to terms with the traumatic legacy of Pinochet's dictatorship, which entailed a complex dynamic of socially and politically working through these events. Lira underlines how this process has led as an end result to ‘a radical questioning of the historic political foundation of governability in Chile’, whereby amnesty and impunity are no longer ‘entirely acceptable as the foundation for social peace’ (p. 231) within society.
In Part III, Citizens’ Movements and Conceptions of Citizenship, the economist Gordon Hanson tackles the immigration question, tracing the shift from traditional forms of political asylum seeking to today's practices, emphasising how immigration has ‘become a source of intense public debate’ in the developed world (p. 247). In Chapter 11, Segarra discusses people's rights to live in a healthy and safe environment, and the complexities associated with realising those rights. While countries such as Bolivia and Chile explicitly recognise them in their constitutions, it remains an uphill struggle to hold state and non-state actors accountable for actions that have a negative impact on health and the environment. In Chapter 12, Hite investigates the ‘explosion of a politics of memory in Latin America in which human rights movements are chief protagonists’ (p. 31), highlighting once again, as in Burt's earlier chapter, the fundamental role of activists and human rights organisations in the fight against impunity in this region. In the Epilogue, Crahan examines some of the future challenges to human rights protection, drawing attention to how today's violations ‘have a multitude of authors’ (p. 380) and often even democratic states are ill-equipped to effectively respond to them.
This compelling set of essays offers a refined account of human rights challenges in Latin America, cutting across time and generations of rights, reframing the relationship among human rights concerns along a historical continuum, whereby past and present are closely interwoven and inter-related, despite their particularities and defining features. Scholars and students of human rights and Latin America will benefit from this fascinating volume in comprehending and unpacking the complexities that surround human rights struggles and their enduring relevance in contemporary Latin America.
