The subtitle of this new volume raises a question for which there is likely no resolution. It has to do with the intended audience of this now well-established biography series, each slim book devoted to a figure of Islamic history notable to the present day. One understands these readers to be literate but lay, nonspecialists with little detailed sense of the material at hand. The subject of the present work is ʿUthman ibn ʿAffan (r. 644–56 CE). He was, of course, the third and arguably most controversial of the immediate successors to Muhammad, the men that the Sunni tradition would come to know as the “rightly-guided” caliphs. He deserves a volume in the Makers series, but how to write it? Keaney addresses ʿUthman's tenure in office, so one is privy to the history—as best we understand it—but she concentrates on the issues that crowd his legacy and reputation in Islamic collective memory. She has opted, in other words, to foreground issues of interpretation and sectarian debate, as her subtitle indicates. What does this mean for our lay reader?
ʿUthman's story is that of the early Arab Islamic community and state. Keaney knows to situate one against the other. Our imagined reader is well served, for example, in the opening chapter. Here Keaney sums up what modern scholars generally see as the context in which the early caliphate took shape: a late antique Arabia transformed by the formative teachings of a charismatic prophetic figure and the array of opportunity and challenge—material, fiscal, imperial, sectarian—produced by success on the battlefield and the ensuing project of imperial state-building. Keaney is no less helpful in successive chapters in setting details of the new caliph's reign against the wider framework. So, for example, treating ʿUthman's election following the assassination of `Umar ibn al-Khattab in 644 CE, Keaney considers the Arabian tribal practice of shūra (consultation) and the pressures to which it was subjected in this instance. Similarly, in her fourth chapter, Keaney provides a capsule account of the early conquests and the varied dilemmas brought on by victory and defeat alike for the nascent Arab Islamic order. A fifth chapter takes up the later part of ʿUthman's reign, at which point the caliph confronted a chorus of complaints and, ultimately, armed confrontation over questions of nepotism, corruption, overreach of the Medinan center, and decisions on his part and the part of his supporters regarding the Qurʾan.
So our reader learns of the historic setting and the details of this one caliphate. But this material, the history, occurs along the way; Keaney's main discussion deals with its reception and handling by later generations of Muslim commentators, historians, and sectarian actors. Keaney warns as much at the start: “[It] is difficult to exhume the person of Uthman buried under the paradigmatic role of a prominent Companion of the Prophet and caliph” (5). But it is a brief comment, and our reader may not take its full measure: the material of the history will take second seat to the many difficulties raised by the Arab Islamic historiographic tradition. A specific example concerns the act of regicide with which ʿUthman's caliphate reached its unhappy end. Did he fall as tyrant or martyr? From the very onset of Islamic history, perhaps, the question was caught up in how one saw the proper achievement of the community and, more to the point, the task of representing the first generation of Muslims, that is, Muhammad's companions. For Sunni scholars and historians, the task turned on an image of these men, in this case ʿUthman, as “righteous, unified, and above reproach” (134), all this to preserve communal integrity, legitimize the teachings of successive generations of Sunni teachers and their work, and parry the claims of their Shiʿi counterparts. For the latter tradition, the companions, and principally ʿUthman among them, fell short by refusing to endorse the proper claims to authority of ʿAli ibn Abi Talib, the first of the declared imams, and his progeny.
The terms of sectarian memory were shaped early on and remained. The volume begins and ends with the way ʿUthman is remembered today in Muslim popular imagination (Keaney refers to ʿUthman's character in an Egyptian Ramadan TV series from 2001) and contemporary political debate (she refers to its shifting use by the leadership of al-Azhar in relation to the overthrow of Hosni Mubarak, the long-standing dictator of Egypt, in early 2011). The point is that if scholars in Arabic, Islamic, and Middle Eastern studies have felt comfortable producing canned renditions of, in this case, the biographies of exemplary figures, this is typically no longer the case. Most scholars active in the field today, Heather Keaney among them, have taken on board more subtle (and more difficult) approaches to the sources produced in a variety of Middle Eastern languages from the pre-Islamic period onward. As this turn suggests, any reconstruction based on these sources, certainly of a figure as central to Islamic communal self-understanding as the third caliph, is deeply fraught, as one must negotiate the considerable body of polemic and representation that runs through the sources, Sunni and Shiʿi alike.
But, again, where does this leave our lay reader? History and its reconstruction are inherently unstable, and Keaney does a fine job illustrating the point with regard to ʿUthman's career and reputation. But is an introductory volume the place to make the point? Ultimately, of course, there is no paradigmatic reader: many will appreciate Keaney's approach, others will struggle, others will turn away. Advanced students, I think, will benefit very much from a reading, not only from what it teaches them of history and Arab and Islamic historiography alike, but also for its skillful synthesis of recent scholarship.
