The House of Lords when I took my seat shortly after my father's death of pneumonia in 1931 – which took place a few years before the discovery of penicillin and other antibiotics – was a very different place from what it has become over 60 years later.
I have now become the longest active member, having served continuously in Government or Opposition or as Chairman of Committees, apart from a short break during the war years, and my time in Ghana as Governor-General.
It was at that time an entirely hereditary chamber, apart of course from a handful of Bishops and Law Lords. The Labour Party, as the official Opposition, could only man two Benches, including the Front Bench, and in 1938 could still muster no more than 15 Peers. They were greatly outnumbered by the 80 Liberals, also of course on the Opposition side of the House. In fact, I remember a protracted argument between my Leader Lord Ponsonby, and the Leader of the Liberal Party, the Marquis of Crewe,Footnote 592 about which party was entitled to occupy the Opposition Benches immediately facing the Ministers sitting on the Government Front Bench. It was decided in favour of Lord Ponsonby, because the Labour Party was the official Opposition and occupied this position on the Opposition Front Bench in the House of Commons. The Conservative Party had even then a permanent majority of between 300 and 400 Peers in the House.
Perhaps even more striking than the differences in composition was the difference in our working hours. In those days the Law Lords used to sit and deliver their Judgments and heard all appeals in the Chamber before legislative business had begun in the afternoon, so we never started our work before 4.30 pm at the earliest. We rarely sat on a Monday, never on a Friday, and we almost always adjourned by 7.30 pm, so that every noble Lord could get a hot bath and change into a dinner jacket suit before dinner, and prepare for a long weekend at his country seat.
This, indeed, was a life of leisure, compared to our present strenuous daily routine, with legislative business or general debates starting as a rule in the early afternoon. We regard ourselves now as somewhat lucky if the House rises in the early evening. Another illustration of our leisurely life was the fact that in those days the Lord Chancellor had only two Deputy Speakers, the Chairman of Committees and Lord Airedale,Footnote 593 instead of the 20 odd he has now.
So far I have only mentioned the legislative and deliberative pre-occupations of the House when it is sitting in the Chamber. But apart from the sessional Committees concerned with our domestic arrangements, procedure, and administration, we now have a number of subject ‘Committees’ which meet in the morning and very often sit all day. I shall deal later on with the more detailed work of these Committees.
Another field in which there has been a substantial increase in the work of the House is that of Private Bills. These are Bills promoted by individuals, or bodies such as Local Authorities, petitioning Parliament for powers which they cannot exercise under the General Law. A recent example is the London Underground, authorising the construction of the extension to the Jubilee Line. Like Public Bills, they have to pass through both Houses of Parliament, but as they do not emanate from the Government they are not handled by Ministers. They are therefore the responsibility in both Houses of a politically neutral officer of each House, the Chairman of Ways and Means in the Commons; and the Chairman of Committees in the Lords. These Officers are also the Senior Deputy Speakers in their respective Chambers.
There can be no doubt that the House worked much harder in the 80's and 90's than it did in the 30's. As late as 1956 the average daily attendance was 104, and the number of sitting days 130 in the year. The corresponding figures in 1985 were 315 and 142 respectively.Footnote 594 But the vital question is whether it has become a more efficient and useful legislative body. This can best be judged by the extent to which it has been able to complement the work done by the House of Commons, both on Public Bills and Select Committees, and in general debate on issues of national importance. There has been an enormous increase in the number of amendments made by the Lords during the Committee and Report stages of Public Bills, and a great majority of these minor alterations have been accepted as improvements by the Commons. The Lords rarely, insists on an amendment rejected by the Commons.
The influx of talented representatives of the professions is a striking and remarkable change since I took my seat early in 1932. It has been mainly due to the Life Peerages Act of 1958,Footnote 595 which has also made possible the establishment of the Select Committees which in recent years have added so much value to the detailed scrutiny of Government policy. Their presence is signified by the growth in the number of Independent Cross-Bench Peers, which by 1984 had already exceeded the combined total of Labour and Liberal Peers. Since the abolition of the University SeatsFootnote 596 there have been few Independents in the House of Commons. So they also serve a useful purpose in representing a considerable cross-section of public opinion without any firm Party attachment.
A joint Select Committee of both Houses (on which I was lucky enough to be chosen to sit) recommended to Parliament that the succession to an hereditary title could be relinquished during the successor's lifetime. Parliament accepted our advice, and several Peers by succession have done so for different reasons – such as a career in the House of Commons,Footnote 597 the expense of being a Lord, or an objection to titles – without attracting much public attention. It would certainly have made it easier for me if Legislation of this kind had been passed some years earlier.
I do not find that the House has become more informal in its habits, or more inclined to take advantage of the absence of a Speaker to enforce the rules of procedure. I remember that Lord Onslow,Footnote 598 and before him Lord Donoughmore,Footnote 599 used to wear a frock coat as Chairman of Committees, but their successors have not followed what may have been an uncomfortable formality of the House in the 19th Century. Any transgression of the rules of procedure is still easily contained by a few words from the Leader of the House, or an occasional shout of ‘Order, Order’. It is striking how soon well known hecklers from the House of Commons have accepted the self-discipline of the Lords. A few elderly Back Bench Conservative Peers still wore top hats in the Chamber, I remember among them Lord Banbury of Southam.Footnote 600
I would like to record my impression, and after all these years it can only be an impression, of some of my colleagues in the House of Lords before the war. I have already mentioned my Leader, Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede, much respected even by those who most abhorred his opinions, to whom I owe a large debt of gratitude for my initiation into the procedure and personalities of the House. There was no Deputy Leader of the Opposition, so his second-in-command was our Chief Whip, Lord Marley.Footnote 601 A former officer in the regular army, he retained some of its external habits. The brisk walk, the upright figure, the smart appearance, accompanied a genuine feeling for the underdog shared by his delightful wife whose warm heart and unfailing support gave him a happy home background. But his revolutionary socialist views led to serious criticism in the House when his American lecture tours were reported in the British press. He was certainly used by the Communist Party in the US to put their case to large audiences from coast to coast. It was represented to my Leader that the House of Lords was being brought into disrepute by a British Peer preaching the communist doctrine of the Soviet Union, advocating at that time world revolution, in the United States. Marley was obliged to resign.
Another figure whom I remember vividly from the time I first took my seat in the Lords was the Leader of the Liberal Party, the Marquis of Crewe. In appearance, with his elastic-sided boots, his tail coat, and his stick-up white collar, he was a survivor from the Edwardian era. But his whole life testified to his genuine Liberalism, a patrician born into a cultured literary family who was more of a radical than a whig. From his appointment by Gladstone, at that time a fervent Home Ruler, as Viceroy of Ireland until his retirement to become Leader of the Liberal Party in the House of Lords [for the second time, in 1936], he had sat in every Liberal Cabinet since the Liberal election victory in 1906. In the long struggle between the Lords and Commons over the passing of the Parliament Act,Footnote 602 he did not hesitate to support his party, and share with his small group of Liberals in the Lords the final threat of creating enough Peers to carry the Bill. His speeches in the Lords were always heard with respectful attention on all sides of the House. He was, however, handicapped by a slow and painfully hesitant delivery. One of his female relatives is supposed to have remarked that she hoped her delivery would not be as difficult as that of her noble kinsman.
In the years before the last World War the House was predominantly concerned with agriculture, which reflected the landed or farming interests of most of its members. There were always two parliamentary Under-Secretaries at the Ministry of Agriculture, and one of these had to be in the Lords to reply to the frequent questions and debates on this subject. I had a short spell in this capacity during the 1951 Labour Government,Footnote 603 and I much enjoyed my travels around the country to meet the County Agricultural Executives, when I was expected to exhort farmers to grow more food to make up for the food shortage that had persisted for so long after the war. I found a good friend in the Secretary of the Agricultural Workers Union, George Brown,Footnote 604 later himself in the Lords, and did what I could to support his claim for an improvement in the wretched wages of the agricultural labourer. I am sure the infinite patience farmers learned from exposure to the trials and tribulations of nature taught them to cope with an ignorant Londoner like myself, speaking from a Whitehall brief prepared by civil servants who knew as little as I did about practical farming. I also remember the last occasion on which a Peer was tried on a criminal charge by his Peers as required by law. The Court assembled in the Royal Gallery, and the Lord Chancellor, as Lord Steward, with his fellow Law Lords presided. The Defendant in this case was Lord de Clifford,Footnote 605 who was charged with an offence arising from a road accident. He was acquitted by the Jury of his Peers. I did not myself participate in the trial, as I did not wish to be party to what was obviously an anachronistic procedure. This procedure was extinguished in 1948 by legislation requested by the House of Lords.
When I returned to the House of Lords in 1960, after I had completed my three years service in Ghana, I took my place, after a provisional interval of political neutrality observed before and after my appointment, on the Front Opposition Bench. I first served under Lord Jowett [sic], when I assisted as an ex-Postmaster-General in dealing with the Broadcasting Bill. We both warned the House at the time about the risks of allowing advertisements to pay for the new Commercial channels, which would compete with the BBC, and might lower its standards by threatening to take away listeners to public service programmes.
It was not until 1965 that an opportunity occurred of doing something more constructive and useful for the whole House. This was an offer to succeed MerthyrFootnote 606 as Chairman of Committees. He had been anxious for some time to retire, in order to enjoy his few remaining years on what he called his ‘boat’ – which was in fact a very comfortable luxury yacht which he sailed on the Mediterranean. At that time his principal assistant had been Lord Airedale. The essential qualification for this post, apart from regular attendance, was to be sufficiently unabrasive, and not to antagonise any substantial section of the House. Airedale had unfortunately fallen out as a robust and active Liberal with some of my Labour colleagues, and they also took the view that it was time for a member of the official Opposition Party to claim this important office. The Labour Party was the only Party in the House not to have provided a Chairman of Committees from among its numbers, and my Leader, Lord Longford,Footnote 607 decided to put my name forward. He first ascertained that the Conservative Party would not object. Their Leader, Lord Carrington,Footnote 608 was entirely agreeable, but he was slightly doubtful about some of his Conservative followers, particularly an ex-Lord Chancellor, who had some influence in the Party. However, he and I had been nodding acquaintances at Eton, and I am afraid that this removed the doubt about my suitability. My nomination was therefore supported by all the Party Leaders, and I was elected by the House nemine dissentiente.Footnote 609 I was already familiar with some of the duties of the WoolsackFootnote 610 – as the Chairman of Committees was also a Deputy Speaker – because when I was Chief Opposition Whip it was the custom for one of the two Party Chief Whips, who were obliged to stay in the Chamber until the House rose at the end of its daily proceedings, to occupy the Woolsack if the Lord Chancellor was not present at the finish.
The office to which I had succeeded in 1965 had a long pedigree, and was second in importance among the Officers of the House to that of the Lord Chancellor as Speaker. An official Chairman of Committees was only formally appointed for the first time by the House, in a series of resolutions passed on July 23rd, 1800, which still govern the appointment and the functions of the present Chairman. He is still chosen by the House at the beginning of every new session, he still presides over Committees of the whole House and over Committees on Private Bills, and he is still a salaried officer of the House.
The origin of the official appointment of a Chairman of Committees is an interesting example of the slow evolution of parliamentary procedure. It was no more in fact than open recognition of what had for a very long time been the actual practice of the House. From at least the middle of the 18th Century there had been one Lord who was usually chosen to take the Chair in Committees of the whole House and in its Select Committees. It seems that there were usually a number of impoverished Lords who were in hope of Government largesse in giving so much of their time to the work of the House. From the session that began in January 1795, until his formal appointment as Chairman of Committees in 1800, Lord WalsinghamFootnote 611 had continued to occupy the same position and to discharge the same duties in the House and its Select Committees. His experience of Private Bill Committees went back to 1782. After 1800 Walsingham was re-appointed annually in every session until 1814, when he retired on account of ‘ill health and infirmity’. At least he had the support of qualified Counsel during his later years, for in 1808 the House resolved upon a Humble Address to the Crown representing ‘That the office of Counsel to the Chairman of Committees of the House of Lords is an office to which very material duties are annexed’ and praying for his ‘better remuneration’. In recent years the number of Private Bills have increased to such an extent that my lucky successor, Lord Aberdare,Footnote 612 was able to benefit from more professional legal advice than I had.
Walsingham's retirement in 1814 was marked by a suitable eulogy in a ‘Humble Address’ to the Prince Regent,Footnote 613 commending ‘His Lordship's eminent and essential services to His Royal Highness's most gracious consideration’. The Prince Regent's response was equally laudatory, and asked the House to concur in the grant of an annuity of £2,000 per annum. None of Lord Walsingham's successors have, unluckily, been equally fortunate.
During the whole of my time as Chairman of Committees I heard no-one cast the slightest doubt on my political neutrality, in spite of my past record as a Labour Minister of the Crown. At the start of the new session following the defeat of the Labour Government in 1970, I was immediately assured that Conservative Ministers in the Lords wished me to carry on. My workload of Private Bills was increasing so rapidly that I had to ask for some assistance. I was delighted when the House appointed one of our few women Peers, Priscilla Tweedsmuir,Footnote 614 to assist me as the principal Deputy Speaker. This she did though her main task was to chair the recently appointed European Communities Committee. It was good that the officers of the House should not continue to be an entirely male preserve, and she herself was not only an ideal colleague but had a lightness of touch which I much envied in enlivening even the dullest Committees.
Although as a rule our hours of work were considerably shorter than they are now, we had the occasional all-night sittings, when the Government wanted to pass a Bill of special urgency through all its stages in the House. Priscilla and I divided the night's work between us, as we felt it would be unfair to involve any of the unpaid Deputies. We did short stints of two hours each between 9.00 pm and 7.00 am, so as to avoid the risk of falling asleep while off [on?] duty! Her early death was a tragic loss to us all.
When I retired from my post in 1976, I sat for a short time on the Cross-Benches, which emphasised the neutrality I had assumed for the past 11 years. Since then I have had more time to consider the future of the House of Lords and its proper function in our parliamentary system, and I shall now set out a few of my own thoughts on this subject.
I am convinced that the House of Lords can still justify its existence by the need to revise legislation coming to it from the House of Commons. Parts of some Bills are often withheld altogether from parliamentary scrutiny by the use of the ‘closure’ or ‘guillotine’ in the House of Commons. Less controversial Bills are often introduced and pre-digested in the Lords before they are passed on to the Lower House. In this way it does succeed in complementing, without attempting to rival, the elected Chamber. No more delay can be justified than that required for the considered opinion of both Houses to be expressed on the Government's legislative proposals. Without careful scrutiny of the drafting and substance of every clause of a Public Bill in the Lords, the Commons would probably have to add at least another stage to every important measure.
Owing to the pressure of Government business in the Commons, the Lords has always had more time to discuss matters of public importance, such as unemployment, education, housing, or foreign affairs, which Opposition Leaders or Back Benchers wish to raise, and to allocate one day in the week when debates take precedence over public legislation. We are particularly fortunate to have many of the leaders of the professions, who do not have to attend regularly, but come to give their advice on subjects requiring their expertise, such as ex-diplomats on foreign policy, or retired Field Marshals or others eminent in military matters on defence. Before the last World War we had naturally fewer representatives of the Armed Services. The contribution of these experts from many different fields can only be expected to continue so long as the Lords maintains its relative immunity from the Party battle that must and should dominate debate in the elected Chamber.
Much of the useful but least conspicuous work of the Lords is done by its Select Committees. The reports of these Committees are published and debated by the House, where the Minister representing the Government replies to the debate. The most important of these Committees was set up after we joined the European Community, and is called the European Communities Committee. It has no less than six sub-committees, each of which deals with a different aspect in the field of legislation covered by Brussels, such as finance, transport, agriculture, environment etc. Most of the sub-committee members are co-opted for their special knowledge of the subject dealt with by the Committee. This gives their Reports special authority, and sometimes they are more widely read then those of the Commons.
We also have a Committee on Science and Technology, which includes members of the Royal Society and one Nobel Prize winner. It is a pity that we do not have more of these expert Committees, on other vital topics, such as health, education, unemployment, or foreign affairs. There is certainly room for a further expansion of the work of our Select Committees but the House is careful not to duplicate work done by Select Committees in the House of Commons.
It is of course desirable for any changes in the powers or composition of the Lords to be acceptable to both the major political Parties, Conservative and Labour, and to the Liberal Democratic Party so long as it is represented in Parliament. As long ago as 1968 an Inter-Party Conference on the reform of the House of Lords produced an agreed report, embodied in a White Paper and published in November of that year, which included the recommendation that in future membership should be by creation alone, and the succession to a hereditary Peerage should no longer carry with it a right to a seat in the House of Lords.Footnote 615
If the proposals in this White Paper had been approved by Parliament, the main problem of reform of the House of Lords would have been almost completely solved 20 years ago. Its recommendations went first to the Lords, where they were accepted by a majority of 251 votes to 56 votes in favour of the proposals in the White Paper. In the Commons it was also carried by a smaller majority. The Government then introduced the Parliament number 2 Bill which received a Second Reading, but was bogged down in Committee, mainly due to filibustering speeches by Michael FootFootnote 616 and Enoch PowellFootnote 617 from opposite ends of the political spectrum. Their obstructive tactics were successful in obtaining the withdrawal of the Bill, which the then Labour Government decided would take up too much parliamentary time. Thus the latest opportunity to reform the Lords fizzled out. By 1977 the Labour Party had reverted to its traditional policy of outright abolition, though since then it has had second thoughts about a non-hereditary indirectly elected Second Chamber.
But the present degree of dilution of the hereditary Peerage is by no means sufficient to give a Labour Government a reasonable chance of getting its legislation through a chamber with an inbuilt Conservative majority. For this we shall need to go back to the White Paper of 1968, which advocated a two-tier structure of Peers, with voting powers and non-voting Peers, which would include most of the hereditary Peers, with the right to speak but not to vote. Succession to a Peerage would no longer confer membership of the House of Lords, but existing hereditary Peers would remain as non-voting members for their lifetimes. The voting Peers would constitute the working House. It could of course include the young and bright hereditary Peers, who have already done such excellent work in recent years, if they are granted voting rights.
This immediately raises the question of how and by whom the voting Peers should be chosen. From this it can be seen that I favour appointment rather than election for a reformed House of Lords. It seems to me that any form of election, whether direct or indirect, would be regarded as a threat by the House of Commons. It is most important that the legislative supremacy of the House of Commons, as the only elected Chamber, should be upheld in appearance as well as in fact. A further consideration is that the House of Commons would be most unlikely to pass a Bill that would considerably strengthen the authority of the Upper House.
The obvious difficulty about appointment is the extended power of patronage this would give the Prime Minister. Prime Ministers of all parties, from Lloyd George to the present day, have shown they cannot be trusted not to favour their friends or Party supporters. Of two recent Prime Ministers it can be said that one was unduly kind to his friends, and that another favoured those who were closely associated with companies that gave large contributions to Party funds. At present the only constraint on the Prime Minister's exercise of patronage is imposed by the Political Honours Scrutiny Committee, which can veto obviously unsuitable candidates. But the function of this Committee is to prevent undesirable appointments, rather than to propose the best candidates. For that purpose a stronger and more representative Committee should be appointed. What is needed is a body of elder statesmen and privy councillors, not themselves directly involved in day-to-day Party politics, which would be acceptable to both Houses, and have the approval of the Lord Chancellor and the Speaker of the House of Commons. This surely would be the most satisfactory way of securing life Peers from every walk of life, who would be chosen on their personal merits and their record of public service.
The non-voting Peers, would have except in this respect, exactly the same rights as other Peers, and there is no reason why they should not vote on matters arising in Select Committees of the House or on Private Bill Committees. As they would not continue to constitute the great majority, non-voting Peers might speak more often than voting Peers on Motions or Bills before the House, and their expert knowledge on subjects to which they are personally or professionally concerned would continue to be a unique contribution to Parliamentary debates. In the course of time the Chamber would ultimately become a Chamber of life Peers, as the successors to hereditary Peerages would no longer have the right to a seat in Parliament. They would be Peers of the Realm, but not Peers of Parliament.
An exception should of course be made for the Bishops of the Church of England. Whether or not the Church should be separately represented in the Lords, is a matter for public opinion to decide. There are some who favour disestablishment. But so long as the Protestant Christian Church remains established I have often thought, especially in view of our large ethnic minorities, that other forms of worship should be represented. The Bishop of Durham has recently said he would have no objection to seeing Roman Catholic Bishops or the non-conformist Moderator in the House of Lords. The main religious denominations: Catholic, Jewish, Non-conformist, Moslem, Hindu; should choose their own representatives as Life Peers.
So much for the composition of the Lords, as I would like to see it. A chamber of life Peers, male and female, comprising voting Peers with a right to speak and vote, and non-voting Peers with only a right to speak, while taking part in all the other activities of the House. I would expect the large contingent of Cross-Bench Peers to maintain their independence of Party affiliation. It is unlikely that any Party would have an absolute majority of voting Peers, but it would become a constitutional convention that the Government of the day should not be obstructed by the unreasonable use by the Lords of its delaying powers in obtaining consent for their legislation. It would probably be essential to fix a retiring age, in order to prevent the House from growing to an unreasonable size or an excessive age.
After a radical change in composition there would be less need for any substantial diminution in its present powers. The most contentious of these powers is the right to veto subordinate legislation. The administrative decisions of Ministers which are sufficiently important require parliamentary sanction of a negative or affirmative character. The negative order becomes law within a limited period of time unless it is annulled. The affirmative order comes into force after the express approval of both Houses. It is surely anomalous that the Lords should have the right to veto any form of legislation. It should be sufficient for them to express views which Ministers would take into account, and allow them to be over-ridden by the House of Commons if they disagree. This is in fact what happens usually in practice, as the power of rejection is too dangerous to use by the Lords, and no Ministerial Order can be amended. It might be said that the Lords should at least be able to delay subordinate legislation but there has been no demand for this additional degree of control over Ministers.
The limit of one year's delay for Public Bills approved by the House of Commons has not caused any serious conflict between the Houses. The most recent example of a Bill passed by the Commons over the heads of the Lords was the War Crimes Bill.Footnote 618 Its retrospective character condemned it in the Lords, where the legal profession is stronger, but the Commons took an opposite view and the Bill received the Royal Assent after the statutory lapse of time.
I think a certain amount of modernising could be done now with the consent of the House. The Lord Chancellor's duties are our only survival from the days before the division of powers. He is a Judge, a Cabinet Minister, Head of the Judiciary and also Speaker of the House of Lords, and he combines the duties of all these offices in his own person. Other countries have a Minister of Justice, responsible for a Department dealing with the Judiciary and the Courts. I can see no strong reason for not transferring the Lord Chancellor's present departmental duties to another Minister, answerable to either House.Footnote 619 This would give him more time for his judicial functions, and for presiding over the House of Lords from the Woolsack. It would avoid the present system of appointment of some 20 Deputy Speakers, none of whom could be so well versed in the procedures of the House as an almost whole-time Speaker. It always amazes me how successfully Lord Chancellors have survived their intolerable workload, which has steadily increased with the longer sittings of the House. I can only remember one occasion when a new Lord Chancellor seemed rather visibly dependent on prompting from the Clerk at the Table, who had to run to the Woolsack with the necessary procedural advice.
There is one way in which Governments seem deliberately to prevent the Lords from giving proper consideration to their Bills. They do this by applying the existing rule of law that all unfinished Public Bills expire at the end of a parliamentary session. They cannot be revived until the following session, when they are re-introduced. On the other hand, Private Bills are often ‘carried over’ from one session to another, as the prohibition applies only to Public Bills. But I am afraid it is hard to imagine any Government altering a rule that is so much to their advantage but some useful Bills would pass into law if they were allowed to run for two sessions instead of only one.
The House of Lords is a courteous and friendly place. Its courtesy is not a mere formality, because it is an expression of the friendly feeling and respect which cuts right across Party lines. It is because issues are usually debated on their merits, and without regard to scoring Party points, that there is so little hostility between the Parties. Another factor is the large number of Cross-Benchers. There are usually more Cross-Benchers amending in the course of a single Session than members of either the Liberal or Labour Parties. The fate of a Government can be decided in the Commons. In the Lords the Government can frequently be defeated without any loss of public support, as such defeats are due to a combination of members from all parts of the House.
Its proceedings can be deadly dull, but in almost any debate you can hear a speaker who really knows what he is talking about, and regular attendance is a liberal education. However outrageous an opinion, it is there to be heard, and if you disapprove you leave the Chamber, you don't shout the speaker down. Its usefulness in amending the drafting and the substance of public Bills gives it a unique place in our Constitution.
So long as the Lords continue to assist and complement the work of the House of Commons, its usefulness will not be questioned. But its survival will depend on its willingness to play a constitutional role that in all matters of Government policy gives the last word to the elected Chamber, and prefers persuasion, influence, and collaboration to the exercise of its diminished and strictly limited political powers. I hope the House survives as an example of courteous, rational, and civilised debate and discussion of public affairs, and I am deeply grateful for all the tolerance and kindness I have personally received from all quarters during a span of over 60 years.
