Theosis is a disputed interpretation of Christian salvation. It has roots in the Second Testament and quietly wends its way through Christian theology, overtly in the Christian East, obliquely in the Christian West. The editors of this volume invited five other scholars to illuminate theosis in various periods and central figures. After these treatments it seems clear that divinisation within Christianity is a slippery topic, but not a slippery slope, as some have feared. In the hands of master theological craftsmen like Athanasius, Augustine, Maximus, Calvin, Jonathan Edwards and T. F. Torrance, the Christian doctrine is both clearly distinguished from its pagan predecessor, and does not fall prey to blurring the creator–creature divide or to diminishing human individuality, as popular and largely uninformed opinion has feared, and as the doctrine's most popular expression – God became human that we might become divine – might erroneously lead one to believe. Having mentioned the master craftsmen of the doctrine, it is worth noting the absence of important figures like Ps.-Dionysius, Boethius and John Scotus Eriugena from the volume, a curious omission while there is a whole chapter on theosis in the First Testament, where it does not really appear, and much attention to the Reformed tradition that is quite hesitant about the idea.
The essays point to the beginnings of deification in the apostolic fathers and apologists of the second century and its recurrence through the nineteenth century with Vladimir Sovloviev – a most idiosyncratic Christian thinker – and the twentieth with Torrance, a weighty Reformed voice yet open to insights from the East. One of the most interesting essays is on Augustine that examines this doctrine in his newly discovered sermons.
The authors often note that theosis is not an alternative to atonement-dominated soteriology because christology is essential to theosis all along the line. Though working separately, together they offer a fuller soteriological vision than has been common in modern theology, and in that regard the book delivers a healthy reminder of just how expansive the Christian vision of salvation is. The tantalising possibility is that theosis does not stand over against penal substitution, for example, but that both, as well as the visio dei all sway and bob in the great current of desire for God that is at the core of so much Christian hope. It also offers a focused reminder of the dangers of trying to separate dogmatics from spirituality. Still, the effort would have benefited greatly from better design.
