Gary Shapiro has been thinking with and about Friedrich Nietzsche for more than four decades. In this, his fourth book devoted exclusively or primarily to Nietzsche's thought, Shapiro focuses attention on several themes in Nietzsche's oeuvre that he thinks have not received the scholarly attention they deserve. In so doing, he brings Nietzsche's thinking to bear on questions of globalization, world history and its end, geophilosophy, political aesthetics, and political theology in ways that both challenge how Nietzsche traditionally has been read and suggest how Nietzsche has much to contribute to our thinking about some of the most pressing political issues of the day.
In the introductory chapter, Shapiro lays out the guiding thought of his book: Nietzsche puts forward the earth (Erde), sometimes the “human-earth” (Menschen-Erde) as a pointed alternative to the concept of world (Welt), a concept that takes center stage in Hegel's championing of present modernity as the end of world history. The Hegelian “world” is a culminating concept in which the telos of philosophy, art, politics, religion, and so forth makes itself present in the current age. The earth, on the other hand, is open to the future, open to great events as well as great politics, and Nietzsche sees it as his task to announce and prepare the way for a future human-earth.
Shapiro's second chapter offers readings of Nietzsche's four Unmodern Observations (his preferred translation of the Unzeitgemässe Betrachtungen) that exemplify Shapiro's desire to triangulate Nietzsche's thought between current ideas of modernity and globalization and the nineteenth-century versions of those ideas. In the first two Observations, David Strauss and Edouard von Hartmann are criticized for framing the emergence of Bismarck's German Reich as, respectively, an optimistic and a pessimistic version of Hegel's “end of history.” Shapiro argues that Nietzsche's critiques offer resources to challenge recent triumphalist accounts of the end of history (e.g., Fukuyama and the neocon responses to the fall of the Berlin Wall and breakup of the Soviet Union) and not-so-recent ones (e.g., Kojève). The Observations on Schopenhauer presents him as an alternative to the glib journalistic thinking that dominated the universities of his day, while Richard Wagner in Bayreuth champions Wagner as himself a “great event” ushering in a new future. This chapter ends with Shapiro defending the interesting thesis that Nietzsche gave up on his plan to continue the series of Unmodern Observations because he came to realize that his praise of Wagner was in fact grounded on Wagner's Hegelianism, a position that was incoherent with the work's otherwise resolute anti-Hegelianism.
In chapters 3 and 4, Shapiro turns to more explicitly political themes in Thus Spoke Zarathustra, Beyond Good and Evil, and On the Genealogy of Morality. What he finds in these three texts is a recurring critique of the state: Zarathustra proclaims the state “the new idol” and Beyond rejects the nationalistic state ideology that Nietzsche sees underlying “peoples and fatherlands.” Genealogy continues the critique, framing the state as the ultimate creditor which results from the logic of debt that Nietzsche traces from the earliest of human relations (“creditor and debtor”) through Christ's self-sacrifice (which removes the debt/guilt [Schuld] only for it to return as infinitely unrepayable) to the political economy of the modern state, to which our very concept of temporality has been mortgaged (“Time is Money”). These chapters cover a wide range of topics, including Schmitt and Agamben on sovereignty and the “state of exception,” Deleuze on nomads and nomadism, time as Kairos vs. Chronos, and Nietzsche's distinguishing the multitude (Menge) from the masses or herd. Throughout, Shapiro returns to Zarathustra's call to remain loyal to the earth as Nietzsche's alternative to what Shapiro suggests is Nietzsche's dismay at the already visible globalization to come.
Chapter 5 takes Zarathustra's animals’ announcement that “the world awaits [him] as a garden” to explore Nietzsche's many references to gardens throughout his oeuvre as forming the basis for a political aesthetic of the earth. Readers may be surprised by how often Nietzsche refers to gardens, both metaphorically and literally, and although much of this chapter somewhat disjointedly chronicles Nietzsche's various appeals to gardens and gardening, Shapiro shows clearly that Nietzsche was familiar with the treatment of gardens as an art form in early modern aesthetics and argues persuasively that Nietzsche makes use of this familiarity to put forward cultivating one's garden as a model both of what Foucault would come to call the care of the self and what contemporary environmentalism understands as stewardship of the earth.
The sixth and final chapter is likely to be the most controversial for Nietzsche scholars, as Shapiro offers a provocative reading of The Antichrist as a work in the tradition of political theology. Shapiro argues first that Nietzsche comes to reject “the idea of secularization as a political illusion” (169). This leads Nietzsche to the idea that “the path to a renewed vision of the human-earth could lie in deploying the conceptual resources and historical traditions of Christianity against” itself (175). This then leads Nietzsche to affirm the biblical figure of the Antichrist and “a philosophy of the Antichrist” (often articulated in terms of his pseudonym “Dionysus”). Christianity is a “religion of the book” and so must be vanquished by another book; The Antichrist is that other book, “Nietzsche's “atheological-political treatise, an anti-messianic response to world history and political theology” (179). To support this reading, Shapiro draws our attention to Nietzsche's friend and atheological professor of New Testament and early church history, Franz Overbeck, who Shapiro argues recommended and often supplied Nietzsche with current scholarship on the origins and history of Christianity, including his own controversial study Über die Christlichkeit unserer heutigen Theologie (1873; How Christian Is Our Present-Day Theology, 2005). Overbeck's works led Nietzsche to conclude that “there was only one Christian, and he died on the cross” (Antichrist §39), and they led him as well to the conclusion that the way to challenge the apostle Paul's creation of the Christ and invention of Christianity is through a parody of that creation by means of The Antichrist’s declaration of war against Christianity and Nietzsche's creation of a philosophy of the anti-Christ.
Not surprisingly, in a book written by as sensitive, nuanced, and creative a Nietzsche interpreter as Gary Shapiro, there is much to recommend in Nietzsche's Earth. Although a more attentive copyeditor should have removed some of the textual repetition, his readings of the Nietzschean texts are innovative and will challenge those readers comfortable with the standard interpretations as he draws attention to the future great events and great politics that Nietzsche expects will usher humanity into a human-earth. Shapiro makes a strong case for what will strike many initially as the surprising claim that Nietzsche “is one of the very few major philosophers to have taken on characteristic questions posed by modernity when it first became possible to do so, given the nineteenth-century zenith of the nation-state and the new speeds of industry, transportation, and communication” (ix–x). And he does successfully highlight ways in which Nietzsche's critical response to the Hegelian triumphalist end of history of the nineteenth century can apply as well to the neoconservative response to the fall of the Berlin Wall, end of the Cold War, and emergence of the global market. Whether Shapiro's argument retains its currency, however, is a question. But this may not be Shapiro's fault. Like Nietzsche's madman (Gay Science §125), Shapiro's book too may have come too early, as recent “great events”—Brexit and questions concerning the future of the European Union, the reemergence of nationalism and election of neofascist autocrats across the globe, the election of Donald Trump and the truly disastrous consequences this may have for the futurity of the earth—may be leading to a future that no one could have anticipated.
