Academic research into Muslim intellectual history owes a significant debt to Henri Corbin (d. 1978) and his circle of students, prominent among them Seyyed Hossein Nasr (b. 1933), who proved that the widely-held notion that creative Islamic philosophy had ultimately come to an end with Averroës (d. 595/1198), and been replaced by only reproductive scholasticism, was incorrect. Ever since their identification of hitherto uncharted philosophical developments at the Safavid court of Isfahan, academic researchers have aimed to map all intellectual changes between the twelfth and seventeenth centuries ce. Given the comparative youth of this subject, it is reasonable that much groundwork remains to be to be done before scholars can engage in a deeper analysis of the philosophical and theological contents which dominated the debate during those five centuries. Although not necessarily extraordinarily exciting reading, inventories of individual thinkers who have significantly contributed to what the late John (Yahya) Cooper has called “processes of amalgamation of various intellectual currents” are indispensable. So, studies like those on Ibn al-Muṭahar “ʿal-ʿAllāma” al-Ḥillī (d. 726/1325) and Ibn Abī Jumhūr al-Aḥsāʾī (d. around 906/1501) by Sabine Schmidtke, from 1991 and 2000 respectively, have helped a great deal to obtain a better understanding of the key-thinkers who contributed to the process but had, thus far, been rather marginalised in academic research. Comprehensive inventories of their works, along with meticulously compiled lists of available printed and manuscript copies, have proven to be of great assistance to anyone keen to delve deeper into these individuals’ thoughts.
It is in this context that we have to consider the book under review, which emanates from a very recent PhD dissertation at the Freie Universität Berlin under the supervision of Sabine Schmidtke. The author, currently a research assistant at the Institute of Islamic Studies at McGill University in Montreal, has shed some light on the period immediately between the above mentioned al-Aḥsāʾī and the later philosophers in Safavid Iran, commonly subsumed under the rather problematic label “School of Isfahan”. Pourjavady positions the Shiraz-based philosopher Najm al-Dīn Maḥmūd al-Nayrīzī as having died, most probably not of natural causes, after 943/1536, and it is especially in his introduction (pp. 1-44) that he provides a valuable map of the philosophical landscape of Shiraz at the turn of the Safavid era. This is vital, not least, for a better understanding of al-Nayrīzī's philosophical stance, as displayed in Chapters Two (pp. 74–105) and Four (pp. 137–152). Chapters One and Three appear—at least at first sight—to be more conventional and even technical: while Chapter One (pp. 45–73) sheds light on the biography of the al-Nayrīzī, Chapter Three (pp. 106–136) provides a discussion of his works, which is complemented by a comprehensive inventory of his works in Appendix One (pp. 153–192) and of works copied by him in Appendix Two (pp. 193–195). The remaining two appendices (pp. 196–202) contain the transcript of a teaching permission (ijāza) by the renowned Shirazi philosopher Ghiyāth al-Dīn Dashtakī (d. 949/1542) from a Tehran manuscript, and transcripts of fourteen passages from unpublished Arabic sources that have been quoted throughout the entire book.
Given the so far relative neglect of al-Nayrīzī in academic reasearch and, coming to that, even of his named more renowned contemporaries, the author had to work entirely from unpublished manuscript sources, kept in collections scattered across the globe. This, of course, is praiseworthy as well as a serious challenge, especially given the usually rather tight timeframe for a PhD. It may therefore be excusable that the author did not, as he readily acknowledged in his Preface (p. x), consult those manuscripts held in the Iraqi and Indian collections. However as the latter, as opposed to those in Iraq, are currently easily accessible, the next step should certainly be to match the Iranian and Turkish MSS with the Indian copies. However, because of the highly commendable scrutiny of these original materials, Chapters Two and Four appear to be the most relevant chapters, as well as, of course, the inventory of texts that constitutes a useful tool for further research on al-Nayrīzī and the philosophical traditions around him.
This unfolding of the philosophical landscape in southern Iran at the turn to the sixteenth century ce, of which al-Nayrīzī had only been one—albeit important—part, is precisely what makes Pourjavady's study so valuable and indispensable for any further research on the matter. Thus, in Chapter Three he follows current Iranian scholars in their challenge of Corbin's widely perpetuated notion of a “School of Shiraz”, by pointing to the existence of (at least) two rivalling circles of philosophers, one around Jalāl al-Dīn al-Dawānī (d. 908/1502) and the other, to which al-Nayrīzī also belonged, around Ṣadr al-Dīn Dashtakī (killed 903/1498). Pourjavady's meticulous outline of the five logical and metaphysical core issues of dispute between these two circles, results in the reader being able to identify future directions for research. For example, one may pursue the ways in which textual as well as personal authority is established in learned Muslim circles of early modernity. Herein, the role and importance of commentaries, which is often used as a core argument in support of the thesis of the decline of Muslim philosophy after Averroës, will certainly have to play a major role. Also the highly complex sociological problem of what constitutes a ‘tradition’ and/or a ‘school of thought’ may also be worth addressing by future research. Since the study under review clearly belongs to the foundational stage of compiling inventories, these questions are well beyond its scope and have therefore not been addressed by the author. Instead, great care has been taken to position al-Nayrīzī's philosophical thought, besides his contribution to the Dawānī-Dashtakī-dispute, as a thinker very much engaged in reconciling the strong peripatetic tradition of “Avicennism” with the popular and mystically charged illuminationist philosophy of Shihāb al-Dīn al-Suhrawardī (executed 587/1191). This he does by substantially challenging Suhrawardi's, and his epigones’, critique of elements of Ibn Sīnā's (d. 428/1037) systematic thought.
Overall, this work can, as has been stressed repeatedly, be regarded as a substantial contribution to the necessary groundwork still to be done on the too long neglected intellectual developments especially in the Persianate world. It provides a useful, although rather cursory, overview of the philosophical state-of-affairs around the advent of the Safavids in Persia, as well as a highly beneficial inventory of the writings of one of its major proponents. As such, the book may be regarded rather as a handbook than a work of deep and stimulating analyses. To consider Pourjavady's work in this way would also explain, although not justify, why the author has abstained from writing a conclusion in which he brings together all his thoughts in a systematic manner. A conclusion which points out directions that future research may take would nonetheless have been highly commendable and its lack is therefore considered a serious flaw in an otherwise solid work.
