Kimbra Smith's Practically Invisible is an engaging and meticulous study reflecting on issues of indigeneity, racism, globalisation, tourism, fluidity and decolonisation, in a region often overlooked by Andean anthropologists: the coast. Although coastal communities and their territories have been experiencing radical transformations since pre-colonial times, academic literature about this complex region is still insufficient. However, the rapid expansion of global tourism and capitalism seen throughout the Pacific coast of Latin America in the last few decades is changing this trend, opening up new fields of study amongst Andeanists. Amongst them, anthropologists are unravelling the – commonly ignored – socio-cultural changes these populations are going through, now that they are – more than ever – actively engaged in the global economy. Practically Invisible contributes substantially to this academic debate, bringing an insightful anthropological account that explores the tensions and transformations faced by coastal indigenous groups, and the strategies they employ to challenge national narratives of indigeneity and globalising forces affecting their everyday life.
Based on the Agua Blanca case, a ‘non-recognised’ indigenous community located within the Machalilla National Park in the Manabí province of Ecuador, Smith starts by underscoring the power structures that maintain coastal indigenous communities marginalised from and totally neglected in dominant narratives of the nation. Her detailed analysis reveals that this region is predominantly represented as a territory of mestizos and Afro-Ecuadorian communities but not of indigenous groups. Smith accurately argues that these populations remain invisible not only because of their lack of universal markers of identity but also because identity politics in Ecuador are deeply dominated by colonial discourses of racialised geography and racialised labour. That is, discourses that support the unquestioned belief asserting that specific groups belong to particular places within the national landscape, and that they undertake specific and fixed types of labour.
According to the author, discourses of racialised geography, constructed through national narratives of the nation, the education system, censuses, political websites amongst others, have strongly contributed to socially represent this region as a recently populated territory. They have been also used to legitimise dominant representations of coastal groups as poor, rural, uneducated, lazy and backward. This has allowed the emergence and imposition of fixed ethnic categories, such as montubios – which connotes racial mixing and imperfect mestizaje. As a result, these powerful discourses have naturalised a hierarchised social structure, and have limited the options of coastal communities to self-identify as indigenous, situating them in an ambiguous ethnic condition. This makes Smith's contribution to identity politics in Ecuador relevant for many Latin American countries within the Pacific coast, a region where indigenous groups are invisible due to racialised strategies of domination.
Then, the author moves on to examining both recently invented and ‘traditional’ local cultural practices. By analysing the ‘Festival de la Balsa Manteña’, a local festivity invented in 1992 that is performed for outsiders, Smith describes how members of this community have managed to construct agentive cultural productions in which particular identities have been put into practice and embodied. She shows how through this performance Agua Blancans engage with broader discourses of authenticity and indigeneity, and manage to destabilise received categories of ethnicity and discourses of racialised geography. For the author, apart from allowing them to meet specific needs, with this invented tradition coastal indigenous communities are attempting to transform the ways in which being indigenous is possible in Ecuador.
This section of the book is complemented with a thorough analysis of how Agua Blancans – like other indigenous communities – construct their sense of belonging and reproduce strong internal connections by performing their everyday activities and traditional practices, such as washing clothes, undertaking mingas, participating in local celebrations and public encounters, amongst others. The underlying argument of this section is that it is through the performance of these practices – invented or traditional – that members of this community, and the outsiders interacting with them, gradually shift their perceptions of reality. Consequently, if this allows Agua Blancans to gain fluidity over their identity, enabling them to have more control over their agency and self-determination, with these performances they end up challenging racialised and fixed representations imposed by the dominant elites. In doing so, they have managed to deal with the threats brought about by tourism and development, while protecting their communal territories and local livelihoods.
In this engaging book, in addition to uncovering how coastal indigenous groups negotiate their visibility, appropriate the landscape and reproduce their own way of life, Smith explores the complex changes and transformations that Agua Blancans have recently experienced. In the final section, the author invests great effort on illustrating how the Pacific coast is a lived and occupied territory, where indigenous groups have specific attitudes and reactions towards globalising processes brought about by modernising initiatives and tourism projects. Here, Smith takes into account a broad variety of aspects affecting Agua Blancans in the present day, from the introduction of electricity and new building materials, to the adoption of scientific discourses and practices, and the local strategies used to deal with contexts fostering social hierarches, amongst others. She also analyses local situations provoking fear amongst community members, and concludes that fear could undermine the community's control over group practices and self-determination.
Throughout this methodologically rich ethnography, the author develops the concept of interpracticality. By defining it as ‘the process of engaged practice through which we produce fields and habiti’ (p. 4), Smith argues that, within the context of globalisation and tourism, interpracticality has become the most effective tactic used by coastal indigenous groups to practise their own methodology of decolonisation. This allows them to challenge hegemonic discourses and limiting structures while creating fields where they can inscribe new meanings and engage with broader audiences. Overall, Practically Invisible is an original and valuable ethnographic account that explores the various resources used by coastal indigenous groups to strategically construct their Indianess, deploy their local agency and maintain their everyday practices within the local landscape.
