Just as Muslims use the shariʿa to authoritatively assert their identity, Westerners use Islamic law to argue for the religion's backwardness and the necessity for Muslims to assimilate Western legal codes. Sami Zubaida does neither.
In his book, Law and Power in the Islamic World, Zubaida pictures the very term shariʿa as a misnomer. Opposing the conservative conviction that the “gate of ijtihād is closed,” he argues that Islamic law is not monolithic and that it never stopped evolving. Instead, Zubaida proposes that contemporary Islamic law evolved through the intellectual discourse of consecutive “pious” scholars, then through “controlling” political institutions.
His book thus addresses Islamic past and present through legal transformation. Yet, Zubaida goes against popular belief in suggesting that historically Islamic law has always been compromised by the state and that it remains merely theoretical in aspects of public law. Tension between religionists and secularists are not a novel occurrence in the Muslim world, but Zubaida goes so far as to argue that the struggle between “pious individuals” and “the corrupt state” has been the most visible characteristic of Islamic legal history. What is more, he proposes that the relationship between law and power (jurists and rulers) determines the never-ending human effort to anticipate God's will. For example, under the patronage of the early Abbasid court, the Muʿtazila, the caliphs publicized a prominent philosophical theological school of thought to challenge the “literalist” scholars who insisted on restricting legal judgments to the confinements of the “text.” State has won over religion, Zubaida argues, despite the unyielding resistance of the ulama, who sometimes suffered for their resistance. However, after the famous inquisition (miḥna) of Ibn Hanbal, and the flogging of Abu Hanifa (who refused a judgeship offered by the caliph), the ulama earned some independence and autonomy.
The book's second part addresses Ottoman reform and what Zubaida calls the “etatisation” of Islamic law, paying close attention to its consequences on modern Egypt and Iran. Much of the contemporary Islamic resistance to law reform, Zubaida argues, is a reactionary response to this Ottoman development (and to later secularists like Gamal Abdel Nasser in Egypt and Reza Shah in Iran). Orthodox institutions like al-Azhar in Egypt outrage reformists because they have replaced the ulama and preserved only limited autonomy from the state. The comparison between the Egyptian and Iranian examples is particularly astute because of its elaboration on Sunni and Shiʿite resistance. Zubaida draws parallels between Egypt and Turkey but suggests that Egypt will most likely follow the tracks of Iran.
Law and Power in the Islamic World ultimately argues that the “return to shariʿa” is a simplistic and uninformed presumption that Islamic law has been maintained throughout Islamic history. Although his argument is convincing, Zubaida lacks any coherent discussion on the status of women within Islamic law. Muslim women have been the most affected by legal changes, which this kind of book can scarcely afford to ignore. We have to address gender dynamics to understand societal power structures. Zubaida writes too little about the Ottoman reforms of family law, failing to connect them to the overall argument on Islamic law and power. Zubaida merely uses the contemporary discontent of Egyptian Muslim women to communicate optimism that secularism will take over an apparent Islamic resurgence.
Although it is not always easy, Zubaida successfully links medieval, early-modern, and modern Islamic polities throughout the work. Likewise, he never fails to thoroughly consider the prominent religious figures and theoreticians of legal theory. Best of all, his exploration of the impact of Shiʿite and Sufi sects on the development of Islamic law is exceptional. Yet, triumphs like these are eclipsed by Zubaida's fragmented narrative. The book lacks a straightforward chronological account of Islamic law's development.
The book can be recommended for both a lower division survey class of the Middle East, and even a specialized graduate class of Islamic law. (It should be noted that most of the book's sources are secondary, which is understandable considering that it is such a widespread survey.) Although particular accounts of early and medieval Islamic histories are both accessible to nonspecialists and relevant to experts, Zubaida leaves his most important question unanswered: how and why Islamic law should be shaped in the future.
