José María Serna de la Garza has written an excellent book describing Mexican constitutional organisation. It forms part of a series that seeks to provide scholars and students with accessible introductions to the constitutional systems of the world. The Constitution of Mexico fits very well with the main purposes of this collection. On the one hand, it offers a detailed account of the working of the Mexican constitutional system, covering issues such as the three branches of power, the electoral system, federal organisation and the protection of human rights. On the other hand, it puts those institutions in context, so as to facilitate the reader's understanding of the entire legal system (why each part of the institutional organisation was adopted, when and for what reasons they were reformed, and so on). In addition, and following the series’ requirements, each chapter ends with a helpful conclusion and a list of further, recommended reading.
The author's academic endeavour was obviously challenging, given the complexities of Mexican legal and political history, and the quantity and importance of the country's recent institutional reforms. In fact, very few countries can equal Mexico's record in this regard, with numerous recent legal changes that fostered radical innovations in the nation's political life. These innovations, which I shall summarise in the following paragraphs, seem impressive, particularly if one takes into account the fact that one single party, the Partido Revolucionario Institucional (Institutional Revolutionary Party, PRI), exercised harsh control over Mexico's public life during much of the entire twentieth century.
Among the many institutional developments that are examined in the book, perhaps the most significant are those related to the electoral system. This was subjected to a number of reforms after the scandalous presidential election of 1988. On that occasion the PRI candidate won, but the result, which relegated Cuauhtémoc Cárdenas, a popular leader and former member of the PRI, to second place, was highly contested and resisted by large sections of the population. This political crisis first provoked the creation of the Federal Electoral Institute in 1990, and then the establishment of the Federal Electoral Tribunal. Both institutions played a crucial role in the opening of the traditionally hermetic Mexican political system. Subsequently, these initial changes favoured the adoption of new institutional reforms. The Supreme Court, for instance, was significantly restructured: the number of justices was reduced from 26 to 11, the justices were relieved of most of their administrative functions, and the court was strengthened as a constitutional tribunal. The author partly explains these decisions by the fact that many within the PRI's elite wanted to put a more independent supreme court in place in the face of an expected loss of power. Similarly, according to the author, the breakdown of the hegemonic party system also provoked the adoption of structural changes in the organisation of congress and the federal system.
Of course, the impulses for change were not only endogenous to the national political organisation: external forces also worked towards the introduction of institutional novelties. For instance, Mexico's adhesion to a significant economic pact with the United States and Canada (NAFTA) seems to be correlated with the country's renovation of its judicial system: more independent courts appeared to be indispensable for the new economic order. Similarly, it is usually assumed that Mexico's creation of the National Commission on Human Rights and its acceptance of the jurisdiction of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, two decisions that would have a powerful influence on the functioning of the entire legal structure, are also closely related to pressures coming from abroad.
Serna de la Garza rightly summarises the actual implications of these substantive institutional innovations. They include the passage from a hegemonic party system to a multiparty system; the change from non-competitive elections to more fairly contested ones; the creation of a more balanced organisation of power; a more plural congress; a reinvigorated judicial system; a stronger federal system; and an increased influence for international courts and the emergence of a new paradigm on the protection of human rights.
This impressive list of reforms and outcomes suggests that, once again, Mexico had learned the lessons of its own past institutional failures. At the beginning of the twentieth century, it responded to more than 30 years of autocratic rule by Porfirio Díaz with institutional reforms, including the banning of presidential re-election. Likewise, at the end of the twentieth century, Mexico reacted to more than 70 years of priismo with another, even more ambitious package of legal reforms.
Undoubtedly, as the author recognises, these achievements should not be overstated. The Mexican institutional system still shows serious deficiencies, and the country still faces terrible social and political problems, which it has not managed to eradicate after so many decades (particularly problems related to the ‘war on drugs’). At the same time, the existence of grave, unresolved difficulties should not negate the importance of what was done: the Mexican case actually confirms that legal changes matter, and matter substantially, even (or particularly) in the context of unjust and unequal societies.
José María Serna de la Garza's important book appears less compelling in certain analytical aspects. For instance, the author's insistence on the existing ‘gap’ between the ‘formal’ and the ‘living’ constitution is not particularly helpful for us to evaluate what has been achieved or imagine what could or should be done in order to improve the legitimacy of the country's legal organisation. However, the main purpose of the book is descriptive, rather than analytical, and in this respect Serna de la Garza does a great job. Very few books have been able to present such a detailed and contextual, brief and at the same time rich analysis of the Mexican constitutional system, particularly in English and from a legal perspective. For this important achievement, we cannot but give an enthusiastic welcome to this book.
