The history of the Arsacid Empire has long been put in second place, marginalised in the shadows of Teispid and Achaemenid Persia on the one hand and the Sasanian Empire on the other. The Arsacids tended to be underrated regarding their role and place in the history of the Ancient Near East. Scholars have often followed Pliny in his negative depiction of the Arsacid Empire as an unstable cluster of regna (HN 6.112) and characterised Arsacid rule as weak and always on the edge of collapse, a mere intermezzo in Eastern history. During the last decades, however, this attitude has changed: Arsacid rule has been reassessed and rehabilitated as an important stage of Eastern history. Research on Parthia has become crucial to the understanding of the political development in the Ancient Near East, not only in relation with Roman policy but also in its own right. As a result, there has been an increase in studies on the history of Arsacid Parthia during the last years: on its society, culture, economy, administration, political structures and networks, numismatic and archaeological sources, the self-presentation of the kings and the perception of the Parthians in Greek and Roman sources.
This trend is illustrated by two new books on the Arsacids. Jason M. Schlude offers a useful, short overview of Arsacid relations with the Romans from the first contacts with L. Cornelius Sulla in the 90s b.c. (when he was assigned the province of Cilicia) to the end of Arsacid rule under Artabanus IV in a.d. 224. S. distinguishes carefully between ‘image’ (in the sense of Roman perceptions) and ‘reality’ (in the sense of Realpolitik) and characterises the Roman-Parthian relations as defined by ‘cooperation and conflict’, not as a series of hostilities (14). The book is clearly structured, vividly written, agreeable to read and shows profound expertise. It addresses a wider audience and provides students and all those who want to be introduced into the subject with the relevant basic outlines. The book is provided with three useful maps and twenty-five monochrome images, mostly of numismatic evidence, and has careful endnotes after each chapter. It contains an introduction, eight chronological chapters and a final conclusion (including a glance forward to the rise of the Sasanians).
The earlier period of Roman-Parthian relations takes the lion's share. Four out of eight chapters treat Parthian-Roman relations during the late Roman Republic: from Sulla to Lucullus (ch. 1), Pompey (ch. 2), Crassus (ch. 3) and Marcus Antonius (ch. 4). While chs 5 and 6 cover the Julio-Claudian dynasty and ch. 7 is devoted to the Flavians (140–55), Trajan's Parthian campaign and all the — not unimportant — subsequent events down to the time of the Severans are treated in a single chapter (ch. 8). Thus, Hadrian's decision to abandon Trajan's conquests, the Parthian campaigns of Lucius Verus, Septimius Severus and Caracalla, as well as Macrinus’ problems in the East, all receive very brief treatment. A better balance would have devoted more space to the second and third centuries a.d. There are also several points of detail on which it would have been preferable to have at least a brief reference to the existence of controversies in scholarship, e.g. the date (96/5, 94/3 or 92 b.c.) and the results of Sulla's meeting with Mithradates II's envoy Orobazus (some scholars doubt that there was already a formal agreement on the Euphrates as the border between the Roman and the Arsacid sphere of influence, e.g. M. J. Olbrycht in J. M. Munk Højte (ed.), Mithridates VI Eupator and the Pontic Kingdom (2009), 163–9) or the historicity of Dio's and Herodian's claim that Caracalla used a false marriage offer as a pretext for his Parthian war in a.d. 216/7 (D. Timpe in Hermes 95 (1967), 470–95). There might also have been some discussion of the ongoing debate on the question of whether the Arsacids pursued a deliberate policy of imitation and evocation of the Teispid and Achaemenid heritage or this was a Roman fiction (cf. M. R. Shayegan, Arsacids and Sasanians (2011)). In sum, however, S. has written a recommendable, profound introduction to the political history of Roman-Parthian relations under the Arsacids with a focus on the period from the first century b.c. to the first century a.d.
Nikolaus Overtoom's book, ‘an interdisciplinary effort to reconstruct ancient international relations and geopolitics’ (16) in the Hellenistic Middle East, is a specialist study of the emergence and development of Arsacid rule and the Parthian struggles with the Seleucids down to the age of Arsacid expansion under king Mithradates II. Thus, it covers the span from the middle of the third century b.c. to the early first century a.d. and traces the Parthians’ path from political dependency to hegemony. A particular strength of the study is its sensitivity to the problem of the literary evidence. Thus, O. puts great stress on the problem of the bias of our Greek and Roman literary sources and devotes a lot of thought to the question of how to approach them critically. He includes an overview of Greek and Roman sources (xxvii–xxxi), discusses the issue of the literary evidence and provides short background information on the main sources in the introduction (1–26), and also critically discusses their accounts in the chapters. In order to overcome the problem of the sources and allow for a fresh perspective, O. employs Realist Theory from political science, a structural approach to study how system structures affect the relations of international political conduct (16–26). In other words, he examines political structures and networks rather than focusing on the actions of individual political actors — an approach that has become predominant in scholarship during the recent decades.
The study consists of six chronological chapters. After an exploration of how ‘exceptional’ the rise of the Parthians was (ch. 1), O. traces their trajectory with setbacks and successes from the emergence of the Parni and their political rise under Arsaces I and Arsaces II (chs 2–3) to the hegemonic struggle between Arsacids and Seleucids (chs 4–5) and Parthia's gain of unrivalled hegemony under Mithradates II (ch. 6). Regarding two major controversies in scholarship on the Arsacids, O. steers a balanced course. On the question of the authenticity of the Parthians’ nomadic origin, he argues that it was historical but tended to be exaggerated by Greek and Roman authors (30–1). As for the question of systematic Arsacid use of the Teispid and Achaemenid legacy, he suggests that they made occasional use of it and embraced much of Persian culture anyway (32; cf. A. Luther in K. Ehling and G. Weber (eds), Hellenistische Königreiche (2014), 154–9). The book also contains seven maps, a very useful timeline (xxi–xxv), a genealogy of the early Arsacids (xxxiii) and thirty images of well-chosen Arsacid coins.
It might have been desirable to have a short summary at the end of each chapter and a final conclusion at the end of the book. It is also questionable if one still has to take at face value the biased and stereotypical ancient tradition that the Seleucid king Antiochus II may have been poisoned by his wife Laodike (75). In sum, however, this is a highly reflective, very profound, thorough and critical study that offers a lot of important perspectives and thoughts that will enrich scholarship on Arsacid Parthia. It is a most relevant contribution to Arsacid research and recommended to all who are working on Parthia or are interested in its early history.
