The Makers of the Muslim World series “is devoted to the men and women throughout history who have made a significant contribution to the political, intellectual and religious landscape of the Muslim world.” The subject of Maribel Fierro's study is arguably the most important ruler in the history of al-Andalus (Islamic Iberia): ʿAbd al-Rahman III (r. 912–61). The eighth Umayyad to come to the throne in al-Andalus after the ʿAbbasid revolution brought an end to the caliphate in Damascus, ʿAbd al-Rahman III revived his dynasty's claims to the command of the faithful and founded the second Umayyad caliphate in Cordoba. He redefined al-Andalus politically, ideologically, and culturally and (with his son and successor) dominates all narratives of the rise and fall of Islamic rule and the history of Islamic civilization in Iberia.
Fierro's biography of ʿAbd al-Rahman III provides a focus for a concise political history of al-Andalus accessible to lay readers. The historical record defines the man by his achievements, and Fierro deftly situates ʿAbd al-Rahman III's reign in the context of the history of the Iberian peninsula, beginning with the Muslim conquest from 711 through 714 and concluding with the end of his life (with frequent references to his successor and a short chapter dedicated to his legacy). The book is more compelling than a straightforward political narrative because Fierro, who has written extensively on religion and politics in Umayyad al-Andalus, takes the opportunity to explore Andalusī identity and suggest how ʿAbd al-Rahman III helped define it. She summarizes: “A common Andalusi identity emerged both through the writing of local history from an Umayyad point of view and through the religious scholars' defence of Islamic egalitarian values. The most important feature of that identity was that it linked al-Andalus with Medina (the town where Muhammad had acted as both prophet and statesman) through the adoption of the Maliki legal school” (p. 134).
Students and scholars of the Islamic world who are looking for a quick introduction to the history and historiography of al-Andalus will find this book useful. On a basic level, Fierro defines some of the terms in the field and demonstrates usage. The reader learns, for example, why “al-Andalus” is preferred over “Islamic Spain,” why “Mozarab” is misleading, and how “Muwallad” appears in contemporary texts and modern scholarship. Her account of the early history of al-Andalus and portrayal of ʿAbd al-Rahman III and his times presents a synthesis of her own research and of recent scholarship and alerts the reader to issues of current interest and subject to variant interpretation. The synthesis is helpful because it provides an avenue through an often tangled historical narrative, identifies key actors and events, and pulls together disjointed trends in scholarship. Among the issues of interest are how the processes of Arabization and Islamicization took place on the peninsula and whether and how they were related; the development of institutions; and the definition and significance of frontier politics to the north of al-Andalus and to the south, in North Africa.
Fierro is intimately familiar with the primary sources through her own research and suggests on several occasions how and where the sources may be ideologically shaped and factually suspect. She is also a master of the secondary literature and has been involved in making Spanish-language scholarship more accessible to English-language readers, and among other works draws on some of the essays that she and Julio Samso and Manuela Marin have compiled and reproduced in English in The Formation of al-Andalus (Parts I and II). Fiero also alludes to some of the historiographical debates in which she is actively involved. For example, in an article titled “Four Questions in Connection with Ibn Hafsun,” first published in Spanish in al-Qantara 16 (1995): 221–57, she challenges Manuel Acien Almansa's interpretation of the rebellion of ʿUmar ibn Hafsun; the basic points of departure are outlined in the book under discussion. Elsewhere she identifies the question of whether the Duero valley was a wasteland before Christian repopulation as “one of the most debated issues in Spanish historiography” (p. 69). In the interest of appealing to a general audience, the series apparently does not allow for notes; readers looking for a trail to pursue some of the topics and debates referred to in the narrative will have to make do with the brief appendix, “How Do We Know What We Know About ʿAbd al-Rahman III,” and a bibliography that provides some guidance.
Fierro opens her book with the observation that we have only limited access to the man who is the subject of the biography. Illustrating her point, she refers to a report that in the daily written record of his forty-nine-year reign, ʿAbd al-Rahman claimed only fourteen days of happiness but never identified them specifically. One may only speculate about which days. What might this information—only fourteen days—convey about ʿAbd al-Rahman III's personality? Or is this a tropical representation of the ruler burdened by the weight of his responsibilities? Fierro's book gives us the limited and not incontrovertible evidence we have of her subject's temperament (burning the face of a slave girl who spurned his kisses and naming his palatine city for a favorite). Most of her biography, of course, is really a history made vivid by the prism of her interpretation of how ʿAbd al-Rahman III was a “maker of the Muslim world.”
