In this new narrative of medical innovation and the law in twentieth century America, Kara W. Swanson recounts how the first human body products to be systematically harvested and used as therapeutics—blood, breast milk, and sperm—came to be understood as property and exchanged via an array of institutions called “banks.” Swanson argues that the choice of the banking metaphor to characterize the collection, storage, and transfer of body products—including, by midcentury, organs—has had troublesome consequences. It has “straitjacketed American thinking about body products and markets,” resulting in “lives lost and in injustice” (3, 4). With its overtone of bodily commodification, the banking metaphor aroused controversy from the start. Swanson details how the medical profession and policy makers contended with clashing values and interests. By the 1980s, the inflexible gift/commodity dichotomy (9) predominated in the law, and it remains stubbornly in place today. The National Organ Transplant Act of 1984 forbids the sale of organs and bone marrow, establishing a network for their procurement and distribution exclusively as gifts. Other sources of bodily property (blood, breast milk, and, most profitably, sperm) may be legally bought and sold, although most blood today comes from unpaid donors. Therefore, if you need breast milk, check Craigslist. If you need a kidney, take a number, or try your luck on the global black market. The entire system, according to Swanson, unfairly disadvantages the poor and people of color and serves private interests better than social needs. Her normative agenda in this book is to use the history of body banking to move American law beyond the gift/commodity dichotomy and to reconceive bodily property, in civic terms, as a well-regulated and equitably distributed communal resource.
The pivotal figure in the narrative is Dr. Bernard Fantus, director of therapeutics at Cook County Hospital during the Great Depression. It was Fantus who (in an era of catastrophic bank failures) coined the term blood bank. Swanson uses his story to show that from its inception, the banking metaphor never implied a wholly free market in body products. In fact, Fantus conceived of the blood bank as a collective solution to a social problem. The increasingly common practice of transfusion (made safer and easier by the use of syringes, for extracting and infusing blood, and sodium citrate, to reduce clotting) created a rising demand for blood. Physicians relied on a new figure: the oxymoronic “professional donor.” Their blood could be typed and screened (for syphilis) in advance, and the (usually male) donors were readily available, for a fee. Doctors and hospitals routinely passed on the cost to their patients. But large urban institutions such as Cook County Hospital served a patient population too poor to pay for blood.
Fantus devised a system in which blood recipients themselves would keep a hospital's blood bank solvent. In order to take blood out, patients (or family members) were asked to put blood in (either before or after their procedures). As Swanson explains, “His goal was to replace reliance on ‘professional donors’ … with a communal system of blood as a shared resource among patients” (7). Banked blood would be “a fungible commodity,” but one that remained “under complete medical control, available to serve the professional goal of healing the sick” (7). Borrowing a concept from property law theorist Gregory Alexander, Swanson says that Fantus conceived of banked blood as a form of “civic property,” (13) to be used purposefully for the public good.
Ironies abound in Swanson's narrative. During World War II, the entire nation (following England's Blood for Britain campaign) served as one big blood bank. The wartime United States blood program normalized uncompensated blood donation as a civic duty, but it also nationalized the Southern Jim Crow practice of segregating blood collected from whites and blacks. (Meanwhile, the companies that made freeze-dried plasma from donated whole blood turned a tidy profit.) After the war, the Red Cross envisioned a peacetime extension of the wartime program that would provide free blood as needed to the citizenry, but in a classic Cold War story, blood banks joined forces with the American Medical Association to oppose the Red Cross plan as a scheme of “socialized” medicine. Meanwhile, the growth of product liability law in America shaped the blood market. Patients sued doctors and hospitals for infusing them with defective blood (tainted with hepatitis). Taking a step away from the banking metaphor, the medical profession pushed government protection in the form of “blood shield laws” (121), which all but six states enacted by 1973. The laws treated blood as part of the medical services that a physician might provide to patients, rather than something that might possibly be construed as an “‘unreasonably dangerous’ ‘product’” (121). Postwar Americans also debated what to call the act of blood donation itself: was it properly a gift, or a sale? The American Association of Blood Banks ultimately advocated moving the blood supply to an unpaid donor system, which it has largely remained to this day. The gift/commodity dichotomy proved most troubling in the field of organ transplants, especially after Congress wrote that dichotomy into federal law in the National Organ Transplant Act of 1984.
Two final chapters narrate the revealingly divergent histories of the banks in breast milk and sperm since the late twentieth century. Community-based milk banks have relied for their supply on the maternal kindness of uncompensated mothers, whereas sperm banks, a central part of the big business of assisted reproduction, have had little trouble sidestepping the gift/commodity dichotomy, maintaining—and even proudly advertising the elite pedigree of—their professional semen donors.
Banking on the Body is an informative study of a fascinating subject, although one can always wish for more. The book's source base—chiefly medical journals, administrative reports, and journalism—affords little access to patients' experiences. Americans have had no monopoly on body banking, but the international dimension is absent here. As an American story, the book does not engage with the legacy of slavery or the protean concept of self-ownership: the idea of a property in one's person that, from Locke's Second Treatise to the Thirteenth Amendment and beyond, has been an essential and contested tenet of the liberal tradition. The relationship between blood, milk, and sperm banks (whose histories occupy virtually the entire book) and organ donation (whose inequities seem to concern Swanson most) needs fuller elucidation. And although Swanson's plea for reconceiving of body products as sources of civic property is suggestive, it is not self-evident how such a rethinking would eliminate the injustices of the present system.
