European politicians, media, intellectuals, and citizens today refer to multiculturalism as a problem and a solution—as the cause of social fragmentation and the effect of fragmented national identities. In a timely, wide-ranging, and well-researched response to this confusion, the authors of Challenging Multiculturalism: European Models of Diversity provocatively suggest that reports of multiculturalism’s demise are exaggerated. This is not to say that multiculturalism is uncontested or unchanging, however. Raymond Taras has edited a collection of European case studies on multiculturalism with the aim of answering two questions all scholars of European politics, race and ethnicity, Islamophobia, and migration should be asking: Why is multiculturalism so widely questioned across Europe, and why now?
The book is divided into five parts: an overview of the state of multiculturalism across Europe; three collections of case study chapters, grouped by the prevalence of multiculturalism; and a conclusion that revisits the question of why multiculturalism has become the sick man of Europe.
In Part I, “Theorizing Multiculturalism,” Pieter Bevelander and Raymond Taras write that “our book examines where multiculturalism went off the rails, where it did not, and where the rails have been adjusted” (p. 8). This metaphor of “adjustment” epitomizes the book’s approach to multiculturalism. Just as the contributors avoid using essentialist notions of culture in their analysis, multiculturalism itself is presented as a dynamic, fluid, and contested concept. Such an understanding of multiculturalism requires a very specific kind of analysis, one that can take into account the different meanings actors attribute to the term, the different contexts in which it is used, and the different audiences actors intend their discourse to reach. Throughout the book, contributors do precisely that. A prime example is Scholten’s chapter on Dutch multiculturalism, in which he “looks at multiculturalism in several…spheres, including political and media discourses (which are distinguishable from formal policy discourses), academic discourses and actual everyday policy practices in which formal policies are…translated to a ‘street-bureaucrat’ level” (p. 106). This nuanced approach invites the reader to view multiculturalism not only as a set of policy objectives (which themselves can be arranged along a continuum of more or less multicultural), but also as a terrain of political conflict on which multiple dramas about inclusion, diversity, and national relevance play out.
Tariq Modood and Nasar Meer provide an empirical overview of the situation of multiculturalism in Europe today. We must not, they advise, conflate the recent political interest in “‘old’ national identities” in Europe with a turn away from multiculturalism (p. 44). In fact, the recent recognition of local cultural particulars combats the universalist gloss of liberal neutrality that usually makes such particulars invisible, rendering “culture” an exotic thing only possessed by the other and to be begrudgingly tolerated by those who have advanced passed it. The challenge, Modood and Meer argue, is for European nations “to pluralize, not empty, [the] cultural content” of nationality (p. 44).
In the final chapter of Part I, Christian Fernández reviews the political theory literature on multiculturalism. Fernández describes and interrogates the liberal goal (or fantasy) of “separating” public and private life to achieve equality in the former while allowing freedom in the latter. Fernández notes how multiculturalists critique the duplicity of this notion of separateness: “Despite its purported neutrality, liberalism and liberal societies consistently favor some ways of life over others, namely the ones that reflect the liberal ideal of personal autonomy” (p. 56). This relates back to Modood and Meer’s comment about the invisibility of majority cultures.
In Part II, “Multiculturalism’s Pioneers and (Ex-)enthusiasts,” contributors seek to explain how multiculturalism became a dirty word in Britain, the Netherlands, Belgium, and Sweden. A common thread throughout is that multiculturalism has not entirely disappeared: Meer and Modood find the term “re-balancing” a more accurate depiction of the condition of British multiculturalism than “retreat” (p. 80). Peter Scholten argues that recent Dutch criticism of multiculturalism does not negate the continued presence of multiculturalist policy at the local level or in political and media discourse, where it perhaps outstripped what national-level policies ever were. Karin Borevi maintains that despite the rhetoric, policies in Sweden remain multiculturalist in the sense that they continue to strive to increase the openness of institutions and to acknowledge the culturally diverse nature of Swedish society; they also refrain (unlike Britain and the Netherlands) from imposing assimilationist requirements on immigrants (p. 155). Meanwhile, determining the appropriate shape of multiculturalist policy seems to be the least of Belgium’s woes: Marco Martiniello explains that Flanders, Wallonia, and Brussels command their own immigration and labor policies, frequently to the chagrin of one another.
Part III on “Multicultural societies without Multiculturalism” covers Germany (Martina Wasmer), Denmark (Nils Holtug), Italy (Tiziana Caponio), and France (Florent Villard and Pascal-Yan Sayegh). These authors successfully unpack the various meanings of the concept of multiculturalism while also breaking down its articulations by the types of speakers and their intended audience. As a result, we discover that, despite their common political rhetoric condemning multiculturalism, these countries all have various policies that seek to promote equal rights and opportunities, increase access to and improve the delivery of welfare and social services to certain marginalized groups, and combat discrimination.
Part IV, “Multiculturalism’s Future Converts?”, looks at Poland (Renata Włoch), Russia (Sergey Akopov), and Turkey (Ayhan Kaya). We learn that multiculturalism is not on the radar in Poland and Russia and that its presence in Turkish political discourse has declined with the rise of euroscepticism.
Ulf Hedetoft’s conclusion argues that multiculturalism is “a fall guy for the ongoing decline of statist control, and the cultural backlash against it” (p. 331). Hedetoft suggests that European nations, today confronted with new problems, are clinging to that which is familiar: a tired nation-state model and “old-school sovereignty.” Hedetoft suggests that Europe must forge new solutions, but admits that “[s]uch a highly complex toolbox still has to be constructed and deployed intelligently” (p. 332). Readers will undoubtedly wonder what should go in this toolbox and who should be putting it there. This calls to mind another notable pattern throughout the book: the tendency for local policymakers to pragmatically consult cultural minorities and for national policymakers to consult researchers. The identification of new solutions may not happen without the expansion of political, media, and intellectual circles.
Apart from Part IV (which is by design), this book reads as a thematically harmonious set of case studies. This is due to the patterns that emerge across the case studies and that raise a series of questions: Would multiculturalism be taking this beating were it not for anxiety about Muslims and securitization across Europe? Or the increased tendency to, as Jonathan Simon would say, govern through crime? Or the trend towards re-nationalization? The absence of a longer conversation on these patterns is somewhat regrettable. We are also left to wonder just how important the undigested legacy of European colonialism is for understanding these conversations about national identity. Rather than a limitation, these unanswered questions can be viewed as a gift, providing an ideal jumping off point for new projects on the politics of difference in Europe.
