Gül Aldıkaçtı Marshall's Shaping Gender Policy in Turkey explores recent gender policy changes in Turkey, situating them in the context of the country's European Union (EU) membership process. The EU promotes so-called gender equality directives for both member and candidate countries, the adoption of which tends to result in shifts in gender-related policies. Thus, Turkey's attainment of official candidate status for EU membership in 1999 was followed by a series of amendments to its gender-related policies in the early 2000s.
The primary aim of the book is to highlight the role of feminist activism in these policy shifts. Moving from the observation that this role is underexamined in scholarly analysis of Turkey's EU membership process, the book seeks to “render feminist efforts in policy making and policy change visible and locate them in the multifaceted picture of the agents” (p. 4). As the author makes apparent in the book's subtitle, these agents include the EU and the Turkish state. While shedding light on the significant roles played by these two governing bodies, the book tries to foreground women's grassroots organizations as the central units of analysis.
Other analyses of feminist activism in Turkey have already observed that the women's movement utilized Turkey's candidacy for EU membership in 1999 as a unique historical opportunity to press for reforms that enhance gender equality. Similar to these analyses, Aldıkaçtı Marshall argues that women's grassroots organizations have increasingly relied on transnational activism to put pressure on the Turkish state to transform its gender legislation. According to the author, “these efforts of feminist activists should be conceptualized as sustained-pressure, a strategy that proved to be staggeringly beneficial when feminists asserted themselves as pivotal actors in reshaping gender policies in the 2000s” (p. 3).
The author engages the “multilevel governance” and “multitiered system” approaches—both of which she explains in the introduction—to analyze the role of multiple actors in the making of gender policy. However, she also points to the shortcomings of these approaches for understanding both the important role of women's organizations in policy making and the policy process in candidate countries, over which she claims the EU has more power than it has over member countries. The book also engages and is situated within theoretical debates on Europeanization and gender equality.
The first part of Aldıkaçtı Marshall's book is devoted to laying out the relevant historical background. The author discusses the historical development of both the EU's gender equality policies (Chapter 2) and the Turkish state's gender regime (Chapter 3). Further, she situates feminist activism associated with Turkey's EU membership process in historical perspective by analyzing its link to the longitudinal struggle of the women's movement, which since the 1980s has been attempting to eliminate the state's gender-discriminatory policies (Chapter 4). Chapter 5 shifts the analysis to the contemporary context of Turkey's EU membership process in the aftermath of the 1999 Helsinki Summit, tracing the influence of the EU and the Turkish state in gender policy transformation.
In Chapter 6, the most interesting of the book, the author offers an easy-to-read, well-organized, informative, and lively account of feminist activism in the early 2000s, when grassroots activists used the EU membership process as an opportunity to pressure the Turkish state to make gender policy reforms. The chapter is based on analysis of written sources from women's organizations as well as interviews with their members, among whom many are feminists, several are Kemalists, and one is Islamist. The chapter documents the advocacy and lobbying efforts of these women's organizations, showing how grassroots activists built coalitions in Turkey as well as with transnational bodies to pressure the Turkish state. The chapter gives an account of the various strategies used by feminist activists, including public campaigning and face-to-face interaction with MPs, to push for desired changes at the moment when amendments to the Civil Code, Penal Code, Labor Law, and constitution were underway.
Although the book's stated focus is women's grassroots organizations, only one chapter deals directly with feminist activism, with much of the remainder of the book devoted to laying out the theoretical framework, the relevant historical and contemporary contexts, and the roles of the EU and the Turkish state. One wishes that the author had devoted more space to her analysis of the advocacy and lobbying efforts of women's organizations, which constitutes the most interesting and original part of the book. One also wonders whether the author could have enriched the analysis by attempting to trace the daily process of policymaking and lobbying, including the practices of feminist activists and their contestations with politicians and bureaucrats. Of course, this would have required the incorporation of other methodologies (participant observation and fieldwork) as well as research carried out in the early 2000s when policy amendments were actually underway.
Aldıkaçtı Marshall's analysis is nevertheless invaluable in that it highlights the significance of feminist activism to gender policy transformation. The book demonstrates that policymaking and policy transfer are not merely technical processes but also political ones, entailing both top-down pressure from the EU to nation-states as well as bottom-up processes shaped through the advocacy of grassroots organizations. Although the author rightly emphasizes the successful outcomes of activists’ strategies, pointing to the impressive progress achieved in gender policy, some limitations of this policy transformation might have been taken up in the conclusion. One such limitation pertains to the worrisome gap, as pointed out by some feminist analyses of women's rights in Turkey, between rights recently enshrined in legal texts and prevailing gender inequalities on the ground.
The conclusion touches upon a very important quandary: the very AKP government that has transposed EU gender equality directives into Turkey has also taken steps, as part of its conservative politics, to undermine gender equality and women's rights in the country. In fact, there seems to have been a spike in such attempts since the book's preparation,. The recent (and ongoing) public debate over abortion is one of many issues that have caused some women's groups to feel that previously secured women's rights in the country are in jeopardy of being pushed back. Furthermore, with the current Turkish government seemingly less committed to demonstrating an adherence to EU values and with Turkey's diminishing prospects for EU membership in light of recent political developments, it might even be apt to critically reassess one of the book's major theses: that “the EU has more power over candidate countries than member states” (p. 6). Of course, this may point less to a weakness of the book than to the conundrums of developing social scientific analysis on contemporary phenomena in a radically and rapidly changing, politically volatile world, most strongly reflected in the case of Turkey over the last few years.
All in all, Shaping Gender Policy in Turkey makes an important scholarly contribution that stands at the intersection of numerous fields. The book will be of interest to scholars interested in gender studies, Europeanization, and Turkey.
