World politics, so the overall argument of Wilfried Röhrich's book goes, can only be understood if the power of religion is acknowledged. Röhrich, a professor emeritus of political science, thus divides his book into seven chapters: one each on Judaism, Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Confucianism, and, in the end, the “chances and risks of inter-religious dialogue.” Each chapter systematically summarizes the main content of a world religion, and then “its power” is demonstrated in “exemplary country studies” (p. 9). In all cases, with the exception of Confucianism, the first subchapter is devoted to “the religion and its fundamentalism,” followed by country studies. This review will mainly concentrate on the Middle Eastern aspects of the book.
In the first chapter, Judaism and Jewish fundamentalism are followed by “Israel and the Palestinian–Israeli conflict,” and a third subchapter is devoted to “Jerusalem: Judaism and Islam.” The ten pages on Israel and the Palestinian–Israeli conflict are, by necessity, a broad overview. Not a necessity, however, is the way Röhrich singles out a very small group of scholars (Michael Wolffsohn and Bassam Tibi) as his main references, who therefore monopolize his whole account of the Middle East and Islam. The Palestinian–Israeli conflict is narrated from an Israeli standpoint.
The issue of the “holy city of Jerusalem” emerges as the sole core of the conflict, thus taking the conflict back approximately 3,000 years. This “historical heritage” makes clear the potential for conflict between Judaism and Islam, which, in turn, “makes the peace process in the Middle East into a problem” (p. 47). It could have been expected that a political scientist at least mention this is also a specific and rather recent political conflict about territory and statehood, but Röhrich prefers to make it a purely religious one in line with his overall argument.
The chapter on Islam covers Islamism; Egypt, Morocco, and Saudi Arabia as country studies; the “Persian–Shiite example of the re-politicization of the sacred”; and the “Turkish politicization of Islam and Kemalism.” From the outset, it has to be noted that the main arguments in this chapter are drawn from Bassam Tibi, who is referenced in thirty of the total fifty-two footnotes. Röhrich discusses different meanings of jihad and comes to the conclusion that Islamism is both a political ideology and a social protest movement, turning as such in its inner realm against nonfundamentalist elites and in its outer aspect against the whole Western world. He sees Islamic fundamentalism as a “defensive culture and not only as a violent form of totalitarianism” (p. 108).
In the Arab country profiles, Röhrich analyzes the nation-state as an alien and imposed Western entity, “transferred unto Islamic civilization in the colonizing process,” although these “nominal nation states lack everything that the European institutions excel in. So, among other things, they are not democratic units based on a civil society whose citizens form a nationally homogenous population” (p. 110). Citing Robert Kaplan, Röhrich concludes, “The real boundaries are … those between cultures and tribes …” (p. 110). It is not even hinted that these are highly contested notions in the scholarly discussion of the Arab world. Röhrich then analyzes the Khomeini era with the use of Max Weber's category of charismatic leadership; he concludes with the post-Khomeini state which, in line with the model of theocracy, features the Islamic leader as the dominant factor in contemporary Iran. In Turkey, Röhrich sees a “De-Westernization” at work, in which the secular state is being pushed back and in which a deeply divided society prevails.
His chapter on Christianity is the longest and perhaps the best part of the book. This is somewhat surprising, because Christianity undoubtedly features a great number of splits and tensions and yet does not involve a major world conflict unless one wishes to view the politics of the Bush administration toward the Middle East in this light, which Röhrich does in his introduction and conclusion. The chapter on Christianity draws on Nietzsche's argument of the Hellenization of Christianity starting with Paul and then proceeds to give a concise overview of Christian history. One entire subchapter is devoted to the Gospels and one to Christian fundamentalism, including a critical account of the Vatican. American Christianity and the plurality of its sects are also given broad range.
The chapter on Hinduism includes Hindu fundamentalism, India, Hinduism in practice, conflicts between Hinduism and Islam, and the conflict over Kashmir. The chapter on Buddhism begins with an overview of Gautama Buddha and his Four Noble Truths, touching upon the differences between Theravada and Mahayana Buddhism and fundamentalism. The country studies given for Theravada Buddhism in South and Southeast Asia are Sri Lanka, Burma, Cambodia, and Laos. Mahayana Buddhism is historically explained through the Soga and Heia eras and the Taisho era up until contemporary Japan. The chapter includes such new religious movements as Shinnyo-En (Borderless Garden of Truth), the God Light Association, and Kofuku-no-Kagaku, a combination of Buddhism and Christianity. The chapter on Confucianism starts with the ethical–political teachings and then looks at Confucianism and the modernization of China from the Ming dynasty to Communist Party rule, including contemporary secret societies.
The large scope of the book necessitates radical summaries of complex phenomena. This is also true for Röhrich's conclusions. The concluding chapter explores the “chances and limits of inter-religious dialogue” and ends with a word of warning to the West about forcing its political models onto the reluctant regions of other world religions (p. 220 ff.).
Despite its wealth of information, Röhrich's book is not a handbook and is too condensed for use in the classroom. However, it can serve well as an introduction for the more general reader.
