Emancipation brought its own diaspora, one that resettled thousands of newly-freed slaves in northern states. In this beautifully researched book, Leslie A. Schwalm argues that this wartime migration forced a rethinking of the racial and gendered hierarchies coded into law and society. Struggles for civil and social equality, as well as contests over the memory and meaning of the Civil War, impacted and changed the region's communities, white and black.
The book begins by exposing the “hidden” history of slavery and ascriptive racial hierarchies in the Midwest before the Civil War. Although historians have long labored to demonstrate that racially-restrictive laws saturated the “free” Midwest, the endurance of popular notions that slavery was unknown to the region still color our historical memory. Schwalm sees historical continuity between the introduction of slavery to the Midwest and the “black laws” that correlated citizenship with whiteness and blackness with servitude. In the face of this legal regime of racial subordination, blacks formed defensive communities. In Keokuk, Iowa, a community of 245 African-Americans founded an African Methodist Episcopal (AME) church and an African School that, despite limited resources, outperformed white schools in the city (39).
Schwalm's treatment of the diaspora of emancipated slaves is careful and methodical, although the evidence sometimes resists definitive conclusions. For instance, she meticulously traces the refugees’ origins, but fully thirty percent left no tracks at all. There were several different waves of migrations, beginning with wartime liberations and increase in fugitiveness, extending through the Second Confiscation Act, and Emancipation Proclamation, and finally to the postwar migration.
Despite some assistance, refugees from slavery generally did not encounter a friendly population in the Midwest. The influx of blacks coupled with the constitutional amendments ending slavery and guaranteeing birthright citizenship forced a new dialogue about precisely what constituted membership in the community. Blacks participated in this by building up their own institutions. The AME churches generally anchored communities, but so too did other private associations, such as the Prince Hall Masons and their partner, female, organization, the Order of the Eastern Star. Blacks also repeatedly pressed white Masonic lodges to integrate their membership or grant recognition to affiliated lodges. By 1877, white lodges had pulled down the official barrier to black membership in their own lodges, but had also refused recognition to their all-black counterparts. They nonetheless remained segregated for another century thanks to their ability to self-select their membership.
The struggle for civil and political rights ran into more serious opposition. Although the states of Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Iowa all approved black suffrage before the Fifteenth Amendment, Schwalm points out that the public in these states were ambivalent and even hostile to the notion of black suffrage. Access to public services, particularly schools, was even more problematic. School boards refused to admit black students, segregated them when they did, and otherwise humiliated them. Popular reaction could be even worse. One school in Iowa was torched after a black student enrolled (195).
There is, of course, nothing new about pointing out the racial hierarchies in law and society in the Midwest. Schwalm's greatest contribution to this scholarship is her consistent and persuasive engagement of gender. Blacks and whites alike repeatedly cast citizenship in masculine terms, and fraternal organizations codified the rites of manhood, membership, and citizenship. But beneath this layer of gendered discourse were the women themselves. They organized within their churches, petitioned legislatures, and formed their own private associations. When their children were denied entrance to public schools, mothers sued school boards. The postwar years saw a dramatic attack in these states on segregation, and women were among those in the vanguard.
This is a useful work of scholarship, especially in its layering of quantitative data with lived experience. Readers will learn how northern black communities were formed, defended themselves, and fought for their rights in the decades we normally associate with the reconstruction of Southern society. Readers will also be forced to confront the disjunction between memory and history. In a perceptive last chapter, Schwalm delves into blacks’ struggle to commemorate their central role in the Civil War. Against dominant narratives that romanticized the conflict by erasing black involvement and whitewashing the southern experience of slavery, blacks celebrated their emancipation by stressing their own civic duties and civil rights. But even such powerful acts in defiance of white supremacy were weighted by gendered discourse. At such celebrations, women were only tolerated as spectators, and male public speakers equated citizenship with manhood. Women were pushed yet again to the margins. Schwalm's book is a bid for a new narrative, one that recognizes both women's contributions and the masculine discourse that has masked them.
