Although Thomas Jefferson and James Madison generally agreed on political issues, they engaged in debates over constitutional change. Citing the principle that “the earth belongs in usufruct to the living,” Jefferson suggested that constitutions should change every generation or so, which he calculated would be about once every 19 years. By contrast, Madison emphasized the need for constitutional stability, in part because he thought this would increase reverence for the document.
John Dinan, who has authored several previous books, including The American State Constitutional Tradition(2006), and who writes the annual review of state constitutional development for The Book of the States, does not focus specifically on the Jefferson/Madison exchanges. Nonetheless, he effectively demonstrates that while Madison’s penchant for constitutional stability has prevailed at the national level, Jefferson’s vision has come to be more closely realized at the state level. Thus, whereas the U.S. Constitution has been in effect since 1789 and has only been formally amended 27 times, states “have drafted 144 constitutions since 1776,” and, as of the beginning of 2017, their constitutions “have been amended 7,586 times, an average of just over 150 amendments per state” (p. 23).
Courses on American constitutional law are typically organized around specific provisions of the Constitution (Article I, legislative powers; Article II, executive powers; Article III, judicial powers, etc.) and often around specific amendments, but the majority of the texts read in such classes typically consist of Supreme Court decisions interpreting the various provisions. By contrast, Dinan’s analysis suggests that much of state constitutional history can be traced by examining changes brought about through new constitutions or amendments. Amendments to the U.S. Constitution are proposed by two-thirds majorities of both houses of Congress, or (by the still unused Article V convention mechanism) called at the request of two-thirds of the state legislatures. Amendments are ratified by three-fourths of the state legislatures, or, as in the case of the Twenty-First Amendment repealing national alcoholic prohibition, by state conventions called for this purpose. As Dinan details, depending on the states, constitutional amendments may be introduced through legislative initiative (often requiring supermajorities and/or votes in more than one session), through conventions, through referenda, and through state conventions and commissions, and are often ratified through referenda. As a consequence, state amending processes are far less rigid than those at the national level, and as a result, the amending process has become almost a routine feature of state law. One can trace the history of most important developments in state law, and movements in the United States more generally, through detailing amendments that have been proposed and adopted.
In attempting to chronicle more than 12,000 amending proposals that have been introduced at the national level, I have in my own Encyclopedia of Constitutional Amendments, Proposed Amendments, and Amending Issues, 1789–2015 (2015) used an encyclopedic A to Z approach. Likely with a more practical view to classroom use (and this would be an excellent supplement to any main text in state and local government classes), Dinan has chosen a narrative approach to state amendments. He has, however, still managed to convey encyclopedic knowledge of the amending proposals that have been introduced, the historical currents that they have reflected, and the scholarly sources that have described and analyzed them. Although he focuses on state constitutional amendments, he constantly keeps the federal model in mind by way of comparison and contrast.
After detailing the amending processes within the states, Dinan devotes chapters to discussions of amendments dealing with institutions, rights, and policies. He then summarizes with a chapter that explores the consequences of relying upon amendments so extensively at the state level.
In Chapter 2, the author describes how states use what he calls “institutional-authority amendments.” States have used such amendments for a variety of purposes. These include the following: to clarify state–local relations on such issues as home rule and unfunded mandates; to establish regulatory commissions and regulatory agencies; to deal with budgeting; and to govern redistricting.
Chapters 3 and 4, respectively, detail what Dinan describes as “Right-Defining” and “Court-Responsive” amendments. Recognizing that state constitutions may, with respect to rights, be more expansive than their federal counterparts, states sometimes seek to expand, overturn, or contract the scope of state court decisions. Sometimes they preempt them. Dinan illustrates with issues as varied as the right to bear arms, the free exercise of religion, gay rights, victims’ rights, the rights of criminal defendants, and the rights to hunt and fish. Since many state judges and justices are elected, strategists must often weigh whether they are more likely to succeed in accomplishing their goals through amendments or through seeking to replace members of the judicial branch. In cases where courts have been silent, they may also simply seek statutory changes.
In Chapters 5, 6, and 7, respectively, Dinan examines what he calls “policy-constraining” amendments, “policy-authorizing” amendments, and “policy-enacting” amendments. Again the subjects are varied. They include lotteries, corporate charters, banking, internal improvements, taxation, debts, budgeting, worker-protection measures, social welfare policies, affirmative action, stem-cell research, animal welfare, English-language policies, right-to-work laws, political reforms, and regulations over alcohol, cigarettes, and marijuana.
Dinan devotes his final chapter to ascertaining the consequences of using amendments as such a prominent mechanism of state government. On the positive side, he argues that incorporating policies into constitutions often allows the people to bypass legislators who are unresponsive or self-interested, or who are too subject to the influence of special interests that might be inimical to public welfare. Citizens might also think that amendments, especially those that they have had a part in enacting, are more legitimate. Dinan argues that once incorporated into constitutions, however, amendments might make it more difficult to adjust policies and institutions. On other occasions, it might seem easier to seek to elect judges who are more responsive to popular will than to amend the constitution. For better or worse, constitutions that are too frequently amended might blur the line between fundamental law and statutory law. Although the author does not discuss the issue in detail, amending referenda may also be influenced by special interests.
I also think that Dinan might have engaged in deeper discussion of the degree to which the relative stability and supremacy of the U.S. Constitution opens up the possibility for greater social experimentation at the state level. If the federal constitution did not create a floor, would states be as confident in utilizing their own amending processes respecting rights and other issues?
Dinan’s book is a virtual cornucopia of ideas for constitutional change. It has numerous end notes, and it is well-indexed. Students reading the book as part of a course on state and local governments could easily check the index for issues relative to their own state or region.
My hope is that this book’s simultaneous release in cloth and paperback will both meet the needs of public and university libraries and encourage widespread course use. It seems unlikely that there will be another book of comparable scope and depth on the topic in the near future.
