Biographical reconstructions of historical figures are objects to be handled with care, and those of philosophers and scientists are no exception. That in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries a convinced hermetic magician like Giordano Bruno should be portrayed as a champion of freethinking and democracy is just one example of the goal-oriented nature of biographical narratives. In the history of science, Galileo's life is probably the best-known case of a biography that has been continuously reshaped in order to address issues that were immediately significant to the authors and their contemporaries. In this sense, Bertold Brecht's Galileo was very much a 1930s intellectual struggling with ideology and authority, while Paul Feyerabend's Galileo would not have looked out of place in 1960s Berkeley. The case of Isaac Newton is particularly interesting in this respect, as the transformations of his biography map very clearly onto changes in the status and understanding of scientific practice itself. However, his early transmutation into the emblem of modern science and the successful popularization of his heroic image seem to have contributed to veil, more than in other cases, the artefactual and contested dimensions of his biography. Already at the end of the seventeenth century, writing on the life of Galileo meant positioning oneself within the religion-and-science debate, and the partisan nature of these reconstructions was perceived even at the level of popular representations. Instead, in the case of Newton, the interpretative conflict emerged more slowly, especially during the first half of the nineteenth century; even then the debate remained confined to the academic community of Newton specialists.
In Recreating Newton, Rebekah Higgitt focuses precisely on the making of Newton's reputation in the early and mid-nineteenth century, turning it into an object of historical analysis, and an extremely significant one. Her book complements nicely the second volume of Newton's biographies edited by Higgitt and Rob Iliffe, which was devoted to nineteenth-century biographical materials, published and unpublished (Early Biographies of Isaac Newton 1660–1885, London, 2006). Now Higgitt investigates in more depth the contexts in which those biographies were constructed and deployed, paying particular attention to the different purposes that they could serve in Victorian culture. In this kind of analysis details are essential, and Higgitt does an excellent job of presenting the nuanced and sometimes contradictory strategies of the biographers. She pays particular attention to texts by Jean-Baptiste Biot, David Brewster (for a long time the leading authority on Newton's life), Francis Baily and Augustus De Morgan.
The case of Biot gives Higgitt the opportunity to discuss the romantic notion of scientific genius, contrasting it with that of science as a collective enterprise based on training and hard work. Although, interestingly, these positions seem to have coexisted in Biot's writings, they were usually deployed against each other to support opposite views of the human mind and of society itself. Biot's biography also illustrates the ways in which Newton's life could be mobilized in support of scientific theories and practices – in this case, the corpuscular theory of light and Continental calculus. Through Brewster's 1831 and 1855 biographies and his controversy with Bailey, Higgitt provides convincing evidence of how the hagiographic defence of Newton from perceived attacks against his reputation could serve various religious, political and moral purposes. It could also contribute to the debate on the future of science in Britain, and on the status of the emerging professional figure of the scientist. The religious positioning of those involved in these debates seems to be particularly relevant here, with reformist and radicals engaging in a process of demythologization that was a critique of the religious establishment and its long-lasting alliance with Oxbridge, best expressed by the British tradition of natural theology.
The book also deals explicitly with a number of related themes, such as the emergence, in the first half of the nineteenth century, of a new, scientific approach to historical sources, especially archival and manuscript. While the subversive use of philology had a long and illustrious tradition, the new impartiality and objectivity advocated by authors such as De Morgan clearly mirrored the new criteria for scientific objectivity that were being institutionalized in the first half of the century. In other words, the story of the new uses of archival materials to construct a supposedly impartial image of Newton cannot be torn apart from that of the contemporary emergence of a new notion of objectivity in the natural sciences. Another interesting historiographical point is discussed towards the end of the book, where Higgitt uses the famous case of Michel Chasles's forged letters to illustrate how, well into the second half of the nineteenth century, the public image of Newton had remained virtually unaffected by the specialist controversies about his character, morals and religious inclinations.
Higgitt has produced a well-researched and carefully crafted book which will be of interest to historians of science, literature, religion and Victorian culture. It is indeed a excellent example of the truly interdisciplinary nature of much current research in the history of science.
