The Great New Orleans Kidnapping Case offers a rich narrative of a fascinating case caught in the middle of Reconstruction politics and racial change. Drawing on the sensational newspaper history of the case, along with trial records and other legal documents, Ross writes an exciting detective mystery of the kidnapping of a child named Mollie Digby in 1870 New Orleans. Amidst the story of the manhunt, and the subsequent trial of two Afro-Creole women, Ross expertly explains the particular racial and political context of Reconstruction New Orleans. New Orleans had a unique racial context due to its Afro-Creole community and their history of at least some acceptance among the white population of the city. In 1870, during radical Reconstruction, the city was attempting to create a biracial government and police force. The sensational nature of the case caught the attention of the country, but it was also an important example of the workings of a Reconstruction Republican biracial city government.
Ross’ strengths lie in his narrative style and his ability to draw the reader in to the individual events and characters of the story while emphasizing their larger importance. In part, this is accomplished by incorporating the biographies of many of the key players, including Afro-Creole detective John Baptiste Jourdain, a Democrat ex-confederate District Attorney, and the two Afro-Creole defendants charged with the kidnapping. Such inclusion allows Ross to open his story to the events that created 1870 New Orleans and what happened to race relations in the city after Reconstruction ended.
Ross’ unique lens into the racial politics of New Orleans and the importance of Afro-Creoles is perhaps the most important addition to the historiography. Afro-Creoles were educated, bilingual members of French New Orleans society. While they did not have the same legal rights as whites, they were able to sue in court, send their children to private Catholic schools, and often partake in elite society. However, as Louisiana became more Americanized and the country feared abolition, the legal rights of Afro-Creoles deteriorated. Immediately after the Civil War ex-Confederates were serving in government and instituted Black Codes in Louisiana which eliminated any rights Afro-Creoles possessed before the Civil War. In 1866 New Orleans experienced a violent riot led by policemen who attacked a biracial constitutional convention, killing 34 black men and three whites. John Baptiste Jourdain, the detective in the Digby kidnapping case, testified before Congress about the riot and three months later Congress overrode President Johnson's vetoes to pass the Reconstruction Acts of 1867. It was these acts that instituted biracial government in New Orleans and Jourdain's testimony that emphasized the importance of a biracial police force. Jourdain asserted that an all white police force would never protect the lives and property of African Americans as they protected a whites. Against this backdrop the Mollie Digby case was a proving ground for whether a biracial police force could adequately investigate the kidnapping of a white child.
While Ross explores the multitude of racial issues surrounding the case, he does not employ the same rigorous analysis to the gendered implications of the case. How did the fact that the defendants were women as well as Afro-Creole affect the coverage of the case and the outcome of the trial? What was the importance that the crime was a kidnapping of a young child rather than a murder or a robbery? One of the defendants in the trial had a child with a white man and lived as his unofficial wife. Sexual relationships between white men and black women were particularly problematic for whites in the post-Civil War South hoping to hold onto a racially bifurcated society. Were these Afro-Creole women therefore more challenging to white society than if they had been black women married to black men? Although Ross mentions some of the gendered aspects to the case, a more in-depth analysis could have brought another important layer.
Despite this The Great New Orleans Kidnapping Case is an exciting and illuminating read about a complicated time and place in America's racial history. Ross’ attention to the details of his historic characters adds an important dimension to the story and draws our attention to the stakes of one criminal case to the future of biracial government during Reconstruction.
