No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 November 2004
The momentous changes in the international system that marked the end of the Cold War also had significant repercussions for Turkish foreign-policy. The new international context presented Turkey with an intricate web of challenges and opportunities, pushing it out of the comfort zone of the familiar foreign-policy parameters of the bipolar era. In Suits and Uniforms, Philip Robins successfully tackles the challenging task of presenting a sound and multi-dimensional analysis of the complex dynamics of Turkish foreign policy in a period of systemic transition.
The main argument of the book is that in the post–Cold War period, Turkey, which firmly maintained its Westward orientation and remained committed to a multilateral approach to regional conflicts, has been a status quo power in terms of both norms and conduct in an extremely volatile region.
Rather than a chronological or region-by-region approach, which is often the case with books on Turkish foreign policy, this book is organized thematically. The first of the study's three parts examines the general contours of Turkish foreign policy by identifying and analyzing its key processes and players. Robins presents the government, presidency, foreign ministry, and security establishment as the primary players in foreign-policy making and implementation. The interaction between civilian and military actors, as highlighted in the title “suits and uniforms,” is particularly emphasized. The study presents the Parliament, media, interest groups, ethnic pressure groups, and public opinion as complementary, yet secondary, players with a more limited impact.
In the second part of the book, Robins uses an interactive approach to integrate external and internal factors shaping foreign-policy decisions. The author successfully relates complex domestic factors to the formulation and execution of foreign policy. This section is further divided into subsections highlighting historical, ideological, security-related, and economic factors as the ideational (ideological and identity-related) and material determinants of foreign policy.
In the final part, the author zooms in on four case studies to provide a better understanding of the complex dynamics of Turkey's foreign affairs. These case studies include an assessment of Turkish–Israeli relations as the “embattled” alliance of the “new Middle East”; Turkey's relations with the Turkic republics as an indicator of the prevalence of self-interest rather than sentiment in shaping policy; an analysis of the dilemmas of Turkey's position concerning northern Iraq; and Turkey's multi-lateralist approach in the Bosnian crisis.
Robins, who is also the author of Turkey and the Middle East, is a well-known expert on Turkey's relations with its Middle Eastern neighbors. This strength is clearly revealed in the relevant parts of the book and the case studies related to the Middle East and Central Asia. The author acknowledges that he has deliberately avoided separate chapters on Turkey's relations with the European Union, Greece, and Cyprus, arguing that the existing publications on these topics are already in “inverse proportion to the substantive developments” concerning these areas during the period under discussion (p. 5). The absence of separate chapters, however, does not mean that these areas are neglected; there is coverage of these topics in some subsections, particularly on the international system, history, ideology, and economy.
Nevertheless, while Robins gives so much importance to the interaction of domestic and external factors in foreign-policy analysis, he has a very limited discussion of the post–Helsinki period, during which relations with the European Union served as a powerful “external anchor” for instigating and giving impetus to domestic reform in Turkey. Moreover, by excluding the impact of these drastic reforms on a number of previously taboo issues, including the abolishment of capital punishment, extending broadcasting and educational rights to the Kurdish minority, and the measures to curb the influence of military in politics, Robins runs into the danger of over-stressing the “normative gap” between Turkey and Europe and overlooking critical changes in Turkey in this regard.
Sometimes in analyzing contemporary events the time lag between the completion of the work and its publication makes an important difference. In this context, given the important foreign-policy implications of the domestic reform process to fulfill the Copenhagen criteria, the results of the November 2002 elections, and the critical developments of the Copenhagen summit, an epilogue or a postscript that would bring events up to date would have been particularly useful.
The book is based on an extensive survey of secondary published works, mainly in English. There is also limited reference to some works in Turkish and French, as well as to a number of contemporary primary sources. The BBC Summary of World Broadcasts and newspaper sources are also frequently used. In terms of the Turkish media, the author relies heavily on the Turkish Daily News and the Turkish Probe. The limited use of Turkish materials is the main shortcoming of the bibliography, but the author refers to numerous interviews with Turkish diplomats and policy-makers, senior officers, businessmen, journalists, and academics. There are also four useful maps in the beginning of the book and an exhaustive index at the end.
Suits and Uniforms is the product of meticulous research and penetrating analysis by one of the leading specialists on Turkish foreign policy. This book is a must for specialists on Turkish politics and foreign policy, as well as for the generalist international relations readership and the layman who is interested in having a compelling and comprehensive account of Turkey's foreign affairs.