In 1598, Elizabeth I's chief minister, William Cecil, Lord Burghley, died at Cecil House in Westminster. Shortly after Burghley's death, a former member of his household composed a biography of the great man. The work was known as the Anonymous Life of William Cecil, until Alan Smith convincingly attributed it to Michael Hickes. Hickes, the author, had been working for Cecil since 1573. In 1580, he became one of Burghley's secretaries.Footnote 1 He evidently liked and admired his master, and the biography was a tribute in memorandum. It was intended to demonstrate that Burghley had been everything a man in his position ought to be. Hickes paid tribute to Burghley's indisputably statesmanlike qualities. He saluted him as a ‘grave and wise councillor’ – indeed, ‘the wisest and gravest councillor of this age’.Footnote 2 Yet Hickes was careful to point out that ‘what business soever was in [Burghley's] head, it was never perceived at his table where he would be so merry as one would imagine he had nothing else to do’.Footnote 3 Burghley has often been cast (with justification) as the packhorse of Elizabethan government. He frequently reminded his correspondents that the best years of his life were ‘faythfully paynfully and dangerously spent’ in the service of his queen and country.Footnote 4 His phenomenal work ethic, and capacity to transact voluminous quantities of political business, never ceases to impress his biographers.Footnote 5 It is consequently difficult to envisage him behaving as if ‘he had nothing else to do’ but be merry.
Hickes, however, evidently felt that the capacity to simulate leisureliness was an important part of Burghley's public persona. Cicero identified this skill as an admirable attribute for a statesman. Setting the scene for his dialogue De oratore, he described how Lucius Crassus projected an aura of easy-going ‘geniality’ to guests at his villa, despite his concern about the terminal crisis enveloping the Roman republic.Footnote 6 Burghley's reverence for Cicero was well known, and Hickes may have intended to compliment his former master by depicting him as a model Ciceronian politician.Footnote 7 However, in the late sixteenth century, the art of studied relaxation was generally identified with Balthazar Castiglione's perfect courtier. Castiglione drew heavily on De oratore when composing Il libro del cortegiano (a dialogue set at the court of Urbino, in which the protagonists resolve ‘to shape in woordes a good Courtyer’).Footnote 8 Nonetheless, it would be a mistake to equate Ciceronian geniality with Castiglionean sprezzatura.Footnote 9 The former was a skill; the latter, a science.Footnote 10 The concept of sprezzatura was central to Castiglione's vision of ‘what in Court a Courtier ought be’.Footnote 11 One of the principal interlocutors in his dialogue, Ludovico Canossa, suggested that a courtier ‘ought to accompany all his doinges, gestures, demeaners, finally al his mocions with a grace, and this, me think, ye put for a sauce to euery thing, without the which all his other properties & good condicions were litle woorth’.Footnote 12 When pressed, Canossa elaborated:
But I, imagynyng with my self ofterntymes how this grace commeth, leaving a part such as have it from above, fynd one rule that is most general which in thys part (me thynk) taketh place in all thyngs belongyng to a man in worde or deede above all other. And that is to eschew as much as a man may, and as a sharp and dangerous rock, Affectation or curiosity and (to speak a new word) to use in every thing a certain Reckelessness, to cover art withal, and seeme whatsoever he doth and sayeth to do it wythout pain, and (as it were) not myndyng it.Footnote 13
Sprezzatura became inextricably associated both with Castiglione, and with Renaissance ideals of courtly conduct.Footnote 14
The Burghley who emerges from the pages of Hickes's Life thus possesses the signature characteristic of a Castiglionean courtier. Initially, we might be tempted to dismiss this as an inconsequential detail. Elizabeth's long-serving, long-suffering Lord Treasurer seems like an improbable disciple of il Cortegiano. For centuries, historians refused to acknowledge that he was, in fact, a courtier. They preferred to define him as a statesman. This epithet was applied to other politicians associated with the group that Winthrop Hudson named ‘the Cambridge connection’ (also known as the Athenian tribe).Footnote 15 However, an examination of contemporary sources suggests that courtly conduct literature significantly influenced the representation of men such as Burghley, Sir Francis Walsingham and Sir Walter Mildmay. In the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries, these politicians were recognised as models of Castiglionean civility.
The tradition of portraying the Athenians as statesmen not courtiers – and the assumption that the two roles should be differentiated – enjoys a long pedigree. In 1641, Robert Naunton published his Fragmenta Regalia, or, Observations on the Late Queen Elizabeth, her Times and Favorits. He divided the men at Elizabeth's court into three basic types: Togati; Martialists or Militiae; and courtiers. He distinguished courtiers (such as Sir Christopher Hatton) from Togati (such as Burghley and Walsingham). The latter were accredited with the gravitas of Roman senators. The former were dismissed as ‘meer vegetable[s] of the Court’.Footnote 16 The historiographical climate of the mid-twentieth century was conducive to such characterisations. Historians emphasised the bureaucratic features of Tudor government. Geoffrey Elton, in particular, portrayed the ‘statesmen of the age’ as ‘somewhat humdrum but very sound civil servant[s]’.Footnote 17 Elton acknowledged that such men were ‘no strangers to the Court’, but insisted that they were not ‘its creatures’ (or vegetables). His solution to the obstinate refusal of ‘statesmen’ and courtiers to differentiate themselves was to propose that court politics be stripped of all its cultural paraphernalia: ‘We need no more reveries on accession tilts and symbolism, no more pretty pictures of gallants and galliards; could we instead have painful studies of Acatry and Pantry, of vicechamberlains and ladies of the Privy Chamber?’Footnote 18 Such ‘painful studies’ would identify the real politicians who had (literally) been masquerading as courtiers.
Socio-economic historians also chronicled the rise of the ‘middling sort’ and the ‘new gentry’. These proto-bourgeois classes featured prominently in contemporary analyses of the British civil wars. The upheavals of the mid-seventeenth century were interpreted as a forceful demonstration of their agency.Footnote 19 R. H. Tawney traced the activism of the commercially minded nouveau riche back to the early Elizabethan era.Footnote 20 Lawrence Stone developed Tawney's hypothesis when he argued that a ‘crisis in the affairs of the hereditary elite, the aristocracy’ meant that ‘For a time this group lost its hold upon the nation, and thus allowed political and social initiative to fall into the hands of the squirearchy.’Footnote 21 Such theories suggested that ‘middling’ men had been playing an increasingly important part in public affairs for at least a century before the crisis of the Caroline regime.
The combined effect of Elton's bureaucratic emphasis and Tawney's neo-Marxist analysis was to generate considerable interest in a particular type of individual within the Tudor and Stuart political establishments. This was the self-made arriviste. His origins were non-aristocratic (he ‘sprung from that middle class from which the Tudors drew their best servants’).Footnote 22 He usually demonstrated his precocity at grammar school, and subsequently at Oxford or Cambridge. On leaving university, he was drafted into the service of an expanding state. Every stage of his career was marked by hard work, aspiration and achievement. Members of the Athenian tribe conformed rather nicely to this stock-type. The assumption that a courtier's role was essentially decorative impeded recognition of the possibility that the Athenians might have functioned in such a capacity.Footnote 23
Over recent decades, the courtier's stock has been reappraised. In 1985, David Starkey demonstrated the extent to which Henry VIII's personal attendants wielded genuine power within the English body politic.Footnote 24 Courtliness could no longer be dismissed as a purely recreational pastime for men of aptitude, and a serious pursuit for mediocrities only. The prizes available to proficient disciples were enticing enough to attract the most talented individuals. Moreover, Starkey argued that ability to court was not a luxury but a necessity for early modern ‘statesmen’:
to survive, the minister had to have the aptitudes of a courtier and the favourites had to have the skills of a politician and often the techniques of an administrator as well. For both, in fact, the goal they strove for was the same: influence, or, in the sixteenth century's own language, the favour of the prince.Footnote 25
He took issue with Elton's attempt to maintain ‘the distinction between courtier and councillor’, on the grounds that ‘Not only were courtiers and councillors pursuing (and achieving) similar goals and using similar methods, they were often the same person.’Footnote 26
The notion that some Elizabethan ministers were ‘mere’ politicians and bureaucrats has also been challenged as a result of new, interdisciplinary approaches to history and biography. It has been argued that the personae of Elizabeth's councillors were shaped, not merely by their political and social circumstances, but by the cultural influences to which they were exposed. Historians have analysed the personal and professional impact of their classically inspired education. Markku Peltonen highlighted the ubiquity of ‘the classical humanist vocabulary’ in Elizabethan political discourse.Footnote 27 Patrick Collinson drew attention to the ease with which humanistically schooled politicians adopted classical republican solutions to monarchical problems.Footnote 28 Collinson's concept of monarchical republicanism has not only generated invaluable insights into episodes such as the Bond of Association (1584); more generally, it has encouraged early modern historians to contextualise politics by seeking out the texts that shaped the mental worlds of policy makers. Yet the fact that it has loomed so large in Elizabethan historiography for the past two decades may help to explain why Castiglione's contribution to political discourse has attracted relatively little attention. Il libro del cortegiano is not a republican text. It presupposes a personal monarchy, and its primary concern is to explore the ways in which an individual can flourish and do good in that environment. Its eponymous hero is certainly no apparatchik. He plays an active part in public affairs; he offers counsel candidly; and he is ready, if necessary, to reprove his prince's errors and vices. Several interlocutors even argue that il Cortegiano is not bound to serve a tyrannical lord (although they do not discuss the possibility of active resistance).Footnote 29 None of this alters the fact that Castiglione's dialogue is essentially about personal monarchies – the opportunities they present and the challenges they pose.
Scholars such as David Starkey and Jennifer Richards have emphasised Castiglione's indebtedness to De oratore.Footnote 30 Il Cortegiano and the Ciceronian orator share an underlying agenda – to persuade those around them to act virtuously in the interest of the commonwealth – and Castiglione was undoubtedly inspired by Cicero.Footnote 31 Starkey suggested that Castiglione's great achievement lay in the fact that he ‘successfully transplanted Cicero from the forum to the Renaissance court’.Footnote 32 Yet he would scarcely have needed to reinvent Cicero's orator if the latter had proved fit for purpose in a courtly environment. The whole point of il Cortegiano is that he is not a republican orator, and can therefore exploit a political paradigm that disarms a Brutus or a Demosthenes.Footnote 33 He does not belong in a republic, monarchical or otherwise, and has consequently played a relatively peripheral part in many recent analyses of late sixteenth-century political culture. It is worth noting that literary scholars, who are perhaps less preoccupied with the concept of monarchical republicanism, have done far more than historians to highlight Castiglione's relevance to the Elizabethan political scene.Footnote 34
Cultural historians have argued that Elizabethan politicians did not only derive certain ideas and attitudes from the intellectual training they received during their formative years; they were also endowed with distinctive approaches to policy-making and self-presentation. Mary Crane has explored how the processes of gathering and framing (gathering knowledge or wisdom from a text or scenario, and framing it in a culturally and socially acceptable format), shaped the methodology and ideology of humanist councillors.Footnote 35 Stephen Alford has examined memoranda drafted by Cecil during the early years of his tenure as Elizabeth's secretary. Alford highlights the extent to which Cecil's thought processes and political tactics were influenced by the techniques of classical rhetoric – techniques that he could hardly have avoided internalising during the course of his studies.Footnote 36 Like the concept of monarchical republicanism, this rhetorical methodology appears irrelevant, if not inimical, to il Cortegiano. It deliberately illuminates the processes whereby decisions are made and desirable outcomes achieved. It requires the politician to show his working out – which is something il Cortegiano prefers not to do. Yet, as Quentin Skinner has demonstrated, the arts of courtliness and rhetoric were closely aligned in the minds of early modern commentators. Renaissance courtiers deployed rhetorical strategies to manipulate their audiences. This fact was widely acknowledged, not least by critics who doubted the capacity of some courtiers to use their powers of persuasion responsibly.Footnote 37 There was nothing inherently anti-Castiglionean about Burghley's overtly rhetorical approach to decision-making. Indeed, it can be regarded as a thoroughly courtier-like device to win the trust of his prince, by persuading her that he offered a balanced, reliable and well-informed perspective on the issues that confronted her.
Despite the insights of the past twenty-five years, we still find it difficult to conceptualise the Athenians as courtiers in anything other than a technical sense. The Elizabethan politicians whose courtliness we acknowledge are those who embraced athletic and chivalric ideals of courtly conduct. These include the earl of Leicester (Master of the Horse and Elizabeth's general in the Netherlands); the second earl of Essex (jouster, Master of the Horse, Master of the Ordnance and military commander); Philip Sidney (the Protestant war hero); and Christopher Hatton (an excellent dancer).Footnote 38 Elizabeth's gender surely affects our perception of who did, and not, count as a courtier during her reign. We assume that the primary role of the queen's male courtiers was to court her – in the lists, on the dance floor and through the medium of love poetry. This has focused our attention upon the men in her entourage who cast themselves as courtly lovers and chevaliers.
However, an overtly chivalric persona was by no means the only acceptable image for a Castiglionean courtier. Il libro del cortegiano delineates both civil and martial ideals of courtliness. As Sidney Anglo has observed, the Urbino Courtier resembles a cut-and-paste conglomeration of humanist truisms, and values associated with the feudal nobility.Footnote 39 Renaissance humanism and medieval chivalry are often deemed immiscible. The Pilgrimage of Grace (1536–7) and the Northern Rebellion (1569) have been interpreted as reactions by the socially conservative north of England against the ascendancy of educated, ambitious ‘new men’ in London.Footnote 40 The Essex revolt (1601) has been presented as the final whimper of an aristocratic cult of honour, rendered obsolete by a newer ‘synthesis’ of ‘humanistic wisdom’, reformed religion and law.Footnote 41 It is certainly valid to analyse these episodes (and other, less dramatic developments) in terms of a culture clash. Yet Castiglionean courtesy literature provided a platform upon which both cultures could be accommodated. It encouraged aspiring courtiers to cannibalise both value systems, appropriating attributes strategically and selectively.
The Urbino interlocutors discuss martial models of courtliness in Book I of Il libro del cortegiano. According to Canossa, the perfect courtier should aspire to ‘vnderstandyng in all exercises of the bodie, that belonge to a man of warre’, and skill ‘on those weapons that are vsed ordinarily emong gentlemen’. He should surpass representatives of all nations in martial sports:
And because it is the peculyer prayse of us Italians to ryde well, and to manage wyth reason, especiallye roughe horses, to runne at the rynge and at tylte, he shall bee in this amonge the beste Italyans. At tourneymente, in kepyng a passage, in fightinge at barriers, he shall be good emonge the best Frenchemen. At Joco di canne, runninge at Bull, castinge of spears and dartes, he shall be amonge the Spaniardes excellent.
Hunting is ‘one of the chiefest’ activities fit for a courtier, ‘for it hath a certaine lykenesse with warre’. Yet Canossa – one of the brightest stars of Duke Guidobaldo's glittering court – admits that he lacks expertise in various war-like exercises.Footnote 42 Federico Fregoso subsequently confirms that a courtier may specialise in non-military accomplishments:
I will haue our Courtier therfore, if he find himself excellent in anie thinge beeside armes, to sett out himselfe, and gete him estymatyon by it after an honest sorte, and be so dyscreete and of so good a iudgemente, that he maye haue the vnderstandinge after a comelye maner, and with good pourpose to allure men to heare or to looke on that he supposeth himselfe to be excellente in: making semblant alwaies to doe it, not for a bragge and to shewe it for vainglory, but at a chaunce, & rather praied by others, then commyng of his owne free will.Footnote 43
Fregoso's words effectively license politicians such as Burghley to develop a brand of courtiership that emphasises other skills and attributes ‘beeside armes’.
The Urbino interlocutors insist that knightly proficiency should be complemented by a comprehensive grounding ‘in those studyes, which they call Humanitie’. Canossa recommends just such a grounding for ‘oure Courtier’,
whom in letters I will haue to bee more then indyfferentlye well seene . . . and to haue not only the vnderstandinge of the Latin tunge, but also of the Greeke, because of the many and sundrye thinges that with greate excellencye are written in it. Let him much exercise hym selfe in poets, and no lesse in Oratours and Historiographers, and also in writinge bothe rime and prose, and especiallye in this our vulgar tunge.Footnote 44
It is worth noting that, whilst Castiglione's protagonists imply that a courtier need not master all the skills pertaining to soldiery, there is no suggestion that his learning can be, or appear, even slightly deficient. The scholarly prowess of the Athenians is, of course, beyond dispute.Footnote 45 If courtliness could be reduced to a checklist of essential accomplishments, Burghley and his Cambridge associates would clearly tick all of the academic boxes. Il Cortegiano's education is not restricted to book learning. ‘I am not pleased with the Courtyer’, observes Canossa, ‘if he be not also a musitien, and beside his vnderstanding and couning vpon the booke, haue skill in lyke maner on sundrye instruments.’ The count also endows his courtly paragon with ‘the cunning in drawyng, and the knowledge in the very arte of peincting’.Footnote 46
The Renaissance courtier could thus aspire to mastery of ‘civil’ or chivalric arts (or both). Castiglione reinvented the medieval knight as a Renaissance commonwealthsman, without entirely subsuming the former into the latter. His dialogue explored martial and humanist ideals of excellence, appealing to soldiers and scholars alike. His interlocutors’ project of describing the perfect courtier was undertaken in a genuine spirit of inquiry, and their ideas were sufficiently catholic to engage representatives of more than one culture. As a non-prescriptive, Ciceronian dialogue, Il libro del cortegiano does not seek to pit one code of conduct against another. Neither, in the final analysis, does it encourage the reader to endorse one particular modus vivendi and discount alternative options. It rather facilitates synthesis, suggesting that various skills and ideals can be yoked together in pursuit of a benevolent agenda.Footnote 47 It offered viable models of courtly conduct to a range of individuals and groups – including the Athenians.
Castiglione's dialogue was sufficiently open-ended to foster various styles of courtiership. However, all Castiglionean courtiers shared two crucial characteristics. First, all were committed to the ultimate ‘ende’ of a courtier, as defined by Ottaviano Fregoso:
The ende therfore of a perfect Courtier . . . I beleaue is to purchase him, by the meane of the qualities whiche these Lordes haue giuen him, in such wise the good will and fauour of the Prince he is in seruice withall, that he may breake his minde to him, and alwaies enfourme hym francklye of the trueth of euerie matter meete for him to vnderstande, without feare or perill to displease him.Footnote 48
The model courtier deploys his talents, not for selfish ends, but to encourage his prince to govern wisely and well. At first glance, this mission statement reads like a reiteration of the maxim that men must be willing ‘not so much to serue their owne turnes as their Prince and Countrey’.Footnote 49 Such exhortations were underpinned by Cicero's prolifically quoted injunction that ‘we be not borne for our selues alone: but somedeal of our birth our countrey, somedeal our parentes, somedeal our frendes do claime’.Footnote 50 Cicero, of course, failed to mention any obligation to princes. It is tempting to suppose that his sixteenth-century admirers were equally unconcerned with the responsibilities of a subject. Hence, when early modern authors invoke the duties owed to ‘prince-and-country’, we tend to assume that they are actually acknowledging a debt to the commonwealth. Yet Ottaviano explicitly states that (in temporal matters) a courtier should concentrate first and foremost upon serving his prince. Whilst the country will obviously benefit if the prince is nudged along the path of virtue, this strategy is undeniably monarchocentric.
Burghley's dedication to the common weal is often regarded as a quasi-republican trait. His attempts to force Elizabeth's hand over the issue of the succession, and his readiness to override her wishes concerning the fate of Mary Stuart, suggest a tendency to champion the interests of the country over the will of the queen, whenever the two seemed to diverge.Footnote 51 Yet Burghley defined his agenda in terms that are strikingly similar to those employed by Ottaviano. Towards the end of his life, in a letter to his son Robert, he wrote that
I do hold and will allwayse this course in such matters as I differ in opinion from hir Majesty as long as I may be allowed to gyve advise; I will not chang my opinion by affirmyng the Contrary for that war to offend God to whom I am sworn first, but as a servant I will obey hir Majesties commandment, and no wise contrary the same, presvming that she being Gods cheff minister hear it shall be Gods will to have hir commandments obeyed after that I have performed my dvtye as a Councillor and shall in my hart wish, hir Commandments to have such good successes, as I am sure she intendeth.Footnote 52
Burghley thus insisted that his role was to capitalise on the favour and trust that Elizabeth reposed in him by counselling her freely and frankly. He also affirmed that his devotion to Elizabeth overrode all other considerations, except the fear of God. Like il Cortegiano, he apparently believed that he could best serve his commonwealth by serving his prince. He endorsed Castiglione's equation of public service with disinterested royal service.
The second characteristic common to all Castiglionean courtiers was sprezzatura. The concept of sprezzatura is often regarded as quintessentially aristocratic, and antithetical to pains-taking humanists such as Burghley.Footnote 53 After all, it proclaims that a gentleman's talents are innate, not acquired; he is brilliant because he was born that way, and because it befits one of his status to be brilliant. The value of hard work and discipline, in which Burghley firmly believed, is implicitly discounted. Il Cortegiano is even advised not to aspire to anything other than a modest competence at chess, because everyone knows how much effort is required to become ‘couning at it’.Footnote 54 By contrast, as Mary Crane has observed, sixteenth-century humanist literature tended to emphasise the moral worth of diligent busyness, and the corrosive effects of idleness (‘What bringeth ruste to Iron smothe?’).Footnote 55 Crane also argues that ambitious English humanists of non-aristocratic origins sought to justify their participation in public affairs by identifying themselves and their aspirations with pre-validated, uncontentious truisms. Their conspicuous subscription to a ‘common culture’ was designed to allay fears that their values and ambitions were innovative, self-promoting, and would ultimately undermine the social order.Footnote 56 Crane regards individualism as the prerogative, or privilege, of the nobility.Footnote 57 A nobleman's social preeminence was uncontroversial, and his political activism was taken for granted. He was consequently placed under less pressure to authorise his exercise of power. According to this analysis of Tudor political culture, sprezzatura represented an unambiguous assertion of aristocratic identity. The ‘reckless’ courtier does not seek to explain himself through reference to the ‘common culture’; such explanation would demystify him. He prefers not to demonstrate how he has constructed himself. Instead, he assumes the persona of a conjurer, unveiling accomplishments as if they were scarves drawn from his sleeves, or rabbits pulled out of his hat. Sprezzatura accentuates his individualism by obscuring the cultural context of his actions and abilities – whereas the essence of humanist ‘framing’ is contextualisation.
Yet il Cortegiano arguably occupies a halfway house between the poles of ‘transcendent dilettantism’ and studious self-referencing.Footnote 58 The Urbino interlocutors agree that he should practise sprezzatura, but they also deconstruct the concept. Cesare Gonzaga acknowledges that some individuals are lucky enough to be born with a God-given capacity for nonchalant grace. However, on behalf of ‘such as of nature haue onely so much, that they be apte to beecome gratious in bestowinge labour, exercise, and diligence’, he ‘would faine knowe what art, with that learning, and by what meane they shall compasse this grace’.Footnote 59 To highlight the need for ‘labour, exercise, and diligence’ is, of course, to explode the mystique of sprezzatura entirely. Canossa, who is charged with revealing the tricks of the trade, suggests that ‘euen as the bee in the greene medowes fleeth alwayes aboute the grasse chousynge out flowres: so shall our Courtyer steale thys grace from them that to hys seming haue it, and from ech one that parcell that shal be most worthy praise’.Footnote 60 As Crane has observed, the metaphor of the bee flitting from flower to flower in a meadow, extracting the sweetest nectar from each bloom, was frequently deployed by humanist scholars to describe the process of ‘gathering’ wisdom to which one would subsequently frame oneself.Footnote 61 The key to sprezzatura, it would seem, is for il Cortegiano to ‘source’ his behaviour in precedents and examples. Moreover, the protagonists proceed to justify this ‘art that appeereth not to be art’, by citing other circumstances under which it has conventionally been practised. Canossa recalls having read ‘that there were some excellent Oratours, which among their other cares, enforced themselues to make euery man beleve that they had no sight in letters, and dissemblinge their conning, made semblant their orations to be made very simply, & rather as nature and trueth lead them, then study and arte’. De Medici adds that
This in like maner is verified [my italics] in musicke: where it is a verye greate vice to make two perfecte cordes, the one after the other, so that the verye sence of our hearing abhorreth it, and often times deliteth in a seconde, or in a seuen, which in it selfe is an vnpleasaunt discord and not tollerable: and this proceadeth because the continuance in the perfit tunes engendreth urksomenesse and betokeneth a to curious harmonye.
Canossa invokes ‘a proverbe emonge some most excellent poincters of old time, that To muche diligence is hurtfull’.Footnote 62 Sprezzatura is thus thoroughly contextualised. Castiglione addresses concerns about its morally subversive potential by highlighting its cultural ubiquity and well-established antecedents. His treatment of the concept exemplifies the humanist techniques of ‘gathering’ and ‘framing’; and his repeated warnings about how hard il Cortegiano must work to sustain the illusion of aristocratic dilettantism are couched in the humanist vocabulary of diligence, endeavour and pains-taking. As Sidney Anglo perceptively remarks, ‘amateurism is stressed throughout Il Cortegiano to such an extent that, in the end, it creates a profession of itself’.Footnote 63
Returning to the issue of Burghley's deceptively carefree demeanour at the dinner table, it is worth noting that Hickes was not the only early modern biographer to identify the Lord Treasurer as a skilful practitioner of sprezzatura. John Clapham made the same point in his Certain Observations concerning the Life and Reign of Queen Elizabeth. Clapham, like Hickes, was a long-term member of Burghley's establishment: ‘a great part of my time, even from my tender age, I spent in his house and about seven years in attendance upon his own person’.Footnote 64 Like Hickes, he made no secret of his regard for Burghley (‘It is a hard matter for a man strongly possessed with affections . . . to retain a true measure in speaking or writing’).Footnote 65 Having prepared his readers for a flattering portrait, Clapham praised the easy sprezzatura of Burghley's manners: ‘surely to him that had seen his behavior only at his table, with what pleasant, familiar and ordinary talk he passed the time, Cecil might have seemed a man free from all care and business’.Footnote 66 The historian William Camden, a Cecilian protégé, also commended his mentor for eschewing verbal ‘Affectation or curiosity’. Camden described the Lord Treasurer's speech as ‘fluent and elegant . . . not affected, but plaine and easie’.Footnote 67 Such comments are not confined to posthumous character sketches of Burghley. In the opening years of Elizabeth's reign, Roger Ascham observed that his friend, then ‘M. Secretarie’ Cecil, ‘hath this accustomed maner, though his head be neuer so full of most weightie affaires of the Realme, yet, at diner time he doth seeme to lay them alwaies aside: and findeth euer fitte occasion to taulke pleasantlie of other matters’.Footnote 68 Hickes, Clapham, Camden and Ascham were all close associates and admirers of Burghley. It is telling that all of them credited him with a courtier-like capacity ‘to cover art . . . and seeme whatsoever he doth and sayeth to do it wythout pain, and (as it were) not minding it’.
Social versatility was an essential component of sprezzatura. The nonchalant courtier was required to appear at ease with all sorts of companions, in various scenarios and situations.Footnote 69 The Urbino interlocutors suggested that a courtier should learn ‘To frame himself to the company’ – in other words, to modify his conduct according to the character and tastes of those around him.Footnote 70 The ability to read, and adapt to, the temperament of his prince was obviously an invaluable political asset.Footnote 71 However, he was also expected to interact successfully with a wide range of constituencies. Philibert de Vienne's Philosopher of the Court referred to ‘a certayne framing and agreeing in all our actions, to the pleasing of the worlde’ habitually practised by competent courtiers.Footnote 72 Prefatory verses published with the Covrt of Ciuill Courtesie promised that the handbook would show a young gentleman ‘at all assays how he himselfe shall frame’ to best effect.Footnote 73 Giovanni della Casa's courtesy manual, Galateo, instructed the reader ‘to frame and order thy doings . . . to please those with whom thou lyuest’.Footnote 74
According to Hickes, Burghley possessed all the skills of a courtly chameleon. He was a highly adaptable raconteur:
His ordinary speeches were commonly cheerful, merry, and familiar, but witty, sharp, and pithy, without dullness or sourness. And whatsoever company he came into, either old, young, men or women, great or mean, he could talk aptly and delightfully, and withal so merrily as was much pleasing to all hearers, and yet not without gravity nor unfit for a great councillor.Footnote 75
Compare this with Canossa's description of il Cortegiano's social versatility: ‘Likewise in company with menne and women of all degrees, in sportinge in laughyng, and in iestynge he hath in hym a certayne sweetenesse, and so comely demeanours, that whoso speaketh with hym or yet beholdeth him, muste nedes beare him an affection for ever.’Footnote 76 This passage from Thomas Hoby's translation of Il libro del cortegiano reminded Gabriel Harvey of Sir Thomas More – another model of ‘civil’ courtliness.Footnote 77
Hickes, Clapham and Ascham cast Burghley as an expert practitioner of sprezzatura. They also deconstructed his care-free demeanour. Like the Urbino interlocutors, they highlighted both the façade of easy nonchalance, and the prodigious effort that lay behind it. Their pointed references to the ‘business’, ‘care’ and ‘weightie affaires’ that Burghley successfully concealed might seem to contravene the ethos of sprezzatura – until we appreciate that sprezzatura was, in fact, a clever synthesis of insouciance and industry. Its fusion of aristocratic and humanist ideals reflected Castiglione's integrative agenda.
This agenda validated Burghley's own political style. Throughout his career, the Lord Treasurer experimented with the cross-fertilisation of patrician and professional modes of expression. As architectural historians have recognised, his great houses of Burghley and Theobalds reflected this magpie approach to self-fashioning. He transformed both buildings from relatively simple manor houses into palaces fit for his queen.Footnote 78 Conspicuous construction was a preoccupation (disapproving contemporaries called it a vice) of the early modern socio-political elite.Footnote 79 Great houses testified to the wealth, status, taste and familial identity of their owners. The instincts that they gratified – display and dynastic ambition – were hardwired into the aristocratic psyche. Burghley's lavish building projects can thus be construed as traditionally aristocratic enterprises, undertaken by a parvenu peer determined to create a convincingly ‘noble’ identity. This was certainly the view of those who claimed ‘in a rash and malicious mockry that England is become Regnum Cecilianum’.Footnote 80 Jill Husselby has demonstrated that the inner courtyard of Burghley House was designed to impress newly arrived guests with its nonchalant magnificence.Footnote 81 James Sutton cites the Middle Court of Theobalds as a similar example of ‘architectural sprezzatura’.Footnote 82 At Burghley House, the iconography associated with the Order of the Garter reminded visitors that the Lord Treasurer was a fully initiated member of the chivalric elite. The genealogies displayed at Theobalds attested that Burghley was just as interested in lineage, and his own dynastic heritage, as any member of the ancient nobility. A gallery of ancestral portraits conveyed the same message.Footnote 83
However, the Cecilian portraits did not simply advertise Burghley's affinity with the old aristocracy. Baron Waldstein, who visited Theobalds in 1600, recorded that the portraits were supplemented by ‘an account of the notable acts of each [Cecil] under different reigns’.Footnote 84 Burghley thus constructed a genealogy of diligent service. The idea that nobility could be earned as well as inherited is discussed in Book I of Il libro del cortegiano. Of course, Castiglione was not the only sixteenth-century author to address this issue. The humanist thesis that ‘a righte gentleman is sooner séene by the tryall of his vertue then blasing of his armes’ was surely one of the most widely debated propositions of the early modern era.Footnote 85 As Felicity Heal and Clive Holmes have pointed out, most social commentators brokered a compromise between the competing claims of lineage and merit. They argued that noble birth was highly conducive to greatness, but that it needed to be substantiated by virtue and wisdom to realise its true potential.Footnote 86 The Urbino interlocutors appear to favour this Aristotelean mean.Footnote 87 Canossa initially asserts that he ‘wyll haue this our Courtyer therfore to be a Gentleman borne & of a good house’. Pallavicino contends that ‘this noblenesse of birthe is not so necessarie for the Courtyer’. He seems to anticipate a degree of conservative scepticism: ‘And if I wiste that any of you thought it a straunge or newe matter, I would alledge vnto you sondrye, who for all they were borne of most noble bloude, yet haue they been heaped full of vyces: And contrarywise, many vnnoble that haue made famous their posteritie.’ However, illustrious ancestry is presented as a facilitator, rather than a guarantee, of worthiness. Canossa highlights the usefulness of pedigree as an incentive, or admonition, to virtue:
For noblenesse of birth (is as it were) a clere lampe that sheweth forth and bringeth into light, workes both good and badde, and enflameth and prouoketh vnto vertue, as wel with the feare of slaunder, as also with the hope of praise . . . the noble of birthe counte it a shame not to arriue at the leaste at the boundes of their predecessours set foorth vnto them.
He also advises that a well-born courtier will find it easier to establish himself socially and politically:
For where there are two in noble mans house which at the first haue geuen no proofe of themselues with woorkes good or bad, assoone as it is knowen that the one is a gentleman borne, and the other not, the vnnoble shall be muche lesse estemed with euerye manne, then the gentleman, and he muste with much trauaile and long time imprint in mennes heades a good op[i]nion of himselfe, which the other shal geat in a moment, and onely for that he is a gentleman.Footnote 88
The arguments in favour of lineage are thus pragmatic, and implicitly acknowledge the supremacy of virtue.Footnote 89
The Urbino interlocutors contribute nothing particularly original or startling to the debate about the nature of true nobility. Nonetheless, il Cortegiano represents a carefully calibrated amalgam of hereditary and desert-based constructs of nobility. In the portrait gallery at Theobalds, Burghley effected a similar amalgamation. He used an aristocratic device (the illustration of ancestry) to associate himself and his forebears with the humanist ideal of virtuous endeavour. He transformed the Cecils’ history of service into a pedigree. The concept of a service aristocracy appealed to other associates and off-shoots of the Athenian tribe – including Burghley's nephew, Francis Bacon. In 1580, whilst still a nineteen-year-old student at Gray's Inn, Bacon was apparently persuaded that Elizabeth had immediate plans for his advancement. He wrote to Burghley, thanking his uncle for the ‘comfortable relation of her Majesty's gracious opinion and meaning towards me’:
It must be an exceeding comfort and encouragement to me, setting forth and putting myself in way towards her Majesty's service, to encounter with an example so private and domestical of her Majesty's gracious goodness and benignity; being made good and verified in my father so far forth as it extendeth to his posterity, accepting them as commended by his service, during the non-age, as I may term it, of their own deserts.
He added that he would be
well content that I take least part of either his abilities of mind or of his worldly advancements . . . yet in the loyal and earnest affection which he bare to her Majesty's service, I trust my portion shall not be with the least, nor in proportion with my youngest birth. For methinks his precedent should be a silent charge upon his blessing unto us in all our degrees, to follow him afar off, and to dedicate unto her Majesty's service both the use and spending of our lives.Footnote 90
Bacon was not a scion of the old aristocracy; by default, his claim to office rested solely on humanist ideals about the elevated function of able and conscientious commonwealthsmen. Yet his letter to Burghley suggests that he regarded this claim as hereditary. His sense of entitlement, like that of a nobleman, derived from his assumption that he would automatically be given the opportunity to serve his queen and country as his father had done. He did not merely cite the achievements of Sir Nicholas Bacon as a ‘precedent’ that he was bound to emulate. He used the specific vocabulary of dynastic transmission, describing the appetite and aptitude for worthy employment as his ‘portion’. The ancestral portraits at Theobalds no doubt reminded Burghley's second son and political heir, Robert Cecil, that service was also his portion. Burghley's expectations for his son, like Bacon's hopes of preferment, were based upon a genuine fusion of lineal and meritocratic definitions of nobility. Il Cortegiano embodied this fusion – and so, ostentatiously, did Burghley.
Theobalds and Burghley House also displayed their owner's scholarly credentials. As Stephen Alford observes, the Great Gallery at Theobalds was ‘something like an instruction manual for classical and contemporary history’.Footnote 91 Waldstein noted that it contained
coloured portraits of the Roman Emperors from Julius Caesar to Domitian, busts of the 12 Caesars sculpted in some special material, a terrestrial globe which is 12 spans in circumference, pictures of some of the Knights-Commander of the Golden Fleece, and also of the following Kings: Richard III, Henry IV, Edward IV, Henry V, VI, VII. On the opposite wall are portraits of Don John of Austria, the Duke of Parma, Count d'Egmont, the Admiral of France, the Prince of Conde, and the Duke of Saxony; in addition there are views of a number of important cities.Footnote 92
The artefacts were gathered and framed to highlight Burghley's encyclopaedic knowledge base and cultural savoir-faire. They emphasised the fact that the lordly designer of Theobalds was more than a wealthy magnifico; he was also a conscientiously educated and well-informed politician. He conformed to the Urbinese ideal of a humanist courtier.
It is generally recognised that ‘chivalric’ courtiers could, and did, subscribe to the image of the serious and scholarly royal acolyte.Footnote 93 It is less frequently acknowledged that humanist politicians could adopt aristocratic modes of behaviour, if the occasion demanded it. As English ambassador in Paris, Francis Walsingham knew how to behave like a seigneur (when his finances permitted).Footnote 94 In 1571, for example, he rode into the French capital with Lord Buckhurst and the earl of Rutland, accompanied by a well-turned-out retinue of stout compatriots.Footnote 95 This is a practice that the archetypal countryman, Vincent, identifies as characteristic of the old-fashioned, landed nobility and gentry in the dialogue Of Cyuile and Vncyuile Life (‘our seruingmen . . . follow vs in the streetes, when wee bee at London, or any other great Towne’).Footnote 96 Thomas Nelson's epitaph to Walsingham presents the secretary as a munificent practitioner of traditional hospitality and charity. Walsingham ‘pittied euery strangers sute that came vnto his gate’; he ‘did good to rich and poore that came vnto [his] gate’; and he was ‘the comfort of the poore, that to them almes did giue’.Footnote 97 It is noteworthy that Nelson describes suitors and paupers congregating at Walsingham's gate, instead of fighting their way through the mêlée at court. It may be no more than a figure of speech, but it implies an aristocratic paradigm for virtuous conduct.
Mary Crane has argued that sobriety of dress distinguished humanist councillors from aristocratic courtiers, noting that Cecil was ‘famous for his plain dress and would have made a clear visual contrast to the leaders of the opposing factions of courtiers (Leicester, Hatton, Essex)’.Footnote 98 According to Crane's analysis, a George Clifford, third earl of Cumberland (resplendent in his azure jousting armour) self-consciously projected himself as a courtier, whereas a Francis Walsingham (simply attired in black) deliberately disavowed the cult of courtliness.Footnote 99 In Book II of the Il libro del cortegiano, however, Federico Fregoso argues that the appearance of a royal acolyte should ‘bee rather somewhat graue and auncient, then garishe. Therefore me thinke a blacke coulour hath a better grace in garmentes then any other, and though not throughly blacke, yet somwhat darke.’ He concedes that ‘vpon armour it is more meet to haue sightly and meery coulours, and also garmentes for pleasure, cut, pompous and riche. Likewise in open showes about triumphes, games, maskeries, and suche other matters, because so appointed there is in them a certein liuelinesse and mirth.’ Generally, however, he ‘coulde wishe they should declare the solemnitie that the Spanyshe nation muche obserueth’.Footnote 100 This visual ‘solemnitie’ reinforced il Cortegiano's ‘sober, & circumspecte’ demeanour.Footnote 101 It was an image to which many Tudor courtiers aspired. Referring to Holbein's portrait of a sombrely clad Anthony Denny (one of the chief gentlemen of Henry VIII's Privy Chamber), W. A. Sessions observed that ‘Although this early courtly model of Puritan humanism appears to lack Burgundian chivalry or Castiglione's sprezzatura . . . he certainly possesses the gravitas Castiglione in the first book of the Courtier requires.’Footnote 102 Sessions is right to detect shades of il Cortegiano in Denny's grave and studiously unpretentious image. In fact, the suggestion that Denny does not evince sprezzatura can be challenged. Well-cut and coloured black clothes did not flaunt themselves in the eye of the beholder, but they were expensive.Footnote 103 They were thus ideally suited to create the impression of unostentatious but authentic elegance.
Since the 1980s, it has generally been acknowledged that the distinction between courtiers and councillors is rather artificial. However, this insight has presented us with a new problem. The political style of a Leicester or a Hatton appears very different to that of a Burghley or a Walsingham. Hence, although we accept that they were all, in some sense, courtiers, it seems impossible to treat them as a single, homogeneous group. We overcome this obstacle by persuading ourselves that Leicester and Hatton were courtly, whereas Burghley and Walsingham were not. Leicester and Hatton embodied the cultural ideal of the courtier, whereas Burghley and Walsingham were simply skilled practitioners of court politics. Instead of discriminating between ‘courtly’ courtiers and their professionally competent counterparts (which essentially resurrects the old courtier/councillor division), we should recognise that there were different models of courtliness. Some Elizabethan courtiers favoured the traditional knightly paradigm, whilst others subscribed to more modern, humanistic and ‘civil’ codes of conduct. These models were intended to complement each other, and could easily be interchanged or integrated. In Il libro del cortegiano, neither is accorded precedence. The courtliness of the Athenians was just as valid and authentic as that of their more flamboyant colleagues. To paraphrase Patrick Collinson, they were statesmen who happened also to be cortegiani; or vice versa.Footnote 104
Collinson's concept of monarchical republicanism has arguably distracted attention from the fact that it was imperative for leading Elizabethan politicians to develop successful strategies for interacting with the queen on a personal basis. Elizabeth's councillors were able to envisage England without a monarch, to the extent that they planned for an emergency interregnum in the event of the queen's assassination. Yet they never forgot that their political influence depended on their access to, and management of, their royal mistress. In 1586, when Elizabeth blamed Burghley for engineering the execution of Mary Stuart, the temporarily disgraced Lord Treasurer acknowledged that he was politically impotent whilst ‘barred’ from the royal entourage. Pleading for rehabilitation, he wrote to Elizabeth: ‘I know not what manner of speche wordes to direct . . . to your Majesty.’Footnote 105 The deletion of the word ‘speche’ is significant; the problem was precisely that Burghley could not speak to the queen, or engage with her face-to-face. Such engagement was crucial to the brand of politics he practised. He flourished in the intimate, supremely monarchical milieu of the court. Moreover, throughout his career, he defined himself through reference to his personal relationship with the queen. He was her servant first and foremost, saving only the honour of God.Footnote 106 His emphasis on individual service to a particular prince is more reminiscent of Il libro del cortegiano than De oratore. He was the creature of a personal monarchy – a model Renaissance courtier.
